News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Yet Another Sign Up (Why Isn't Open ID More Popular By Now?) by dredmorbius on Tuesday June 26, 2012 @05:17PM (#4164179)
And why wouldn't I prefer to have a set of fully independent, unlinked accounts at different sites?

If I understand correctly, using OpenID means that Site A can confirm that User X is the same as User X on Site B, using OpenID?

I can see where that's a win for sites A & B. I can also see many instances where that is not a win for me.

Re:Yet Another Sign Up (Why Isn't Open ID More Popular By Now?) by goodside on Tuesday June 26, 2012 @05:35PM (#4164283)
If you use the same e-mail address to sign up for both sites, they can already determine this. The only way to get the anonymity you want is to create new throwaway accounts for each service. (I realize GMail lets you do things like + aliases, but these should be stripped when trying to match up users across databases.)
Re:Yet Another Sign Up (Why Isn't Open ID More Popular By Now?) by zpk on Tuesday June 26, 2012 @06:08PM (#4164419)
So let them, let them have to do that work and share email addresses, which would potentially be a PR nightmare if discovered, and users did not consent. I'd rather do that than willingly give multiple domains my ID letting one service unify them, and share my ID across multiple sits if the service chooses to. And who's to say people don't already use multiple email addresses?
Re:Yet Another Sign Up (Why Isn't Open ID More Popular By Now?) by earl on Tuesday June 26, 2012 @05:54PM (#4164371)
Or run your own mailserver and hand out email addresses like servicename @ [yourmailserver].com

Everything gets forwarded to the same inbox.

tuffmail.com is awesome and cheap; I'm a happy subscriber.

Re:Yet Another Sign Up (Why Isn't Open ID More Popular By Now?) by StavrosK on Tuesday June 26, 2012 @06:13PM (#4164446)
I like 33mail.com.
Re:Yet Another Sign Up (Why Isn't Open ID More Popular By Now?) by scoot on Tuesday June 26, 2012 @06:39PM (#4164540)
or 33m.co for those quick to type throwaways.
Re:Yet Another Sign Up (Why Isn't Open ID More Popular By Now?) by StavrosK on Tuesday June 26, 2012 @06:42PM (#4164554)
That works? That's awesome, thanks!
Re:Yet Another Sign Up (Why Isn't Open ID More Popular By Now?) by gatordan on Tuesday June 26, 2012 @06:57PM (#4164616)
Exactly. This reminds me of facebook and every site with "login with facebook" implemented. For example, I choose not to log into hulu with facebook because I'm sure its great for facebook to know what bad shows I watch to serve me better ads. But i don't need all of my friends and family seeing that information on their news feed. I believe Spotify forces this on their users and as a result i get the joy of seeing every song my friends listen to on Spotify.
Re:Yet Another Sign Up (Why Isn't Open ID More Popular By Now?) by razwall on Tuesday June 26, 2012 @06:11PM (#4164433)
That depends on the OP's implementation. Google, for instance, will return two different identifiers when the same user logs in to two different sites.

Of course, in reality, both sites will request your email address, so they can figure it out anyway.

Re:Yet Another Sign Up (Why Isn't Open ID More Popular By Now?) by fmystic on Tuesday June 26, 2012 @05:37PM (#4164291)
That would only be true if both OpenID consumers published their user's endpoints
Re:Yet Another Sign Up (Why Isn't Open ID More Popular By Now?) by drivebyacct2 on Tuesday June 26, 2012 @05:45PM (#4164328)
How is this different than correlating user names or email addresses? Especially given that most of the OpenIds out in the wild are specifically keyed off of email addresses anyway.
Re:Yet Another Sign Up (Why Isn't Open ID More Popular By Now?) by dredmorbius on Tuesday June 26, 2012 @06:26PM (#4164497)
Who says I use the same user names or email addresses (particularly when making a concerted effort to divide my identities).
Re:Yet Another Sign Up (Why Isn't Open ID More Popular By Now?) by drivebyacct2 on Tuesday June 26, 2012 @07:10PM (#4164657)
... Then you would have OpenIDs for those email accounts. Or you could just as trivially make throw away subdomains to use as OpenIDs with free providers. (There are several DNS providers with hundreds of free second-level domains that you can make as many subdomains as you like for free in 45 seconds.

Between this and your comments on G+, you seem really interested in villianizing your service providers when there are obvious ways to avoid their naive account associations [1], as you even take advantage of.

[1] I say naive because I would be willing to be a large amount of money that I could track you between accounts unless you're taking some insane precautions against it, even without an email address or OpenID url.

Re:Yet Another Sign Up (Why Isn't Open ID More Popular By Now?) by dredmorbius on Tuesday June 26, 2012 @08:32PM (#4164919)
I suspect you could, or an entity with sufficient motivation could.

For casual purposes, which encompasses much of my present threat model, the measures I'm taking should be reasonably sufficient.

The point I and others are making is that:

0. There's a growing default assumption that individuals have no privacy, that privacy is dead, and that we should all just roll over and forget about it.

1. Even if you trust your service provider today, you may not trust them tomorrow.

2. Even if you trust your service provider, you may not trust those who have access to your data through your service provider. Intentionally or otherwise.

I'm well aware that roughly 32 bits of leaked information should be sufficient to identify me, if not precisely, then with reasonable accuracy. This doesn't mean I'm going to hand over my SSN and DOB to anyone who asks.

It may also be the case that I'm deliberately trying to create various associated identities.

That said: if you're interested in trying to link this identity to others, you can GMail me any of your prospective linkings.