News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Caroline Ellison sentenced to 2 years in prison by shmatt on Tuesday September 24, 2024 @05:57PM (#41641383)
So all diddy needs to do is get on the stand and describe every single party of his and he’ll get a slap on the wrist?

While there should be more incentives to cooperate, like the type of prison, allowed visits, etc. claiming someone should serve less time because they described so much of their own crimes is kind of silly

Re:Caroline Ellison sentenced to 2 years in prison by AlbertCory on Tuesday September 24, 2024 @06:42PM (#41641751)
In the real world, a prosecutor can only nail a higher-up with the cooperation of the people lower down. Those people only cooperate if they get a lighter sentence. It's too bad, but that's how it is and it plays out every day in criminal courts.

As for Diddy: a real, disinterested DOJ would say, "oh, you can testify against <people more famous than you>? Well, we might be able to cut you a deal."

Of course, if the DOJ is not interested in prosecuting those people, then no deal. If they think Diddy is already important enough and they can't let him slide, then no deal, or at least, a medium-stiff sentence.

Finally, two years in prison is not a picnic. See if you want to do it.

Re:Caroline Ellison sentenced to 2 years in prison by csallen on Tuesday September 24, 2024 @07:27PM (#41642081)
> Finally, two years in prison is not a picnic. See if you want to do it.

Seriously. I'm shocked how cavalier people are about the lengths of prison sentences. Two years in prison is a LOOONNNNGG time.

I was once detained for an hour in a small room at a border. Being deprived of my freedom, my phone, and any comfort, was fairly devastating.

Re:Caroline Ellison sentenced to 2 years in prison by sneak on Tuesday September 24, 2024 @07:40PM (#41642159)
Two years is very short in the US for serious crimes. The US has more people in prison per capita than any other developed country by a wide, wide, wide margin, largely in part because of the judicial system's willingness to hand down sentences for relatively minor crimes that would be seen as insane in most other countries.

For what she was charged with, two years is probably the bare minimum that was available at sentencing given the constraint of "must serve jail time".

Meanwhile in Germany, the sentence range for human trafficking is 6 months to a max of 5 years. Stealing a child is also max 5 years (if you're not intending to sell it).

The contrast is pretty stark.

Re:Caroline Ellison sentenced to 2 years in prison by beaglesss on Tuesday September 24, 2024 @08:06PM (#41642305)
Basically every free person in the US can get a 26,000 lb truck or a semi auto rifle in under an hour.

Germany has taken the other approach and implemented policies to make their country closer to a prison with all kind of harsher regulations, then reducing prison time.

There are merits to be found in either approach.

Re:Caroline Ellison sentenced to 2 years in prison by s1artibartfast on Tuesday September 24, 2024 @09:33PM (#41642763)
genuinely interesting thought. I haven't decided if it carries any water, but interesting.

Why would harsher penalties be required in a place where individuals have more capability to do harm? That seems to place a lot of faith in a linear efficacy of deterrence

Re:Caroline Ellison sentenced to 2 years in prison by eurleif on Tuesday September 24, 2024 @09:34PM (#41642775)
Incapacitation.
Re:Caroline Ellison sentenced to 2 years in prison by magic_man on Tuesday September 24, 2024 @09:25PM (#41642721)
After she comes out she can write a book maybe sell movie right etc and she will be ok. Look at Anna Delvey or Jordan Belfort. Maybe she hid some crypto.
Re:Caroline Ellison sentenced to 2 years in prison by borroka on Tuesday September 24, 2024 @07:20PM (#41642042)
But a lighter sentence could, for example, range from no jail time to rates of less than 100 percent of the expected sentence in the case of non-cooperation. The prosecutor's recommendation of no jail time is frankly disappointing. She may not have been the main offender, but she committed the crimes. What would her sentence have been if she did not cooperate (and suppose other did or there was enough evidence anyway)? Fifteen+ years? Two years is not a picnic, but given the alternative, it looks like it is.
Re:Caroline Ellison sentenced to 2 years in prison by djur on Tuesday September 24, 2024 @07:28PM (#41642090)
The prosecutor didn't recommend no jail time. Ellison's lawyers did.

Also, in addition to jail time, she's going to owe a huge sum of money. The feds are going to have a claim on any money she makes for the rest of her life.

For better or worse (I think a little of both), long max sentences exist in the US criminal justice system to allow rewarding cooperators and to threaten non-cooperators alike.

Re:Caroline Ellison sentenced to 2 years in prison by voxic11 on Tuesday September 24, 2024 @07:23PM (#41642050)
> Prosecutors did not recommend a specific sentence for Ms. Ellison

It was her lawyers that asked for no jail time. Not the prosecutors.

Re:Caroline Ellison sentenced to 2 years in prison by borroka on Tuesday September 24, 2024 @07:35PM (#41642127)
According to the article I read (CNBC), "The prison term was significantly stiffer than the recommendation by the federal Probation Department that Judge Lewis Kaplan sentence Ellison, who had run the hedge fund Alameda Research, to three years of supervised release, with no time at all behind bars". In the same article, "Assistant U.S. Attorney Danielle Sassoon urged Kaplan for leniency".

It seems to me, as prosecutors and Probation Dept talk to each other, that all, except Kaplan, agreed on no prison time for Ellison.

Re:Caroline Ellison sentenced to 2 years in prison by AlbertCory on Tuesday September 24, 2024 @07:30PM (#41642104)
> The prosecutor's recommendation of no jail time is frankly disappointing

It could have been disingenuous. Maybe they knew the judge wouldn't go for it.

As for her not cooperating: would you rather SBF skate free?

I don't know what the case against SBF would have looked like without her, and I suspect you don't, either.

Re:Caroline Ellison sentenced to 2 years in prison by borroka on Tuesday September 24, 2024 @07:41PM (#41642165)
You suspect well, I do not. Let me ask you another question for which you and I do not know the answer. Since she got 2 years in prison, she was not promised (i.e. she did not sign any binding agreement with the prosecutor, beyond "we will do our best to get you a lenient sentence") not to go to prison. Why then not a sentence of 5, 10, 15 years in prison?
Re:Caroline Ellison sentenced to 2 years in prison by AlbertCory on Tuesday September 24, 2024 @08:00PM (#41642272)
I don't know how that all plays out, to be perfectly honest.
Re:Caroline Ellison sentenced to 2 years in prison by s1artibartfast on Tuesday September 24, 2024 @09:36PM (#41642790)
Why not just nail her to the wall after the fact? Is integrity of the prosecutor a valid answer?
Re:Caroline Ellison sentenced to 2 years in prison by AlbertCory on Tuesday September 24, 2024 @09:41PM (#41642828)
In almost any profession, your word is all you have. Welsh on someone, and no one will trust you anymore.
Re:Caroline Ellison sentenced to 2 years in prison by borroka on Wednesday September 25, 2024 @02:32AM (#41644304)
I did not say or believe that the prosecutor lied or they should renege on their word, far from it. I said that if she got two years, it means that the agreement Ellison-DA was not for no prison time in exchange for cooperation.

Thus I asked why two years and not five or ten of whatever time under the expected sentence time in case of no cooperation.

Re:Caroline Ellison sentenced to 2 years in prison by s1artibartfast on Wednesday September 25, 2024 @02:58AM (#41644461)
The prosecutor doesn't pick a time, and cant promise it. The judge selects the sentence. This judge thought 2 years was reasonable after the fact, and was not bound to it.
Re:Caroline Ellison sentenced to 2 years in prison by AlbertCory on Wednesday September 25, 2024 @02:03PM (#41650119)
Read who I was replying to (which was not you). They said,

"Is integrity of the prosecutor a valid answer?"

Yes it is.

Re:Caroline Ellison sentenced to 2 years in prison by miki123211 on Tuesday September 24, 2024 @06:25PM (#41641615)
She didn't just describe her own crimes, although I'm sure that played a part.

She also described somebody else's crimes, and did that in a way which helped the government with sentencing the "real villain."

Re:Caroline Ellison sentenced to 2 years in prison by rexreed on Tuesday September 24, 2024 @06:11PM (#41641508)
You only get a reduced sentence if you cooperate in the prosecution against someone else the government / prosecutor is just as or more interested in. That wouldn't be the case with the diddle.
Re:Caroline Ellison sentenced to 2 years in prison by mandevil on Tuesday September 24, 2024 @09:32PM (#41642758)
Not technically true. Even without a formal plea, you can enter a plea of guilty and throw yourself on the mercy of the court. Showing remorse and admitting your crimes definitely makes judges like you more!
Re:Caroline Ellison sentenced to 2 years in prison by stackghost on Tuesday September 24, 2024 @07:02PM (#41641916)
>So all diddy needs to do is get on the stand and describe every single party of his and he’ll get a slap on the wrist?

Do you honestly think this is how the legal system works?

Re:Caroline Ellison sentenced to 2 years in prison by pessimizer on Tuesday September 24, 2024 @06:13PM (#41641523)
We want to bribe criminals to betray each other. The people who they are betraying could do anything up to killing them to prevent this, and we have to compete with that.

The world gets zero benefit to imprisoning this woman indefinitely, it in fact costs money, and if the government had to prove their case against her without her cooperation, it would just cost even more money. Not letting a fully-cooperating sucker like her off is the opposite of a deterrent to crime. It's telling low-level people who are involved in crimes that it's better to keep quiet. We want to encourage them to betray. I hope when she gets out she becomes a celebrity, and it encourages other young people to decide to whistleblow or turn snitch on the scammy companies they work for.

Re:Caroline Ellison sentenced to 2 years in prison by vkou on Tuesday September 24, 2024 @08:04PM (#41642292)
> The world gets zero benefit to imprisoning this woman indefinitely

What sorts of people does the world benefit from imprisoning indefinitely, and where on the spectrum does, say, being a serial and unrepentant shoplifter, stealing mid-four figures sums compare to being a financial criminal stealing mid-eight-figure sums?

She wasn't a 'low level whistleblower', she was one step below the ringleader, and only came clean after the whole thing went tits up and she was staring down two decades in federal.

If you're looking for heroes and whistleblowers, I don't think there were any in that whole organization. Just rats turning on eachother once the trap snapped shut around them.

Re:Caroline Ellison sentenced to 2 years in prison by s1artibartfast on Tuesday September 24, 2024 @09:40PM (#41642818)
I think a serial shoplifter or thief is worse. It is a bigger problem for me personally, and impacts far more people. Therefore I think it deserves harsher penalties.
Re:Caroline Ellison sentenced to 2 years in prison by vkou on Tuesday September 24, 2024 @10:57PM (#41643277)
A thief will steal from a few stores. A fraudster of that magnitude steals from anywhere between thousands to millions of people.
Re:Caroline Ellison sentenced to 2 years in prison by s1artibartfast on Wednesday September 25, 2024 @02:16AM (#41644210)
There is the magnitude of an individual and the magnitude of the summer for each problem.
Re:Caroline Ellison sentenced to 2 years in prison by xwowsersx on Tuesday September 24, 2024 @07:15PM (#41642007)
No, because when prosecutors offer a light sentence to a secondary criminal in a conspiracy, it's usually a strategic decision to secure cooperation in prosecuting the main target. It wouldn't make sense that a lighter sentence for an accomplice/secondary sets a precedent for a principal actor and Diddy is the principal actor in his case, AFAIK.

(I'm not agreeing or disagreeing with any of this, just saying this is the internally consistent approach.)