Re:The TSA's Dumb Air-Security Rules Are Not Based on Science
by freehunter on Tuesday June 26, 2012 @02:58PM
(#4163585)
I do know of an AT&T tower in my state that is malfunctioning (by my standards) and refuses to release the connection once my phone had established the connection. When I'm driving down the freeway past the tower, my signal strength will get weaker and weaker and then I run into no service, even in great service areas. I have to pull the battery (my iPhone toting friends/family have to power down the phone) before it will recognize it's moved to another tower.
Obviously it's a different circumstance, but it's another point of data where cell towers aren't always 100% functional when the target is moving.
Re:The TSA's Dumb Air-Security Rules Are Not Based on Science
by mikeash on Tuesday June 26, 2012 @03:20PM
(#4163678)
The supposed issue isn't movement, it's that cell towers assume a limited signal range due to terrain, which is no longer true once you're in an airplane and high enough to have a horizon of dozens of miles.
Edit: by the way, have you reported the problem to AT&T? I have no idea how responsive they are, but it seems like it could be worthwhile, especially if it's as easy to reproduce the problem as you make it sound.
I fly small planes for fun and sometimes use my phone in the air to check weather. The biggest problem is that it doesn't work above about 5,000ft because the signal gets too weak. I never bother to turn my phone off, and neither do most of my pilot friends. I spent about fifteen minutes flying a plane with an instructor friend once while he chatted on the phone with his wife about when we was going to get home!