Wouldn't it be 50 since the half-life is an interval?
What I was saying is in reference to this study I read long ago, which suggests a modal life span of about 72 years of age in the paleolithic: https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/j.1728-4457.2007...
Neither would a world with 88 people with the following death schedule.
| Age | Deaths/Year |
|---------+-------------|
| 0 to 5 | 2 |
| 5 to 70 | 1 |
| 70 | 3 |
I'm sure that the 3 people who make it to 70 are very happy they are
in the highest mode of the distribution. The 85 who did not may have
something to say about how meaningful using the mode of a distribution
is.Deeper than that, I think there is a modern tendency to want to believe false claims about how awful life was in the past, and how much better we have it now… so there are a large number of such myths that are nearly ubiquitous but not accurate. Not to say that many aren’t also accurate, just that the inaccurate ones go largely unquestioned.
Modern times are very different from most of human history- better in many ways and worse in many others. If we romanticize how perfect the present is, we then lose the ability to make things still better.
I literally proved by demonstration why having a distribution with an absolute mode in the extreme most value means that 97% of people still died younger than that. There is nothing wrong with the assumption that basically no one made it to 70 because less than 0.5% of people actually did for any period where we have records.
>Deeper than that, I think there is a modern tendency to want to believe false claims about how awful life was in the past, and how much better we have it now… so there are a large number of such myths that are nearly ubiquitous but not accurate. Not to say that many aren’t also accurate, just that the inaccurate ones go largely unquestioned.
Again, you're wronger than the people who hold that view. I'm not sure what you're arguing against at this point other than sophistry.
What I am saying is important to me because I’m interested specifically in what health and life were like for those few people that made it to old age in ancient times - to see how it might provide ideas to improve our health today. For example, I have found that I need a huge amount of exercise and natural light or else I feel fatigued and depressed… I felt I “should not” need this, until I realized not getting this is some sort of anomaly in human history- and there is no reason to expect everyone to be able to handle low levels of light and activity.
Reading about “evolutionary medicine” theorizing was so fascinating it led me to get my doctorate and become an academic PI, although my research is not really in that area these days, I still find it interesting and useful as a hypothesis generator and not "anti science" as another person on here accused me of.
The replies to my original comment are basically mostly people making this same category of mistake and arguing which is "correct" - the average or the mode of the same distribution. Unfortunately, I chose a really bad example where people already hold strong almost religious or political opinions, rather than something generic that just illustrates the math.
Oldest age is set 80, mode is set to 75. We start by distribution one percentage point to each age. Then add an extra to the mode and all the remaining to zero.
We now have a distribution where the most common age of death, other than zero be in 70-80, and more than half the population die before they reach 40.
The growth in life expectancy from surviving early childhood makes sense, but the decline in life expectancy for crossing 20 feels too sharp.
This is even wronger than what you critique.
For every period in history that we have good data for people had a half-life - a period in which you'd expect half of all people to die: https://batintheattic.blogspot.com/2011/07/medieval-populati...
For example in medieval Germany it looked something like:
It's called a population pyramid not a population column for a reason.The exact age varies by location, but even if we ignore everyone under 10, half of all people left would still die before they are 40.