News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Dropbox blocks API access for Boxopus over piracy concerns by res0nat0r on Tuesday June 26, 2012 @12:59PM (#4162909)
> it is their duty to take the proper moral stand. Otherwise they are clearly just part of the problem.

They are taking a moral stand. Their stance is they don't want to get involved with software which they believe is primarily going to be use for piracy. Their company, their decision.

Re:Dropbox blocks API access for Boxopus over piracy concerns by wissler on Tuesday June 26, 2012 @01:56PM (#4163234)
Their behavior is unprincipled with respect to their customers. It is immoral. "Their company, their decision" is not a moral argument.
Re:Dropbox blocks API access for Boxopus over piracy concerns by rprasad on Tuesday June 26, 2012 @04:35PM (#4163971)
Gonzo Producer: Hey pizza guy, I want to use your pizza store to film a porno. It's completly legal!

Pizza Guy: No, I have legitimate customers here! You'll drive family customers away!

Gonzo Producer: You're behaving immorally! It's not illegal for me to film a porno, so you're morally bound to let me film in your restaurant, even if it will cause substantial economic damage to your business! You're oppressing my freedom of speech!

Forgive my language, but do you see how stupid your argument is?

Re:Dropbox blocks API access for Boxopus over piracy concerns by wissler on Tuesday June 26, 2012 @05:26PM (#4164238)
Your argument is nonsense. You presume that the torrent feature implies something unsavory, akin to porn, when it's merely a means of copying from point A to point B efficiently.

"Forgive my language, but do you see how stupid your argument is?"

Actually you're embarrassing yourself, compounding your first foolish remark with this escalation.

Re:Dropbox blocks API access for Boxopus over piracy concerns by res0nat0r on Tuesday June 26, 2012 @06:14PM (#4164448)
> You presume that the torrent feature implies something unsavory

The beauty of this is that it is well within Dropbox's rights to determine what they deem savory and unsavory for their business, not you...

Re:Dropbox blocks API access for Boxopus over piracy concerns by wissler on Tuesday June 26, 2012 @06:39PM (#4164542)
What a bizarre thing to say. No one has disputed Dropbox's legal rights here.

The question at issue is whether they are morally upstanding to make this decision or not. And guess what? It's my prerogative to state what I think on that topic, not yours, not Dropbox's.

Re:Dropbox blocks API access for Boxopus over piracy concerns by chii on Wednesday June 27, 2012 @12:35AM (#4165530)
"The question at issue is whether they are morally upstanding to make this decision or not."

A business does not operate in a "moral" way, unlike a human would. No matter how much you personify a business. They would want the public to perceieve them as being moral, but they are doing that for only one reason - PR, which to some coroprations, are intimately tied to their bottom line.

I have no doubt moral behaviour is a consequence of it being a good way to increase the bottomline, and is not a goal in of itself. The free documentary film "The Corporation" outlines this quite well, and worth watching.

Re:Dropbox blocks API access for Boxopus over piracy concerns by Dylan16807 on Wednesday June 27, 2012 @02:48AM (#4165866)
I think if you did a poll you'd find people on either side of "is it moral to do good deeds motivated by recognition". Also, businesses may be largely sociopathic, but not completely.
Re:Dropbox blocks API access for Boxopus over piracy concerns by res0nat0r on Tuesday June 26, 2012 @07:02PM (#4164632)
I guess the only thing left is...build your own alternative to Dropbox?