News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:London saw a surprising benefit to ultra-low emissions zo... by soomerons on Monday September 23, 2024 @08:48AM (#41625476)
I would not quote the dutch design as a success, in fact it's the opposite. Yes people and kids rides bikes, however, they ALSO have the highest road density in Europe for cars :

https://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/web/products-eurostat-news/-/d...

And are in the top 10 of highest co2 emissions in europe

https://www.iea.org/regions/europe/emissions

Then the pigheadedness of dutch cyclists not wearing helmets makes up for a lot of deaths

https://etsc.eu/dutch-road-safety-thrown-back-in-time-15-yea...

Yes, some of the cycling paths are separated from car traffic, but the vast majority of the cycling lanes are not. It's just a painted line, that combined with often times, very narrow roads, and a growing population (highest density of people in europe), cyclists gets knocked of the bikes.

And then let's not even get into a discussion about how dutch cyclists don't follow traffic rules at all.

If anything, the dutch have a cycling problem.

Re:London saw a surprising benefit to ultra-low emissions zo... by Vinnl on Monday September 23, 2024 @10:28AM (#41626515)
Your source for helmets making up lots of deaths is talking about a recent increase in deaths, even though the lack of helmets has been a thing for decades.

It's not the lack of helmets by itself that's a problem; it's the combination with high-speed electric bicycles, and their primarily being used by the elderly, that is causing deaths.

Yes, old people falling and sustaining heavy injuries that they wouldn't have had with a helmet is a problem, but not one that (I think) can be solved by street design.

If you see that in 2018, the Netherlands had 4.7 deaths per billion vehicle kms, vs. the US's 6.9, and then consider that it's a very densely populated country where lots of traffic intersects, then I would count that as a big success.

Re:London saw a surprising benefit to ultra-low emissions zo... by mdrzn on Monday September 23, 2024 @09:02AM (#41625609)
This comment is a great example on how to "lie" with statistics. Saying they are in the "top 10 of highest co2 emissions in Europe" (they are 9th) is such bad faith without explaining that they are also the 9th most populated country in Europe.
Re:London saw a surprising benefit to ultra-low emissions zo... by soomerons on Monday September 23, 2024 @09:05AM (#41625639)
9th is still top 10, correct?

9th most populated country in Europe is by no means a good thing

Re:London saw a surprising benefit to ultra-low emissions zo... by aqme28 on Monday September 23, 2024 @09:28AM (#41625876)
> 9th most populated country in Europe is by no means a good thing

Please explain this. So you're saying that the Netherlands should be a smaller country?

Re:London saw a surprising benefit to ultra-low emissions zo... by eporomaa on Monday September 23, 2024 @08:58AM (#41625577)
>If anything, the dutch have a cycling problem.

I disagree, I don't see how less cycling or more cars would be better?

> ...ALSO have the highest road density in Europe for cars

It is the densest non-micro state in the world, would that not explain the road density?

You cannot protect a cyclist in a car collision using a helmet, the solution is separate infra?

Other than that you have positive outcomes of increased general health.

Re:London saw a surprising benefit to ultra-low emissions zo... by soomerons on Monday September 23, 2024 @09:03AM (#41625622)
off course you can. And it's been proven over and over. Are you really trying to argue that wearing a helmet is not safer than not wearing one?

Not all car and cyclist collisions are high speed, big impacts, in fact, statistically speaking, most of them in the netherlands are slow speed knocks, cyclist, get bumped, when a car tries to squeeze by, and the cyclist falls and hits their head on the concrete or whatever else is close by.

And then there are all the cyclist against cyclist collisions, someone gets knocked off, and smacks their head against the curb.

But I guess the dutch way of saying "we are dutch and are born on a bicycle and know how to cycle", (and they really actually don't), is easier to say than, looking at the actual stats, and seeing they are wrong.

Re:London saw a surprising benefit to ultra-low emissions zo... by aqme28 on Monday September 23, 2024 @09:32AM (#41625906)
What stats are you referring to? The Netherlands has one of the lowest per-km cyclist fatality rates in the world, at least with 2009 numbers[1]. Would be interested to see if that has changed.

[1]: https://blogs-images.forbes.com/niallmccarthy/files/2015/02/...

They also have decently good numbers for traffic fatalities in general: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_traffic-r...

Re:London saw a surprising benefit to ultra-low emissions zo... by Vinnl on Monday September 23, 2024 @02:43PM (#41629252)
(Some extra nuance: it is of course true that, ceteris paribus, wearing helmets is strictly safer. It's just that the Dutch stats show that proper infrastructure is even more important, and cyclists are less of a danger to other traffic participants than people in cars, which is why there's no stronger push for making people wear helmets — it might cause them to stop cycling. At an individual level, for sure, wear helmets, but as a society, there are better things to focus on when it comes to traffic safety.)

I don't actually know how strong the evidence is for that.