It's very possible that early exposure is beneficial. It makes sense to me. However, that does not explain why peanut allergies are so much higher now than a century ago. The under-diagnosis hypothesis does not make sense either, since the reactions are so severe.
Something is leading to exploding allergies. I can list other hypotheses, at least as strong, including:
- Travel and genetics (we co-evolve to local environments; the US is mostly immigrant)
- Parasites / hygiene hypothesis
- Environmental changes / new industrial-age pollutants
And, of course, there are things we don't know about and combination effects.
Footnote: Peanuts are native to South America. When the Spanish came, or they were introduced to Europe, we didn't see mass anaphylaxis either, at least as far as I know.
What do you think about the possibility that this is similar to rates of other diseases "rising", where really it may be an artifact of access to new populations?
There are also striking geographic differences in allergy rates as well between the US and less developed countries (even within genetically identical populations).
Anecdotally, I also know a bunch of people who developed allergies (not peanut / treenut, but seasonal) a few years after they moved to the US.
It looks like there's something environmental going on. I just don't know what yet.
I have no problem believing that severe allergies weren't all being undiagnosed in the past, but we are way too quick to believe studies that match priors, even if there's evidence that the intervention's effects are, at best overblown.
Science is hard, life sciences doubly so. We need to be far more comfortable with wide error bars than we are.
This 2024 Australian program[2] for introducing babies to peanuts early is inspired by this 2022 US report[3] about a 22% remission rate in babies who were introduced to peanut powder compared to 2% who received the placebo.
1. https://www.mcri.edu.au/news-stories/decrease-peanut-allergy...
2. https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/article/2024/aug/...
3. https://www.nih.gov/news-events/nih-research-matters/oral-im...
there's got to be a market for someone to create a new journal that only accepts/publishes research that has been independently reproduced at least a few times and has an actually meaningful peer review process and standards. It could serve as a repository for research that we can actually put some measure of faith in because right now companies can just pay for research with whatever results they want to see in a headline, and there's basically no accountability for scientists that put out garbage research.
Everyone seems to agree that "publish or perish" is a problem, but as long as people are forced to constantly put something out there it'd be nice to see more effort put into validating/invalidating prior research. It'd be better than just adding to the pile of never-replicated garbage that nobody can trust but everyone goes on to cite anyway.
I doubt it. All the incentives for all parties are in the exact opposite direction:
- A journal gains readership based on how many studies it can publish. If it barely publishes any, no one will buy it. Would you buy a magazine that didn't publish anything?
- The doctors and their backers in turn wouldn't give a shit if they got declined by this theoretical journal. They get declined all the time for far less legitimate reasons, most of the time submitting to as many journals as they can, since they will be declined by the majority.
- The journal itself if it's too choosy and lacks the existing brand recognition is incentivized to publish anything it can, which is why most startup journals are even worse than the existing (bad) ones.
The Replication crisis is real, and can be avoided if more effort is put in not to discover something new, but instead to verifying the old information we base new questions/studies on.
I'm not. There are a large contingent of people on here who scream socialism/communism anytime you suggest the government do anything, even when it's demonstrably addressing an existing crisis that's skullfucking our society.
They'll probably downvote this one too because they really don't like when people point out their "objective" and "rational" thinking is neither of those things.
(They also might be thinking that "regulations around reporting" pose a substantial free speech issue.)
At least with a public entity, you should be able to publicly audit what's happening, and with public funding to answer to, the public's interests and the proposed entity's financial security are aligned properly.
in an ideal world...
One would also counter that regulations regarding the accuracy of speech existed in 1987 and were by most accounts, pretty effective at keeping news informative and balanced, as opposed to after those regulations were retired and we got politics being covered like sports and the political divide becoming larger and larger as time goes on because making people angry and scared of the Other is pretty profitable, while getting them balanced, informed coverage is both more expensive and not as appealing to the consumer.
We keep getting these articles based on 2 peanut studies that specifically only included Jewish children from Israel and England, the ones in Israel had the peanuts early, and the ones in England did not. One study being under 100 children, and one over 1000. Based on these studies Australia changed their recommendations and the number of people introducing their children to peanuts before the age of 1 went from 26% to 85% by 2018. This had _no_ effect on allergy rates to peanuts. They still remain the same.
As an aside, my wife is allergic to peanuts, we have no peanuts in our house, and our kids didn't try peanuts until after the age of 7. None of them have peanut allergies.