Our public school system has failed. Full stop.
my wife, who is perfectly capable of basic math, would never have been able to do this task, nor would she have wanted to, and in the past she was exploited by financial advisers seeking to do it for her.
I have no doubt that some people with weak/average math skills can do this, mostly because the math skills have nothing to do with it, really. Confidence about how to invest and manage your life savings is an entirely different thing, and since we don't teach people anything about this, many, many people do not have it.
Social security for example only works because it's mandatory. I think having some percent of your check go into index funds automatically would work too.
There's nothing especially magical about 401ks. Yes, many companies match contributions up to some level. And there are some tax benefits but it's mostly about saving for retirement. It's not like defined benefit plans were anything like universal in the US--mostly big companies for employees with relatively long tenures.
I agree that SS by itself isn't really enough to live on for most people. But that's also just about what I get from my defined benefit pension--albeit for just about a third of my career. A nice bonus but just that.
The financial markets are vastly complicated. If you have exposure simply to arithmetic and not how it is applied to financial instruments, you are ill equipped.
Better to teach the basic financial instruments (Checking accounts, fees, overdraft, Credit Cards, Home Mortgages, Retirement accounts, bond and index funds, and simple allocation), and just the math necessary to understand the fundamentals. You can go a lot farther I think with the 3 R's and a solid home economics class than even things like Algebra, or higher math.
And, if nothing else, teach these people that if your employer matches, fund AT least that much. That's just free money, and you can't get a better return on your money out of the gate than that unless you're lucky at the sports book (ill-advised...).
Vanguard should be publishing ready to go lesson plans for this and giving them gratis to every high school in the nation.
'My plan would work, if it wasn't for that fact it involved human beings' actually just means your plan doesn't work.
It amounts to teaching kids how to be free vs. being trapped in debt. The mentality that money is not to be spent but to be invested and leveraged. All this shit is over the head of anyone trying to teach in our school system. They are just riding out the misery to get their pension.
Unlikely, based on the data.
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41488940 (citations from a previous comment I wrote)