News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Freicoin: bitcoin-like currency from the Occupy movement by mindslight on Monday June 25, 2012 @02:05PM (#4157711)
Economically, this is utterly backwards. To those without access to the cheat-code of newly created money, USD basically is a demurrage currency through inflation. In any environment where currency loses value, those with the most assets (your "1%") can best manage their investing to avoid losing value, while the people with modest amounts of savings get screwed either directly by inflation or through encouraged patronizing of the fraudulent consumer-financial industry. "Hoarding" assets by the middle class is what gives people the freedom to turn down specific jobs and hence puts them in a much better bargaining position for favorable working terms. If you want to even the wealth distribution, you have to empower the middle and lower classes to become financially self-sufficient, not simply try to attack the upper class.
Re:Freicoin: bitcoin-like currency from the Occupy movement by maaku on Monday June 25, 2012 @02:29PM (#4157890)
Inflation hurts the poor and middle-class more than it does the wealthy, for the very reasons you mention: the rich have tools to mitigate it.

What I'm more concerned about here is making sure that under all circumstances credit is available to those who need it, interest rates are low, and money continues to flow through the economy at a predictable and at least minimum rate.

This is not an attack on the upper class, nor am I trying to redistribute wealth. In fact I'm explicitly trying to avoid that--some of the other #occupy currencies that have been floated in the past amount to little more than progressive asset taxes, the very idea of which I am categorically against. Rather, I want to create a fixed and unchangeable monetary policy which would keep the economy moving in good times and bad.

Re:Freicoin: bitcoin-like currency from the Occupy movement by mindslight on Monday June 25, 2012 @03:01PM (#4158093)
The designed incentives are set up to trade in freicoin, and immediately cash out into something else. Clearly there's got to be an opposing force that turns "immediately" into a variable length of time (maybe transaction fee versus liquidity projection). The changing of this time period based on economic conditions is going to make your monetary flow unpredictable. In fact, it seems that in "down" times when people are looking to spend less, they'll want less freicoins, causing the value to drop with positive feedback.

Presently, banks can loan out ten times the money they've obtained, so any asset-based system is going to be a step back for easy credit (which imho is a good thing). Availability of credit and low interest rates have more to do with the risk of default (assuming a sound money supply). As such, if you want to improve the availability of credit, you should work on improved tracking of people/collateral (which imho is a bad thing).

Fundamentally I think you're looking at this from the wrong perspective. Improving people's ability to live paycheck to paycheck is only further perpetuating the system where most people are at the mercy of the economy.

Re:Freicoin: bitcoin-like currency from the Occupy movement by WiseWeasel on Monday June 25, 2012 @03:25PM (#4158221)
The steps the wealthy take to mitigate inflation are what drive a large portion of our economy. Investing in stocks, bonds, angel and venture funds, etc. puts their money to use for the economy, allowing an entrepreneur to get funding for her start-up, so companies have more money to pay employees, so local and national governments can invest in infrastructure and services, and so a rich guy loses his shirt on some stupid or unlucky bets and joins the lower classes. Inflation, to a point, is a very strong incentive against hoarding cash, and provides much of the social mobility in our economy.
Re:Freicoin: bitcoin-like currency from the Occupy movement by Aloisius on Monday June 25, 2012 @02:30PM (#4157899)
those with the most assets (your "1%") can best manage their investing to avoid losing value, while the people with modest amounts of savings get screwed either directly by inflation or through encouraged patronizing of the fraudulent consumer-financial industry

Is there some reason why those with modest savings can't buy treasury bills? TIPS will match inflation and other treasury notes will often perform better. And you can buy them directly from the US government bypassing the "fraudulent consumer-financial industry" altogether.

Re:Freicoin: bitcoin-like currency from the Occupy movement by jcarreiro on Monday June 25, 2012 @02:38PM (#4157951)
Treasuries are not liquid assets for the average consumer -- they are held to maturity. This means that those with "modest" savings can't afford to own them, because of the liquidity risk.

edit: s/TIPS/Treasuries

Re:Freicoin: bitcoin-like currency from the Occupy movement by hollerith on Monday June 25, 2012 @04:29PM (#4158583)
Are you sure about that? There is no market in these Treasuries where they can be sold before the date of maturity?
Re:Freicoin: bitcoin-like currency from the Occupy movement by mindslight on Monday June 25, 2012 @02:40PM (#4157959)
If "other treasury notes will perform better", then by definition, TIPS isn't keeping up with actual inflation. Keeping up with the treasury's definition of inflation doesn't mean your savings isn't losing value.
Re:Freicoin: bitcoin-like currency from the Occupy movement by Aloisius on Monday June 25, 2012 @03:14PM (#4158160)
Can you explain that a little further? I don't see why the federal government can't put out a bond that beats inflation as well as one that matches inflation. After all, inflation is sometimes incredibly low - we had deflation in 2008-09 after all.

Inflation isn't a measure of how much debt the US federal government takes on or how much money is in circulation after all, but rather the price increases of various commodities and services.

The Keynesian view is that inflation has little to do with monetary supply. The Austrian view is it does, though there are enough real-world examples of inflation without monetary supply increases and deflation with monetary supply increases to safely say that the effect is indirect at best. At the very least, it certainly isn't a 1:1 correlation.

Re:Freicoin: bitcoin-like currency from the Occupy movement by runeks on Monday June 25, 2012 @03:53PM (#4158386)
I think a part of the point is that there is no such thing as the measure of inflation. Every measure of inflation measures some basket of goods; what if I want to buy something else with my inflating currency? Then this measure isn't relevant for me. Also, how can we know whether prices rise due to an increase in the money supply or due to something else? Consider the following example where p, q, r, s, t, u and v all denote a certain good. m denotes the monetary good. At first, the relationship, in price, between these goods is the following:

p=2m, q=0.7m, r=1.4m, s=8m, t=0.2m, u=0.6m, v=4.5m

after a while the prices change and now the relationship is the following:

p=2.5m, q=0.5m, r=1.2m, s=7m, t=0.2m, u=2m, v=4.6m

What role has an inflation in the monetary supply played in the change in prices and what role has factors such as scarcity, difficulty of production, labor costs, etc. played in the change of prices? The answer is it's impossible to tell. Sure, you could calculate an average price change between all the goods, but who is to say that this average stems from monetary inflation and not an increase in wages or an incrase in energy costs, for example?

Re:Freicoin: bitcoin-like currency from the Occupy movement by mindslight on Monday June 25, 2012 @07:05PM (#4159230)
USG cannot conjure value out of thin air, so any "free" returns must come from changing the unit of measure. The no-risk USD instrument with the highest rate of return is where conservative money should generally end up, and thus its return is the expected monetary base expansion. And since this expansion is distributed evenly across the economy, by definition it's inflation.

When analyzing inflation in terms of prices, one must also take into account how much those prices would have otherwise dropped due to non-monetary factors such as technological and market progress. If a certain widget is 10% easier to produce than yesterday but the price remains the same due to monetary base expansion, that's a silent 10% reduction of what today's purchasing power should have been. With exponential technological progress, this term is ever-more important.

Re:Freicoin: bitcoin-like currency from the Occupy movement by runeks on Monday June 25, 2012 @02:45PM (#4157994)
> Is there some reason why those with modest savings can't buy treasury bills?

From a purely moral standpoint I think it's wrong for a government to force an inflating currency onto the public, in order to incentivize the public into buying the government's own debt. I mean, this just seems obviously criminal to me if anyone but the government were caught doing this.

Re:Freicoin: bitcoin-like currency from the Occupy movement by nhaehnle on Monday June 25, 2012 @06:00PM (#4158959)
Locking people into a cell is also obviously criminal if anyone but the government does it.

There are certain powers that are useful for someone to be able to exert at specific, well-defined and controlled times. This is why the government has a monopoly on physical force, and for the same reason it has a monopoly on economic force.

Note also that the government doesn't actually force you to use their currency as a store of wealth. You're really only forced to use it to pay your taxes.

Re:Freicoin: bitcoin-like currency from the Occupy movement by runeks on Wednesday June 27, 2012 @07:27PM (#4169721)
> There are certain powers that are useful for someone to be able to exert at specific, well-defined and controlled times.

I agree with that. But I don't think financially encouraging anyone to use a government-made currency is one of those powers that the government should be entitled to.

> Note also that the government doesn't actually force you to use their currency as a store of wealth. You're really only forced to use it to pay your taxes.

The capital gains tax is an effective way of discouraging anyone from storing their wealth in another asset. Say I had bought gold in 1981 because I (rightly) expected inflation to increase, then in 1986, when the currency had lost half of its purchasing power - and the gold I owned had consequently doubled in dollar-value - I would be legally required to give some of that money back to the government, making the protection of my savings' purchasing power very difficult (if I want to stay on the right side of the law). So while the government doesn't directly force anyone to use their currency to store wealth, they make it less attractive to not do so. And I suspect these efforts would increase should we experience a flee from the dollar in the future.

Legal tender laws is another type of legislation that gives unfair advantage to the government's own currency. So forcing citizens to pay their taxes in the government's currency isn't all the government does wrt. hindering currency competition.

Re:Freicoin: bitcoin-like currency from the Occupy movement by kiba on Monday June 25, 2012 @02:19PM (#4157819)
But now people can prove if a currency is worth using by inventing new cryptocurrencies instead of just merely saying "this is utterly backwards".

I am skeptical too, as I don't see why freicoin is worth using over bitcoin. The only other currency I would use is namecoin, but that's because it actually occupy a different niche.

Re:Freicoin: bitcoin-like currency from the Occupy movement by mindslight on Monday June 25, 2012 @02:29PM (#4157888)
I think you're vastly overstating the efficiency of the battle for symbols.
Re:Freicoin: bitcoin-like currency from the Occupy movement by daenz on Monday June 25, 2012 @02:26PM (#4157867)
In theory, couldn't one gain of demurrage be that the fees could be proportional to the amount of money being "secured" (stored)? Inflation is across-the-board, but demurrage could be more targetted.
Re:Freicoin: bitcoin-like currency from the Occupy movement by mindslight on Monday June 25, 2012 @02:32PM (#4157919)
I think you mean to say 'non-proportional'.

Fees higher than linear -> sybil attack brings them back to linear.

Fees lower than linear -> store value in shared accounts aka banks.