News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A Word about Systemd by kemotep on Tuesday September 17, 2024 @08:59PM (#41574581)
I would think a BSD developer has a good idea of the challenges facing OS development and the implementation of an init system.

I do not think it is charitable to them to say they think only Linux matters. If that’s the case why are they a FreeBSD developer?

Re:A Word about Systemd by inferiorhuman on Wednesday September 18, 2024 @03:04AM (#41576678)
Have you not watched the video then? There are a couple sections on why portability is not important because only Linux matters. Benno's words:

  The reality is UNIX is dead… these days I think you've basically got Linux and some rounding errors.

So why is he a FreeBSD developer? Good question.
Re:A Word about Systemd by kemotep on Wednesday September 18, 2024 @10:44AM (#41580331)
Look, I use linux, OpenBSD, Apple and even Microsoft operating systems. I thought the video provided a unique perspective to the systemd discourse that I thought people would be interested in seeing if they hadn’t already.

I couldn’t care less if Debian announced that Debian 13 is going to default to s6 or runit as the init system. I have no loyalty to systemd other than the Linux distros I use have integrated with it.

The linked article introduced me to s6 which is interesting. I do think there is value in simpler codebases a la wireguard, toybox, and doas. None of the hostilities towards one init project over the other have ever made sense to me but “the battle” was mostly fought before I got into Linux.

Re:A Word about Systemd by inferiorhuman on Wednesday September 18, 2024 @11:21AM (#41580870)
What's unique about it? That Benno tosses out a reference to BSD here and there? Otherwise it's just a video of someone dismissing criticism out of hand. Could've gotten that from Lennart.