News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What If Ozempic Is Just a Good Thing? by Apocryphon on Monday September 16, 2024 @04:30PM (#41560486)
The parallel is "I had to work hard to lose weight / maintain my low weight, why should they get a magic pill?" Unfairness can be perceived even when it only exists in a vague cosmic sense and has no bearing in material reality.
Re:What If Ozempic Is Just a Good Thing? by randomdata on Monday September 16, 2024 @04:37PM (#41560567)
I think you forgot to mention the parallel? I guess, seemingly, that would be "I had to work hard to pay my student debt, why should they get to have their parents pay for it?" but that is not a sentiment that is common enough to speak of. Yeah, sure, I'm sure at least one person in history has had that thought before, but not the point of it being notable to talk about on HN. Most people who see another have their loans paid for think "Good for them". There must be something else?

The "I had to work hard to pay my student loan, and now I have to work hard to pay yours too?" sentiment is much more common and I could see that show up here, but it is not a parallel. That's a very different idea that has no parallel. I don't have to work off the weight you lost.

Re:What If Ozempic Is Just a Good Thing? by Apocryphon on Monday September 16, 2024 @04:37PM (#41560582)
The parallel was always there:

"being against student loan debt forgiveness because one had to pay off one's own loans"

> but that is not a sentiment that is common enough to speak of

It crops up every time the issue is discussed online. On places like Twitter, at least.

> I don't have to work off the weight you lost.

Again, this blend of envy, spite, and petty injustice crops up quite often. "Why did I have to exercise when they could afford a gastric bypass?"

You seem unfamiliar with how petty people can be online. There are plenty of people who get personally aggrieved when they think someone got a free lunch / might get a free lunch even when the lunch isn't paid by them / they were unfortunate enough to miss out on free lunch day.

> that is not a sentiment that is common enough to speak of

Sure it is.

Re:What If Ozempic Is Just a Good Thing? by randomdata on Monday September 16, 2024 @04:46PM (#41560681)
> It crops up every time the issue is discussed online. On places like Twitter, at least.

Only when it pertains to government forgiveness, because of the bag holding problem.

Nobody cares when it is an unrelated entity that is willing to become the bag holder (e.g. parents). In fact, it has become almost expected that entities like parents will become the bag holders when it comes to college debt.

The bag holding problem is something quite different, not a parallel.

> "Why did I have to exercise when they could afford a bypass?"

So it crops up quite often, but only when it comes to weight loss-related matters?

Re:What If Ozempic Is Just a Good Thing? by Apocryphon on Monday September 16, 2024 @04:47PM (#41560693)
> So it crops up quite often, but only when it comes to weight loss-related matters?

Do you know what class envy is

Re:What If Ozempic Is Just a Good Thing? by randomdata on Monday September 16, 2024 @04:52PM (#41560745)
I am familiar with the common use, but it speaks to people in a lower class envying those in a higher class. Here we have people in the same class, just with different paths to get there. So, you must have a pet definition?

Regardless, I've never heard a "self-made" rich person complain "I had to work hard to get here. Why oh why wasn't I born rich like that Saudi prince?". They seem to only ever be proud that they were able to become rich. Again, I suppose it has probably happened once, but does not seem common enough to speak of.

Re:What If Ozempic Is Just a Good Thing? by Apocryphon on Monday September 16, 2024 @05:07PM (#41560916)
It might be more common in terms of political power rather than wealth. Nixon, for example, hated the Ivy League-educated eastern establishment ruling elites that he displaced.
Re:What If Ozempic Is Just a Good Thing? by randomdata on Monday September 16, 2024 @05:16PM (#41561025)
Probably not, though, given that you couldn't find an example of envy and decided to randomly reach for hatred instead for some reason. Again, I suppose it has probably happened once, but is clearly not common enough to speak of (you literally were unable to speak of it).
Re:What If Ozempic Is Just a Good Thing? by Apocryphon on Monday September 16, 2024 @05:45PM (#41561315)
Here, a House Representative questioning student loan relief announced in August 2022. Not framed as an issue of others paying for the debtors, but rather "what relief do those who already paid off their debt receive?"

https://x.com/Jim_Jordan/status/1562461372851847168

Senator Chuck Grassley: "For our government just to say ok your debt is completely forgiven.. it’s completely unfair"

https://x.com/Acyn/status/1562530929838436355

Reporter question during the announcement: "Mr. President, is this unfair to people who paid their student loans or chose not to take out loans?"

https://www.c-span.org/video/?522478-1/president-biden-remar...

Re:What If Ozempic Is Just a Good Thing? by randomdata on Monday September 16, 2024 @05:51PM (#41561389)
Valid question. Given that they are assuming the debt, what relief are they getting to pass it off onto the next bag holder? Anyone assuming the debt would ask the same question.
Re:What If Ozempic Is Just a Good Thing? by Apocryphon on Monday September 16, 2024 @05:52PM (#41561402)
"I already paid off my student loans! Am I eligible for a refund and loan forgiveness? Yes, up to $20K — but only under these 2 specific conditions"

https://finance.yahoo.com/news/already-paid-off-student-loan...

Re:What If Ozempic Is Just a Good Thing? by randomdata on Monday September 16, 2024 @05:53PM (#41561405)
You seem to be confusing a past loan with the new loan just taken on; a new loan those assuming it don't want to take on in the first place.
Re:What If Ozempic Is Just a Good Thing? by Apocryphon on Monday September 16, 2024 @05:54PM (#41561416)
I am answering your question, plain and simple. You may not like the answer; that is your prerogative, as always.
Re:What If Ozempic Is Just a Good Thing? by randomdata on Monday September 16, 2024 @05:55PM (#41561435)
No, you keep finding diversions to avoid answer the question.

Let's face it: The question is unanswerable as there is no parallel and there never was.

Your never ending quest to try and find that which does not exist is commendable, and hilarious, but to think that it is answering some kind of question is nonsensical.

Re:What If Ozempic Is Just a Good Thing? by Apocryphon on Monday September 16, 2024 @05:56PM (#41561450)
Here's an example of someone who's paid off their debt, is unhappy at the prospect of others getting relief, but not complaining about being the one to have to pick up the tax bill in order to deliver that relief:

> Student loan forgiveness rewards bad decision making

I took out a $160,000 student load a decade ago

I saved every penny I made to pay it back in full. I ended up paying over $300,000 on the loan

Now I'm getting punished because I was too responsible and paid back my loan too quickly?

I lived in a $500 a month rat and cockroach infested sun room in Boston for years to pay back this debt

If I would have instead ignored my debt and bought cars and useless luxury items I'd get a free $300,000 check?

I'm as a-political as it gets. I hate all politicians. But this is insanity and rewards the WORST behavior

https://x.com/AlexFinnX/status/1793732427325620625

You seem to disbelieve such a narrative exists.

Re:What If Ozempic Is Just a Good Thing? by randomdata on Monday September 16, 2024 @06:01PM (#41561511)
> You seem to disbelieve such a narrative exists.

It has been said over and over that it no doubt has happened, but is not common enough that anyone here would speak to it. Digging deep into the depths of what HN largely considers a trolling website to find some random nobody has ever heard of once saying what you want to hear is not indicative of anything.

I'm surprised you don't take your comedy show on the road. People would pay good money for the laughs you've brought us.

Re:What If Ozempic Is Just a Good Thing? by Apocryphon on Monday September 16, 2024 @06:07PM (#41561567)
> but is not common enough that anyone here would talk about it

But I don't care about whether or not people on HN would talk about it. I'm saying that it exists. Ultimately it is a moral judgment about personal responsibility. You find it in attacks on "welfare queens" similarly. Yes, of course there is always the element of being an aggrieved taxpayer. But there is also the vague cosmic - puritanism? - critique of "why should they have it easy when I had it hard?" I'm glad that you uphold HN as a place that is above such sentiment. But here I agree with you! I do not take such critiques seriously. Yet they abound, and they are a clear parallel to people attacking Ozempic because they find it "too easy" for becoming or staying thin. And so, we come full circle.

> not indicative of anything.

This entire sub-discussion is about fallacious arguments, and it is a fallacious argument that I am saying it exists. Therefore it is entirely germane for me to bring up a trolling website to find an argument used by a random nobody, as it proves the existence of a narrative. Perhaps you may quibble that it is not a narrative that exists in abundance. Then we are simply arguing preponderance, because I have already established existence.

Re:What If Ozempic Is Just a Good Thing? by randomdata on Monday September 16, 2024 @06:11PM (#41561603)
> But I don't care about whether or not people on HN would talk about it.

You certainly don't have to care, but that is the discussion taking place. It is a necessary precondition for this supposed parallel to exist.

If you're trying to tell us that you can't focus and are flailing around like one of those whacky blow up thingys down at the used car lot, have fun with that. It no doubt goes well with your comedy show.

> This entire sub-discussion is about fallacious arguments

Oh, I see, so you really are unable to focus. I get why you appear to be so confused now. It is not so much that you're confused in what you write, but that you're off in your own world. Well, that's pretty funny, at least.

Re:What If Ozempic Is Just a Good Thing? by Apocryphon on Monday September 16, 2024 @06:12PM (#41561619)
> Be kind. Don't be snarky. Converse curiously; don't cross-examine. Edit out swipes.
Re:What If Ozempic Is Just a Good Thing? by randomdata on Monday September 16, 2024 @06:19PM (#41561709)
And most of all, have fun.
Re:What If Ozempic Is Just a Good Thing? by Apocryphon on Monday September 16, 2024 @06:26PM (#41561776)
Are those tears really from laughter, or are you laughing through the tears?

The original post I was responding to was about people who get upset about Ozempic who "show up over and over again on any discussion of these drugs." Maybe the poster did include HN as a place of those discussions, but I interpreted it as in general, in other internet spaces and in meatspace.

I then posted a similar fallacious argument that I felt paralleled it because ultimately they're both arguments out of a perceived lack of personal responsibility being "rewarded" by a quick fix.

You chose to introduce logic and reason by arguing that opposition to student loan debt forgiveness is motivated by the complainers becoming bag-holders. I agree that might be a (strong) motivation, but it is not the only one, because many people become busybodies when it comes to attacking others' personal (ir)responsibility when those others receive a windfall. "Taking the easy way out."

This subthread might have been a meandering road, but we have arrived right at where we started, with you bizarrely attacking a critique that I do not believe in, out of sheer pedantry perhaps.

Now, are you going to attempt a defense, a refutation, or whatever, or continue to hurl insults that both flout the guidelines of this forum and only serve to demean yourself?