Re:Craigslist, LinkedIn, Netflix, and others don't owe us an...
by dredmorbius on Saturday June 23, 2012 @11:28PM
(#4152493)
Craigslist aren't doing this strictly out of the kindness of their hearts.
By charging for only a small number of listing, CL accomplish two things:
1. They create a large marketplace, which by virtue of its size provides more value than if it were a smaller, more diversified set of markets.
2. It "sucks the oxygen out of the room" for any competitor attempting to create a similar service. There are a few other commerce-related online sites -- eBay, Amazon, iTunes store, etc., and even a few competing specialized listings services (jobs, apartments, etc.) -- but none that specifically serve the general classifieds market.
I do suspect that there's a genuine component to CL's community service mission. But that doesn't mean the self-serving aspects of its behavior are any less valid.
By charging for only a small number of listing, CL accomplish two things:
1. They create a large marketplace, which by virtue of its size provides more value than if it were a smaller, more diversified set of markets.
2. It "sucks the oxygen out of the room" for any competitor attempting to create a similar service. There are a few other commerce-related online sites -- eBay, Amazon, iTunes store, etc., and even a few competing specialized listings services (jobs, apartments, etc.) -- but none that specifically serve the general classifieds market.
I do suspect that there's a genuine component to CL's community service mission. But that doesn't mean the self-serving aspects of its behavior are any less valid.