As I understand it, at the time it was a reasonable conclusion (though even back then it was still highly controversial and lots of scientists disagreed), but in the decades since, it's become obvious this "ecoside" theory is wrong, and this latest study puts the nail in the coffin.
So has Diamond ever said "There is new evidence, and I was wrong"? Or is he doing that weird thing that humans often do where they double down on a now obviously incorrect theory because admitting fault is somehow too painful?
But has he come out and said "this new evidence means my older theories are wrong?" The other comment about his review of Questioning Collapse makes me think not, but even that was from nearly 15 years ago.
I think it's important that Diamond acknowledge the new reality, as he is probably the person most responsible for spreading an idea (one that has a lot of implications for the present day real world) that turned out to be wrong.
So they were European slavers, but from Peru...
Most European countries outlawed slavery way before 1862. At that time Peru was not colony, but independent country for 40 years! British Navy was fighting slave trade ships!
Also big part of population left island for economical reasons. They were not "taken" but left voluntary for work and better opportunities. Living on islands was harsh, famine, diseases, hurricanes....
People migrate from countryside even today, it is natural process!
Were these Peruvian slavers native Peruvians, who acted in accordance to the culture and society they had before Europeans arrived there? Or were they people who had moved to Peru from Europe as colonizers and who decided to keep the system of European colonialism after it became independent?
Have you read the book? IIRC it does nothing of the sort
[0] https://www.google.com/maps/@-27.150356,-109.4396352,3a,75y,...
"In December 1862, Peruvian slave traders landed on Easter Island and captured approximately 1,500 Rapa Nui people, including much of the island's leadership and elite. The raids were brutal, and the kidnapped islanders were transported to the guano islands and plantations on the Peruvian coast. Of these 1,500 individuals, only a small fraction would ever return.Of the roughly 1,500 people taken, it is estimated that fewer than 100 survived to return home. By the mid-19th century, the island's population had been reduced to just a few hundred, down from an estimated 3,000–4,000 before the raids."
The invention of ammonia synthesis from atmospheric N2 via the Haber-Bosch process largely put an end to the guano industy and the slave labor that supported it. There's an excellent book, "The Alchemy of Air" by Thomas Hager that covers this history well:
https://blog.rootsofprogress.org/turning-air-into-bread