News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The CIA-in-Chile Scandal at 50 by diggan on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @10:08AM (#41511551)
That sounds scarily familiar to how Russia sees Ukraine today, and I'm unable to see how it could justify what happened in the past or justify what is happening now.

From a HN commentator in 2054:

> I think Russia was very concerned at the time that Ukraine under Zelensky would become a client state or a vassal of the US. Russia still upholds the "No outsiders" Doctrine which states that any intervention in the politics of the Russian World by foreign powers is a threat to Russia. Russia does not want any foreign interference or potential military bases in its 'backyard'.

Re:The CIA-in-Chile Scandal at 50 by SSJPython on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @10:11AM (#41511573)
Yes, it's pretty much identical to Russia-Ukraine. And I'm not justifying it, I am just explaining how the US sees it.

There is no morality in geopolitics. In the anarchic international system, there is no global enforcement mechanism, so states will always try to maximize their security at the expense of others. In short, might makes right in this system.

"The strong do what they can and the weak suffer what they must." - Thucydides

Re:The CIA-in-Chile Scandal at 50 by keybored on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @11:28AM (#41512296)
That’s right. It’s only us normal human beings that have an aversion to war and killing.
Re:The CIA-in-Chile Scandal at 50 by IncreasePosts on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @11:53AM (#41512546)
Basically everyone has an aversion to war and killing. Until something happens that they think is worth going to war for, or killing for.
Re:The CIA-in-Chile Scandal at 50 by keybored on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @12:06PM (#41512684)
The unnormal humans are the architects of these events who do it just for the sake of money and power.
Re:The CIA-in-Chile Scandal at 50 by IncreasePosts on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @12:19PM (#41512821)
Isn't that exactly what the poor 18 year old from Kentucky is doing when he signs up for the army?
Re:The CIA-in-Chile Scandal at 50 by keybored on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @12:52PM (#41513145)
That’s not a good way to get neither money nor power.
Re:The CIA-in-Chile Scandal at 50 by IncreasePosts on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @12:58PM (#41513211)
A common refrain to explain kids joining the army is to escape being stuck in a small town with no opportunities.

So, they are saying they're okay with killing in order to improve their economic prospects.

Re:The CIA-in-Chile Scandal at 50 by fragmede on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @01:38PM (#41513560)
Compared to other prospects for that 18 year old? College is out of reach without help and the military is a good way to get the help needed to go there.
Re:The CIA-in-Chile Scandal at 50 by diggan on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @10:20AM (#41511653)
> And I'm not justifying it, I am just explaining how the US sees it.

Yeah, I guess it's a thin line between "providing neutral historical context and reasoning" and "implicitly suggesting that the reasoning makes the actions acceptable or understandable". I'll trust what you're saying though and assume you're not actually trying to justifying it.

> states will always try to maximize their security at the expense of others

I don't think this is true for every single country in the world, especially those more concerned with their own well-being above their "global security status". That's the kind of black and white view that leads to more division and separation rather than humans trying to work together.

Re:The CIA-in-Chile Scandal at 50 by SSJPython on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @10:32AM (#41511750)
> I don't think this is true for every single country in the world, especially those more concerned with their own well-being above their "global security status". That's the kind of black and white view that leads to more division and separation rather than humans trying to work together.

For some countries, maximizing their security simply means trying to survive and not get taken over. These are typically smaller countries such as Armenia. They can't afford to focus on their economic well-being or working with other nations if their existence is threatened. For other countries that are established powers, maximizing security can mean anything from securing the territory it currently holds (India, Pakistan, North Korea, South Korea) to expanding its territory (Russia, Azerbaijan) to getting or maintaining a sphere of influence (US, Russia, China).

Re:The CIA-in-Chile Scandal at 50 by dtquad on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @10:21AM (#41511666)
The "Russia is just defending their geographical sphere of interest" argument for Russia's invasion of Ukraine only comes from Western isolationists and pro-Russia activists.

The actual internal political communication within Russia makes it clear that they don't consider Ukraine and the Ukrainian identity as legitimate. That is why they want to annex Ukraine. Putin launched the invasion in a speech where called Ukraine a fake nation that shouldn't exist.

Re:The CIA-in-Chile Scandal at 50 by jampekka on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @12:42PM (#41513045)
And Bush launched the Iraq invasion on the totally false pretexts of WMD and 9/11 involvement.

The stated reasons for starting a war are rarely the true reasons. Although Putin did, among other "reasons", say NATO expansion is a critical factor.

Re:The CIA-in-Chile Scandal at 50 by realpolitik123 on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @10:16AM (#41511613)
The key difference being the Cold War is over

But more importantly, from a "realpolitik" International Relations perspective, the biggest problem with the invasion of Ukraine is that Russia couldn't win it as swiftly as it believed it could. If they were not a paper tiger and had in fact succeeded in taking Kyiv shortly after the start of the conflict, the rest of the world would have had to accept it. Because they failed, they get the US and other Western allies supporting a resistance for the stated goal of defending Ukraine's sovereignty but for the true goal of not allowing Russia to grow stronger.

Re:The CIA-in-Chile Scandal at 50 by freilanzer on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @10:38AM (#41511799)
> If they were not a paper tiger and had in fact succeeded in taking Kyiv shortly after the start of the conflict, the rest of the world would have had to accept it.

Not at all true.

Re:The CIA-in-Chile Scandal at 50 by realpolitik123 on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @10:47AM (#41511878)
Show me one instance in which a permanent member of the UN security council successfully invaded another country and suffered any real repercussion other than political backlash.

Downvoting me and saying "not true" doesn't make it less true.