News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Recent Tor Exit Node Operator Raids and Legal Harassment ... by Manuel_D on Tuesday September 10, 2024 @05:08PM (#41505585)
Whether or not the exit node operators retained logs is besides the point. These exit nodes are facilitating illegal activities, and it's trivial to prove. How do they not get arrested?

It sounds like Germany extends some sort of carrier protection to Tor exit node operators. E.g. if someone organizes a drug deal over the phone, Verizon is not liable. But Verizon does have to meet some minimum standards of records keeping and law enforcement assistance (wire tapping).

Re:Recent Tor Exit Node Operator Raids and Legal Harassment ... by lokar on Tuesday September 10, 2024 @05:37PM (#41505867)
Lots of people and organizations facilitate crime. That’s not generally the legal standard. They typically must be proved to done so intentionally (or with reckless disregard)
Re:Recent Tor Exit Node Operator Raids and Legal Harassment ... by numpad0 on Tuesday September 10, 2024 @05:54PM (#41506006)
No, it is. There are more often specific laws that exempt platformers of liabilities on condition that they keep logs and cooperate with LE.

Perhaps the most famous example is DMCA: [Google] is exempt from liabilities for hosting pirated movies on [YouTube] by US laws, on condition that it's not actively involved with it and fully robotic with takedowns.

Re:Recent Tor Exit Node Operator Raids and Legal Harassment ... by golergka on Tuesday September 10, 2024 @06:41PM (#41506349)
If a criminal rode on a bus to place of the crime, is the bus driver automatically liable? Bus company? Is his phone company liable because he talked about his crimes on the phone?
Re:Recent Tor Exit Node Operator Raids and Legal Harassment ... by betaby on Tuesday September 10, 2024 @09:36PM (#41507355)
No. But legal system treats 'on the Internet' in a more harshly way.
Re:Recent Tor Exit Node Operator Raids and Legal Harassment ... by numpad0 on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @02:15AM (#41508509)
IANAL, but "legally"? Bus companies has code of conduct posted on the wall at their depot for its users to read and agree, or state law regulating public transportation, and it always says using it for crimes is against the law. Those clauses let drivers and companies frame themselves as victims to escape prosecutions, unless there's going to be gross negligence or sorts that override them.

It's not like courts treat popular businesses like buses and ISPs as sceneries just by gut feeling. There are always laws.

Re:Recent Tor Exit Node Operator Raids and Legal Harassment ... by codedokode on Tuesday September 10, 2024 @05:38PM (#41505878)
Does iMessage or WhatsApp has wire tapping feature? Are they "facilitating illegal activities"?
Re:Recent Tor Exit Node Operator Raids and Legal Harassment ... by Manuel_D on Tuesday September 10, 2024 @05:50PM (#41505974)
If a government investigator joins a WhatsApp channel where loads of people are sharing CSE, WhatsApp will help the government find the people responsible. WhatsApp encrypts the content of the data, but they retain message logs and do cooperate with law enforcement. Presumably the same for iMessage.

This largely conforms with how the first telecoms received immunity for abuse of their services. They retain logs and assist the government with investigations, and in exchange they are shielded from liability. WhatsApp and iMessage would probably cooperate to the same extent, minus wire-tapping messages in transit (because they can't). That's vastly greater cooperation than a tor exit node operator that retains no logs.s