[1]: https://x.com/tomwarren/status/1671981463040819200?s=46
[2]: https://x.com/twthereddragon/status/1672270407179665409?s=46
I don't know about the others (And Nintendo's in particular is probably ironclad in NDAs and lawyers if their attitude towards their userbase is anything to go by), but for Steam you can read all about the technical, financial and sales/marketing features you get through the platform here: https://partner.steamgames.com/doc/home
EGS and MS Store compete on a lower %, partly because they offer less of this.
Crack the market first (embrace) by offering the lower cut.
1. Steam is voluntary, you are free to instead use gog, epic, whatever or maybe buy physical boxes from the devs.
2. PC games these days can be huge. The hosting cost alone will be significant.
3. Valve have significant R&D costs for getting games run smoothly in multiple environments, some of which they have no control over.
4. It's up to 30%.
Does Steam do this? I thought they left it up to the developers. Except for their first party titles and perhaps for Proton support of major 3P games.
And that’s the same dilemma as with any of the other gatekeepers like MS or Sony or Apple. Right now sure, you can choose not to play ball with any one of them… but if you want to have users you need to play ball with one of them, and they’re all offering the exact same deal.
People have a-priori determined that “only steam is ok” and that itself is anticompetitive and market-distorting. It’s already a monopsony at that point. It’s the Walmart situation where even if there’s notionally a market with millions of end-users… they’re all fronted by a single merchant with monopsony or oligopsony pricing power. Aka what the EU calls a “gatekeeper”. Market fairness isn’t just fairness to consumers after all, or epic wouldn’t be in court.
And from a gamedev perspective it’s the exact same as apple: if you want to access the pc market you don’t have a choice, steam is the pc market and retains a functional ~100% control of this market (in a gatekeeping sense) such that valve should be subject to DMA-style rules and restrictions. Again just like apple, you can go elsewhere, but if you want these users then valve retains a chokehold on your revenue and you don’t really have a choice.
You can decide for yourself whether that’s a reasonable perspective and consideration but that’s the one that’s been applied to apple and their own App Store. Doesn’t matter if people can sideload (altstore/altserver exists) or use a different device, they worked themselves into a gatekeeper position and should be treated as such.
> Default Release (or standard release): This is the most common type of key on Steam, which is usually tied to a Steam store or retail Steam Key package. These keys are appropriate for retail boxes or sales on other digital stores. Customers can activate this type of Steam Key at any time, but the product will unlock only after it has been released on Steam. Games and applications launching on Steam may receive up to 5,000 Default Release Steam Keys to support retail activities and distribution on other stores. After that, all Steam Key requests are reviewed on a case-by-case basis. There is no guarantee that you will be provided additional keys.
Steam is not there to be a free CDN for you; it’s one thing if it’s 5-10% of your sales or for charity like humble bundle, it is NOT unlimited and valve will refuse if you are abusing it.
Moreover this also has to be viewed in the context of valve’s forced “most favored nation” clause - if you undercut steam on the site they will reduce the price on steam accordingly, and if you still are abusing the key system they will stop granting you keys.
Again: steam’s business model wouldn’t work if they were being a cdn for people who don’t even pay for them. That’s not at all how it works, you are misinformed if that’s what you’re suggesting/implying. Sure, they allow some offsite sales… which must be at the same price as on steam, and they can “adjust” your revenue accordingly if you do the thing you are implying.
You are totally allowed to release a website and allow purchase and download of your game through that only. People can still add the game to steam (but no cloud saves!).
You cannot do that on iOS, Sony, Microsoft (xbox) and Nintendo, you are required to pay them to reach those customers.
Now, yes as a customer I prefer if your game is on steam because it gives me some guarantees: no virus, often cloud saves integration, reviews to understand the type and quality of game before purchase. These are things you don't get even if the game was added to steam with "add a non steam game".
While that fee may seem high, the developers are in someways subsidizing other developers that could never afford to build and maintain that infrastructure. They're also reducing the friction and on-ramping of new players/users. They are also providing the payment processing and handling billing/chargeback resolution.
Just the merchant fees alone would be would be 2-4% of revenue (not including losses to chargebacks and fraud/risk controls). The raw cost of bandwidth usage would be ~2 cents per 12GB game download (not including infrastructure to host/facilitate the amount of simultaneous downloads). The staff to manage billing issues/refunds. The raw amounts are small, but not insignificant considering that for every $20 they collect on a AAA title there are several indie games getting all the same functionality which only nets Valve $2.
Valve, Epic, Playstation, Xbox. The platforms are providing the ecosystem and platform that has allowed gaming to flourish at incredible rates, outpacing the motion picture industry and the sport industry.
I recently installed Playnite [1], an open source game library manager and its been incredible. It pulls in games from all launchers/sources and gives you a unified library. I think all it would take to bring down Steam prices is for studios to adopt one such project but they are too blindsided by the ambition to have their own platform. You still have to do all the downloads,licensing etc. but the fact that it's a unified launcher for all stores is enough for me to prefer it over others.
If I'm going to use something like Lutris or Playnite or even Steam to organize my games, a non-zero number of them are going to launch a game-specific launcher. Live-service games seem particularly fond of this, likely so they can show you a teaser while downloading a refreshed client.
But if they could just publish a RSS feed for updates, the launcher could pull the new files and cut out the middleman.
They are not complaining, they have only responded(in June) to a EU watchdog query and saying it not possible for them pay for IAP at 30%[1] to Apple and sell profitably, even though EU made Apple open up the App Store in EU recently.
[1] Apple does not mandate using their IAP per se, but forbids instructing on how to pay outside etc i believe.
* The Division and it's sequel The Division 2 (ubisoft games, so- uplay): https://steamcommunity.com/app/2221490/discussions/0/3768983...
* VtM Bloodhunt; which launched on Steam despite being a Tencent property, due to fan backlash.
* RENNSPORT; Where we also bent to pressure from the community and will release early-access on Steam: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_1dl0v6mevg
First comment on that YT video:
> Good. I refuse to use the Epic Store and I really wanted to check Rennsport out. Glad it's gonna be on Steam.
for context.
I don’t play online and still really enjoyed playing through the stories. I thought it was so much as an NYC dweller to walk around the city in chaos.
They early Covid days made me think of it too, the trailer was fantastic.
I won't make an epic account, not even for free games, after they started with buying exclusives as their first move.
Thats not because valve is a monopoly or because I love valve, but because epic is actively garbage and I won't give them money.
From the gamedev perspective it just looks like people have decided that Valve is the desired monopoly.
A fact that Valve are very content to use against game developers, it seems.
(I say this, owning an OLED steamdeck and being extremely pleased that proton exists; but don't forget that Proton exists because Microsoft was doing to Valve, what Valve does to game developers, and Valve wanted leverage)
(not sarcasm, I find it ironic and beautiful)
In fact, if you become market leader for AAA it would arguably be your duty to shareholders to put it up to 30%
Consumers don’t actually want to be in the business of dealing with many different systems to minimise their costs in these sorts of markets.
Steam are predictable and are yet to dick me. Can’t say that about many companies having dealt with them for 20 years after regular consumption.
- You're not producing a good that people need. Gaming entertainment is actually a pretty thin segment of goods.
- You can get free distribution easily (desktop, web, etc.). Other platforms are just increasing your market opportunity and you can charge a thicker margin to get onto them if you want to.
- Physical distribution has costs
- Servers and multiplayer have costs
With mobile:
- Applications do everything from dating, jobs, food, payments, etc. It's anything and everything, and a lot of them are absolutely essential for modern life.
- Apple and Google are the market. There is no alternative. They're a duopoly and embed their talons into everything.
- The app store is artificial. There's nothing stopping web downloads of applications, and any security concerns could be met with signing, risk signal heuristics and reporting, and application sandboxing.
There should be no "App Store Requirement" to deploy a native app. Period.
Furthermore, there should be no requirement to integrate with the duopoly's payment stack, messaging stack, or any other platform choice enforced upon you.
The gaming industry is larger than the film and music industry combined, and is the single largest revenue source for mobile app stores, by far. The worldwide industry was worth roughly ~282B last year [1]
For comparison, the entire US farming industry is 203.5B [2]
Hardly small.
[1] https://www.fortunebusinessinsights.com/gaming-market-105730
[2] https://www.ers.usda.gov/data-products/chart-gallery/gallery...
You can distribute anything you want; as long as it's a web-app.
Nobody is running random .exe's in 2024; but you have random, arbitrary, untrusted code that runs in heaps and has access to the GPU via websites.
You have the same constraints we do, except it's easier to make a web application for dating, jobs, food, payments - than it is to do high-poly AAA games.
Can you imagine Apple or Nintendo doing such a thing?
I make AAA video games, so 30% for me is basically standard.
* Valve: 30%
* Playstation: 30%
* Xbox: 30%
* Nintendo eShop: 30%
It's only the competitors that give better rates in the open-ish platforms, but people *openly* hate them; (I legitimately still have people denigrating uPlay and EPIC to my face, aggressively, when they find out what games I make).
* Microsoft Store: 15% (12% for games)
* EPIC: 12%
I'm sure there's not much sympathy for AAA here, and it's the nature of consoles to sell the hardware at a loss (something not true for iPhones), but for me when I see the outrage I'm always incredulous.. as this already existing and accepted ecosystem is what Apple are modelling.
I find it ironic that Xbox of all people would complain.