News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Did your car witness a crime? Bay Area police may be comi... by dylan604 on Saturday August 31, 2024 @01:44PM (#41410463)
I don't have to make arrangements to go get my home when it is searched. Also, if you're searching my house, more than likely, I'm directly involved in something. They don't break into my house to get my Ring footage, which is much more equivalent in your attempt equating these disparate concepts. You've now made an innocent civilian incur ridiculous fees to get their car out of impound when there was no reason to impound it to begin with.

You could just as easily boot the car and wait for the owner to return. It's not like this was a long term parking spot. There are just so many options other than tow this innocent car.

Re:Did your car witness a crime? Bay Area police may be comi... by mdorazio on Saturday August 31, 2024 @02:49PM (#41410930)
If your home is searched and the police take something into evidence then you absolutely do need to make arrangements to go get it. And yes, the police absolutely can and do subpoena Ring footage. The difference is that Ring will turn over the footage themselves since it's at least partially cloud-based so that they don't need to break into your home to get it.

You seem to be opposed to the execution of search warrants and subpoenas in general, which is fine, but that's not grounds to oppose this action which is entirely legal.

Re:Did your car witness a crime? Bay Area police may be comi... by dylan604 on Saturday August 31, 2024 @04:37PM (#41411766)
> You seem to be opposed

No, I'm suggesting that there are other ways to get to the footage than just impounding an innocent person's car. Leaving someone stranded when they've done nothing wrong is absolutely a dick move. It's not like they can leave a note in the space where you left the car. There's also no signage with a phone number of a towing company. You don't find out your car wasn't stolen until you call to report your car stolen.

Again, they could quite easily boot your car and have a patrol unit wait for you to return. Or not boot the car, but still have a patrol unit wait. They have the license plate so they can look up the owner. They could try to contact that owner. There are so many other things to do than tow someone's car and leaving them stranded. The fact we are so willingly okay with the cops stealing your car is very strange to me.

Re:Did your car witness a crime? Bay Area police may be comi... by gruez on Saturday August 31, 2024 @02:20PM (#41410714)
>I don't have to make arrangements to go get my home when it is searched

They could however, break your door (if you're not there to let them in), and AFAIK they're not responsible for getting it fixed.

>Also, if you're searching my house, more than likely, I'm directly involved in something.

That's irrelevant. The standard for a search warrant is "probable cause" regardless.

>They don't break into my house to get my Ring footage, which is much more equivalent in your attempt equating these disparate concepts.

...because the ring footage isn't in your house, it's in the cloud. Moreover, if you have an on-premise system and you're on vacation or something, it's plausible that they get a search warrant and break in, especially if they think time is of the essence (eg. your system has limited retention and the footage is going to be wiped).

>You could just as easily boot the car and wait for the owner to return.

If you read the article the police claims that it's only used if they can't locate the owner. It's unclear what that exactly means, but it's not like they're towing every tesla near the crime scene.

Re:Did your car witness a crime? Bay Area police may be comi... by dylan604 on Saturday August 31, 2024 @02:25PM (#41410750)
"If you read the article" is such a lame comment. In other comments in this thread, I've literally quoted the article. How in the world could I have pulled a quote without reading the article.

It's clear you and I have polar opposite sentiments regarding this. So I'll leave it here as you are quite tiresome

Re:Did your car witness a crime? Bay Area police may be comi... by gruez on Saturday August 31, 2024 @04:42PM (#41411798)
>"If you read the article" is such a lame comment. In other comments in this thread, I've literally quoted the article. How in the world could I have pulled a quote without reading the article.

Unlike some commenters I don't check a commenter's entire comment history before making comments. In fact, I don't even keep good track of what everyone said in a particular thread, so forgive me if I didn't do enough due diligence before making a vague implication that you didn't read the article. That said, you need to chill out. If you can't handle a vague implication that you didn't read the article, maybe online forum commenting isn't for you.

Re:Did your car witness a crime? Bay Area police may be comi... by lucb1e on Saturday August 31, 2024 @07:38PM (#41412898)
> I don't have to make arrangements to go get my home when it is searched

Yeah but you no longer have a front door or window when you get there (the person spoke of them breaking in if you're not home), so you have to make other types of arrangements