News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:EU ChatControl is back on the agenda by simion314 on Saturday August 31, 2024 @06:51AM (#41407876)
As far as I know Orban changed the electoral law, he uses the votes from Hungarians outside Hungary (weird to vote for shit that does not affect you), the people in cities are not voting for him so he gets the votes from uneducated people that do not know a foreign language and get indoctrinated by the Orban controlled media. He is also super corrupt and Putin fanboy so most online English support he gets are from Ruzzian trolls.
Re:EU ChatControl is back on the agenda by smackay on Saturday August 31, 2024 @06:58AM (#41407906)
Wikipedia always delivers, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Non-resident_citizen_voting

"As of 2020 a total of 141 countries grant expatriates the right to vote in elections in their countries of origin."

Re:EU ChatControl is back on the agenda by bloak on Saturday August 31, 2024 @07:56AM (#41408212)
An interesting feature of people voting from abroad is that it is very easy to make it very easy or very hard for them to vote, and the choice between those two options tends to depend on how the current government thinks those people are likely to vote. So some countries allow expatriates to vote, but voters have to fill in a load of forms and then turn up with various document at the embassy at a particular time, while other countries proactively hunt down their expatriates and send them a form in the post with a prepaid envelope.
Re:EU ChatControl is back on the agenda by Hnrobert42 on Saturday August 31, 2024 @07:19AM (#41407992)
You are getting responses about expatriate voting. That's not what he did.

Before WWII, Hungary was much larger. After, a large portion was ceded to Romania. He used a sudden super-majority to grant those people the right to vote. Subsequently, his political party has even held political conferences in Romania.

Those Romanians are not Hungarian citizens. They mostly do not suffer the consequences Orban's policy decisions. Yet, they support him because he makes gestures to include them in the country of their cultural origin.

This is far different from allowing overseas voting. This would be like the UK allowing all Irish to vote in parliamentary elections.

Re:EU ChatControl is back on the agenda by macNchz on Saturday August 31, 2024 @07:40AM (#41408111)
Yes this is definitely what the parent comment was getting at, he gave voting rights to diaspora ethnic Hungarians: “Orban granted citizenship and the right to vote in Hungarian elections to more than a million Hungarians living in neighbouring countries. At the last election, 95% of those who voted backed Fidesz.”

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/resources/idt-sh/Viktor_Orban

Re:EU ChatControl is back on the agenda by refurb on Saturday August 31, 2024 @09:06AM (#41408611)
Hungary lost vast swaths of territory after WW2. People who were Hungary citizens weren’t after the new borders were drawn.

I don’t see a big difference between that and Germany giving citizenship to all the people who were Germans prior to WW2, but weren’t after the war.

Re:EU ChatControl is back on the agenda by leadingthenet on Saturday August 31, 2024 @07:42AM (#41408123)
> Those Romanians are not Hungarian citizens.

Those “Romanians” are absolutely Hungarian citizens, as it is a precondition to voting in Hungarian elections.

Re:EU ChatControl is back on the agenda by perihelions on Saturday August 31, 2024 @07:30AM (#41408053)
- "votes from Hungarians outside Hungary (weird to vote for shit that does not affect you)"

I don't know if you're double-trolling or not, but it's pretty dehumanizing rhetoric to say people who've left their country for work or other reasons are not real citizens and presumptively have no stake in their own country's future.

(It's even stranger you apply this kind of–nativist?–language to a member state of the EU, where transnational ties are a founding ideal of that anti-nationalist union..)

Re:EU ChatControl is back on the agenda by defamation on Saturday August 31, 2024 @06:53AM (#41407884)
You can vote outside of any country pretty much if youre a citizen of that country. US included.
Re:EU ChatControl is back on the agenda by jkaplowitz on Saturday August 31, 2024 @07:26AM (#41408036)
Many countries do put restrictions on this. Some examples:

Until literally this year, the UK removed the right to vote after 15 years of living abroad, and Canada even used to restrict that right to just 5 years.

Even now, civilian US citizens living abroad whose intent to return to live in the US is uncertain, and Canadian citizens living abroad regardless of intent to return, are only federally guaranteed a right to vote from their last in-country address in federal elections, but often can't vote in state, provincial territorial, or local elections. This is true even if they retain significant ties to the relevant state, province, territory, or locality, like having close family there (including kids too young to vote for whom they're a legal parent), owning property there, operating a business there, or being owed a pension controlled by the relevant level of government.

And the guarantee of a right to vote from abroad in US federal elections is purely statutory, not constitutional - not to mention it has a few gaps in it, like citizens who have never lived in the US and neither of whose parents last lived in a state that allows the right to vote from abroad to descend to the next generation based on last parental residence.

Et cetera.

Re:EU ChatControl is back on the agenda by chgs on Saturday August 31, 2024 @08:36AM (#41408448)
Indeed the U.K. did not give the right to vote for U.K. citizens living in the EU when there was a vote about stripping their citizenship.
Re:EU ChatControl is back on the agenda by mike_hearn on Sunday September 01, 2024 @04:32AM (#41415245)
Yes they did. You could vote in the referendum from abroad (I did). There's no such thing as EU citizenship anyway, so nobodies citizenship changed as a result.
Re:EU ChatControl is back on the agenda by chgs on Sunday September 01, 2024 @06:13AM (#41415662)
Of course there is

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/European_Union_citizenship

Anyone living for more than 15 years was denied the right to vote but not denied the right to have their citizen forcibly removed against their will.

Re:EU ChatControl is back on the agenda by mike_hearn on Sunday September 01, 2024 @08:22AM (#41416384)
Well just go ahead and apply to Brussels to get your EU passport back then?

Obviously you can't, because there's no such thing as EU citizenship. It doesn't grant citizenship, and cannot because that would require it to be an independent nation recognized by other nations as such. There is only citizenship of member states. Playing with words doesn't make something real, it only confuses people.

Re:EU ChatControl is back on the agenda by chgs on Sunday September 01, 2024 @08:44AM (#41416547)
You can state your “alternate facts” all you want while ignoring actual truth, doesn’t make you right.
Re:EU ChatControl is back on the agenda by jkaplowitz on Sunday September 01, 2024 @06:03PM (#41420784)
You’re right indeed that there is a real legal concept in EU law called EU citizenship, which everyone with the nationality of an EU member state holds. The other commenter is wrong on that point.

But the other commenter is also right that there is not the kind of independently existent EU citizenship that would persist when one ceases to be a national of an EU member state - it gets lost in that case even if the reason for this change is not an individual loss of the member state’s nationality but because the member state withdrew from the EU. The ECJ definitively settled this last year. Nor are EU passports issued on the basis of EU citizenship, nor would EU citizens typically include “EU” as one of the answers if they are asked by a government to list all their citizenships or view themselves as dual citizens if their only national-level citizenship is from a single EU member state.

For several reasons like this, it’s not at all unreasonable for the other commenter not to view EU citizenship as a real citizenship of its own, despite the use of the term under EU law.

Personally, I view the term EU citizenship in part as a briefer shorthand for “national of an EU member state” - including in the definition whatever edge-case handling is appropriate for each country’s special-case territories, and therefore more precise in a predictable way. Beyond that, it’s just a symbolic reflection of the EU’s official aspirational policy goal of ever closer union.

Re:EU ChatControl is back on the agenda by vetinari on Saturday August 31, 2024 @07:00AM (#41407913)
> he uses the votes from Hungarians outside Hungary

That is pretty standard for EU voting; as long as you are citizen, you can vote, usually by mail or by visiting your embassy.

Otherwise, I happen to agree with you -- why you should vote, if you don't feel the impact of your vote?

> the people in cities are not voting for him

That's the common occurrence, people in cities are easier to influence due to density; US also has the Rural-Urban divide.

> he gets the votes from uneducated people

Yes, this is what the (modern|progressive|educated|whatever) tell to themselves to fell on high horse in their bubble.

Re:EU ChatControl is back on the agenda by TheChaplain on Saturday August 31, 2024 @07:12AM (#41407966)
> Otherwise, I happen to agree with you -- why you should vote, if you don't feel the impact of your vote?

Very strange attitude. I voted while I was abroad for two decades, because my family and friends were still there, and I wanted the best from them.

Re:EU ChatControl is back on the agenda by vetinari on Saturday August 31, 2024 @07:31AM (#41408063)
Your family and friends know, what is best for them and can vote for themselves.

Meanwhile, you are abroad and do not have clear idea about the local situation; you are going to have one of game of telephone one (I know, I also lived abroad for a while). As a result, you might do more damage than helping.

Re:EU ChatControl is back on the agenda by buran77 on Saturday August 31, 2024 @08:01AM (#41408235)
> you are abroad and do not have clear idea about the local situation

You're walking a path you're almost guaranteed not properly equipped for. Probably nobody is but knowing not to charge ahead would already mean a lot.

If having a clear idea about the local situation is a prerequisite then what happens with locals exposed to misinformation? Do they lose the right to vote? Do you test people in advance to evaluate their level of understanding? If they vote for populist measures that are clearly unsustainable did they show a good understanding of the situation?

What happens if you're abroad but coming back in a year and are expected to live with a bad situation you could have helped avoid? Can you claim "sorry, I wasn't allowed to vote so the rules don't apply to me"? What about when you live abroad but (some of) the laws of your home country in which you're not allowed to vote still apply to you?

And more importantly, if you're living abroad and you can't vote in your home country because you're away but you can't vote in your country of residence because you're a foreigner, what happens to your right to vote? This right is given to citizens of a country just like many other rights, like the right to private ownership. If one can be taken away due to lack of proximity, can the other? Can that car or house that you haven't used in a year be taken away? What if you as a local didn't exercise your right to vote, should it be taken away because you don't need it?

> you might do more damage

You might too.

Re:EU ChatControl is back on the agenda by simion314 on Saturday August 31, 2024 @09:43AM (#41408824)
My initial comment was not clear, by I am referring of Hungarian citizens that are part of other countries like Romania, this people do not have relatives in Hungary, never lived there, will not move there.
Re:EU ChatControl is back on the agenda by vetinari on Saturday August 31, 2024 @11:04AM (#41409394)
Is it still a thing? AFAIK the neighbor countries protested against it as a passport of convenience. Some even made laws, that when you accept such a citizenship, you are going to lose your previous one. That curbed the enthusiasm for such citizenship rather significantly.
Re:EU ChatControl is back on the agenda by simion314 on Saturday August 31, 2024 @11:23AM (#41409519)
It is still a thing, Romania also does the same thing where we give citizenship to Romanians on territories we lost like R. Moldova so would be hypocritical for Romania to complain about Hungary, ,my personal opinion is that is not democratic if someone votes but they or their family are not affected by the vote. It would be like some jerk In UK gifts citizenship to people in ex colonies and then those people as gratitude wll vote for the jerk.
Re:EU ChatControl is back on the agenda by vetinari on Saturday August 31, 2024 @11:01AM (#41409370)
Slow down, you are taking it way to seriously, and skipped to another rail already.

Nobody ever even remotely suggested to go where you describe. That when you live abroad you are not familiar with local situation is a fact; you get to hear only partial, selected info. Maybe you should try it sometime. I did.

> What happens if you're abroad but coming back in a year and are expected to live with a bad situation you could have helped avoid? Can you claim "sorry, I wasn't allowed to vote so the rules don't apply to me"? What about when you live abroad but (some of) the laws of your home country in which you're not allowed to vote still apply to you?

Here, again on another track.

Nobody is ever going to figure out, when you live when you vote. The difference is showing up in the polling station inside the country or not. I.e. with not being able to vote via mail or embassy.

Again, in our country, we have several different elections (just like in other countries). But in some, you have to vote locally, in others, you can do via correspondence. So when all of them are local only, no harm done. If you can bring your ass to the polling station, that's enough. Nobody is taking your right to vote, it is on you to decide, whether it is worth to you to exercise your right, or not.

Re:EU ChatControl is back on the agenda by simion314 on Saturday August 31, 2024 @09:46AM (#41408838)
>Yes, this is what the (modern|progressive|educated|whatever) tell to themselves to fell on high horse in their bubble.

Right, the peasants with no education and only watching state TV are clearly the ones without a bias, their children that went to university, got a good job, know english are the one brainwashed by CIA/Israel and the evil LGBTQ. I read so many cases of educated Hungarians or Russians ashamed of the level of brainwashing of their parents.

Re:EU ChatControl is back on the agenda by vetinari on Saturday August 31, 2024 @11:10AM (#41409435)
Yes, because the friculins (as in free-cool-in) in their reddit bubbles are so much more clever.

Case in point; any discussion involving policits here, on hn. Politologs are face palming at the naivety, when they see an extract.

Re:EU ChatControl is back on the agenda by simion314 on Saturday August 31, 2024 @11:30AM (#41409565)
If you would know Romanian I would share with you links my parents share with me and have you defend that bullshit to prove that my parents are the correct ones when they fall for the online bullshit like medical stuff (or you will claim that this less educated people are wrong when they fall for medical bullshit but when is about election they are correct).

Latest link from my father was a clip from some TV channel where some pretend doctor was claiming something super vague that is scientifically incorrect, this time I ignored it since I was not in the mood to try to find evidence that the guy is not a real doctor, that the vague shit is bullshit and find scientific shit to clarify things, and all would need to be in Romanian so he can understand.

For this old generation if is on TV or internet and some scammer pretends is a doctor and uses a few medical words they will fall for it, is the same with politics especially blaiming bad stuff on various groups, that stuff works well on the internet.

Give me an example where your or a friend uneducated pessant parents were actually correct in this kind of topics then their educated children that know more languages and read more media.

Re:EU ChatControl is back on the agenda by wkat4242 on Saturday August 31, 2024 @10:00AM (#41408926)
Yeah I wish that within the EU we could just vote for the country we live in rather than the one we were born in. It would make so much more sense.
Re:EU ChatControl is back on the agenda by vetinari on Saturday August 31, 2024 @11:07AM (#41409410)
You can, in the communnal (local) elections.

For the parliamentary, it is here for a reason. To prevent voting touristic. The delay of several years -- you have to live several years in the other country -- serves exactly that.

Re:EU ChatControl is back on the agenda by wkat4242 on Saturday August 31, 2024 @08:37PM (#41413171)
But there is no delay, even if I've been in Spain for 10 years I still can't vote for the parliament there.

I know about the local ones but it's not that important IMO.

I could go to the trouble of obtaining Spanish citizenship after 10 years but it is incredibly difficult and long.

I understand the problem of touristic voting but then they should let me vote here after 3 years or so.

Right now I can only vote for the Dutch government which I have nothing to do with in my life (and which is an extreme-right regime since the last election anyway)