Re:Secure Boot: Who will control your next computer?
by zokier on Wednesday June 20, 2012 @04:28PM
(#4138940)
The article nicely ignores the fact that on non-ARM platforms Secure Boot will be disableable.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Secure Boot: Who will control your next computer?
by ajross on Wednesday June 20, 2012 @04:53PM
(#4139035)
For some definition of "will", I guess. It's part of the windows logo requirements for x86. For now.
But what happens when someone screws up? I buy a laptop with a windows logo and try to install OpenBSD or whatnot, only to discover that the "disable secure boot" option is missing or broken. What's my recourse? Wait for a firmware update (which we know from experience will never arrive -- it boots fine in windows)? Return the laptop (which works perfectly within its warranted behavior)? Whine and look sad?
The incentives are all wrong for this to be a stable situation. Over time and platform changes, "disable secure boot" is going to rot. We all know it.
Re:Secure Boot: Who will control your next computer?
by zanny on Wednesday June 20, 2012 @06:10PM
(#4139385)
Also, we don't want secure boot as ARM moves into the more mainstream device space. We want Linux on ARM machines just as much as on x86. M$ is intentionally driving ARM boxes without the ability to change the OS to try to stop that inevitable growth.
Re:Secure Boot: Who will control your next computer?
by ams6110 on Wednesday June 20, 2012 @08:16PM
(#4139869)
Shop more carefully?
Re:Secure Boot: Who will control your next computer?
by ekianjo on Wednesday June 20, 2012 @08:27PM
(#4139898)
Well there will be some incentives for the manufacturers who do NOT support SecureBoot: they will get a better share on the market than their current one.
Re:Secure Boot: Who will control your next computer?
by rbanffy on Wednesday June 20, 2012 @10:46PM
(#4140272)
Sadly, that isn't enough. For everyone who understands how UEFI limits their freedoms, there is a dozen people who will say "look! shiny!".
Idiots will always outnumber smart people. Microsoft relies on that.
Re:Secure Boot: Who will control your next computer?
by ekianjo on Thursday June 21, 2012 @12:19AM
(#4140535)
Well the 4% share (or more) of future linux users who need a reliable Linux-PC is not so small if you consider the potential number of clients.
Surely some will take advantage of this situation, if everyone else rushes to have SecureBoot.