Re:What Is Post-Quantum Cryptography? – NIST
by Mistletoe on Wednesday August 28, 2024 @07:33PM
(#41385558)
Pretty sure all hell would break loose financially so there would definitely be signs. Think how much value is locked up behind cryptography.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:What Is Post-Quantum Cryptography? – NIST
by cj on Wednesday August 28, 2024 @07:48PM
(#41385655)
Presumably any organization/government smart enough to break cryptography would be smart enough not to do anything that would reveal their ability, unless they wanted their ability known.
Re:What Is Post-Quantum Cryptography? – NIST
by derekmhewitt on Wednesday August 28, 2024 @08:27PM
(#41385921)
This actually happened in WW2, after fully breaking the Enigma codes the Allies had to carefully choose which intelligence to act on and not act on, sometimes with poor results for their own side. But the alternative would have been that the Germans would have to conclude their communications were compromised and change something, rendering a lot of the effort to crack enigma in the first place moot. The Turing movie mentioned in another comment is excellent and touches on this topic.
Re:What Is Post-Quantum Cryptography? – NIST
by staunton on Wednesday August 28, 2024 @08:35PM
(#41385979)
> Think how much value is locked up behind cryptography.
It's actually "so much value" that it's not possible to take much of it if you reveal that you did. People can "fork (parts of) the financial system" even more easily (per actor) than what happens with cryptocurrencies.
Sure, it's a huge hassle with huge overhead but you cannot reveal the capability and also take more than that hassle is worth. I think this means that anyone capable of doing it would not reveal the ability as as a first priority, as others here have also suggested. Especially for a state actor, the trade-off is very clear.
Re:What Is Post-Quantum Cryptography? – NIST
by notfed on Wednesday August 28, 2024 @10:27PM
(#41386656)
It'd be sort of a funny situation if this happened now, because a fork necessarily rolls back recent transactions. So, imagine if people are made aware of a break, and it caused a bank run (on Bitcoin for let's say). Well, tons of transactions would be reversed, including peoples' attempt to cash out. If the attack repeats the next day, the fork would happen again. It'd be utter chaos.
Re:What Is Post-Quantum Cryptography? – NIST
by kortilla on Thursday August 29, 2024 @02:18AM
(#41387887)
There isn’t any going back until they have a version that supports different crypto (a hard fork). It’s not clear how you could possibly allow exits unless you literally ban all transactions on the chain after a certain date.
At that point though, why would anyone be on the buy side of the sell to USD?