News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Higher ultraviolet light exposure is associated with lowe... by OutOfHere on Tuesday August 20, 2024 @02:24PM (#41302568)
That is absolutely the right question to ask. If the results are not adjusted for vitamin D levels, and it does not appear that they are, then the results are largely useless because vitamin D is very easy to supplement.

Note: Adjusting by vitamin D levels is not the same as adjusting by supplemental intake. Even adjusting for supplemental intake must be a linear adjustment, not a binary one.

Re:Higher ultraviolet light exposure is associated with lowe... by jajag on Tuesday August 20, 2024 @02:30PM (#41302623)
That's an overly simplistic approach.
Re:Higher ultraviolet light exposure is associated with lowe... by Mistletoe on Tuesday August 20, 2024 @02:44PM (#41302752)
Vitamin d supplementation studies are a lot more ambiguous than this though. And this also matches my "feel". Getting sun makes me feel good in a way that vitamin D supplementation never does. I was once at a dinner and sitting at the table with the head of the Office of Dietary Supplements for the US government and asked him this question- "How should I get vitamin D and how much should I take?" He answered quite quickly "Get it from sunlight." Your skin autoregulates how much vitamin D is made this way.

"The health effects of vitamin D supplementation: evidence from human studies"

https://www.nature.com/articles/s41574-021-00593-z

I do think the question is complicated by the fact that humans have wildly different skin tones. What is applicable for skin types that are very pale is quite different than darker skin tones. This question has been complicated even more by recent migration of humans into zones their skin was never meant to be exposed to. It feels like the dermatologists all made their guidelines based on people with porcelain skin that live at the equator. The truth is more complicated than that, people with darker skin develop low vitamin D status follwing those guidelines. Humans love to have blanket rules they can follow without regard to extenuating circumstances like different skin tones, but that isn't reality.

Re:Higher ultraviolet light exposure is associated with lowe... by OutOfHere on Tuesday August 20, 2024 @03:15PM (#41303038)
> "Get it from sunlight."

Listening to such people in power is a path to getting yourself killed, in this case by diseases. Their interest is in preserving their power, first by taking it away from you. If you don't understand this now, I hope you will eventually. I am not saying this as a ring-wing nutcase, but to get you to think for yourself without bias from authority.

The study you linked is defective by design. It uses a threshold of 50 nmol/l which is a pathetically low 20 ng/ml. Such studies are engineered to show a null result.