I.e. they did thorough investigations and then determined whether the shipment ought to be successful or not, and then the rest laid in the hands of deities or nature, in ways they assumed were incalculable.
This normative perspective of what the future ought to be like is typical of statistical illiteracy.
I'll get back to you on sources after dinner!
There are what looks like fantastic books on the early days of probability and statistics aside from Weisberg (Ian Hacking is an author that comes to mind, and maybe Stephen Stigler?) but I have not yet taken the time to read them – I'll read more and write something up on this some day.
But statistical understanding is such a recent phenomenon that we have been able to document its rise fairly well[1] which is fascinating in and of itself.
[1]: And yet we don't know basic stuff like when the arithmetic mean became an acceptable way to aggregate data. Situations that obviously (to our eyes) call for an arithmetic mean in the 1630s were resolved some other way (often midrange, mode, or just a hand-picked observation that seemed somehow representative) and then suddenly in the 1680s we have this letter to a newspaper which uses the arithmetic mean as if it was the obvious thing to do and then its usage is relatively well documented after that. From what I understand we don't know what happened between 1630 and 1680 to cause this change in acceptance!
0 - https://www.amazon.com/Against-Gods-Remarkable-Story-Risk/dp...
Do you have a source on that? That sounds very unlikely to me. People just have to look at a single storm to see that it sometimes destroys some ships and does not destroy others. It is very clearly has a luck component. How could have anyone (at any time really) believe that "if you just learned enough about the voyage you could tell for certain whether it would be successful or not"?