Re:&udm=14 for Safari (iOS/iPadOS)
by shortformblog on Tuesday August 20, 2024 @07:45AM
(#41299092)
It harms the publishers and creators that actually built those sites that Google is extracting results from by costing them traffic and discouraging additional clicks. Over time, that discourages the quality of search results by depressing the market for new search-based information generated by humans.
To me, that’s a pretty good reason to stop using it, no matter if you “like” it.
Okay, so how does it do that exactly? As I said, I’m still clicking through, just as I was when all Google gave me was a text extract of each link. What’s the difference now?
If anything, I’m more likely to click through, because I trust the AI summary less than the text extract. So it seems like AI is actually driving traffic in this case, rather than diverting it.
Re:&udm=14 for Safari (iOS/iPadOS)
by shortformblog on Tuesday August 20, 2024 @08:06AM
(#41299247)
You are just one person with one set of habits. Google serves hundreds of millions of people daily, and the benefits publishers traditionally received from Google are in aggregate.
Okay… so? Why should I use or not use something on the basis of how you think other people might use it?
Re:&udm=14 for Safari (iOS/iPadOS)
by shortformblog on Tuesday August 20, 2024 @08:47AM
(#41299580)
Because publishers are telling you that it harms their business and you, as an individual who looks at the bigger picture, want to do the right thing.
Or you can just go for personal convenience. You do you.
Publishers also told me that Napster was destroying their business. And before that, VCRs. Public libraries too, for that matter. Do you always believe what publishers tell you?
Re:&udm=14 for Safari (iOS/iPadOS)
by shortformblog on Monday September 02, 2024 @09:14PM
(#41430240)
I’m a publisher. I am telling you this, personally.
But that was already true prior to the ai generated words at the top of the search results, and was a thing Google was fighting with publishers about.
Re:&udm=14 for Safari (iOS/iPadOS)
by shortformblog on Tuesday August 20, 2024 @07:55AM
(#41299155)
That just means it’s doubly true. The &udm=14 workaround also removes the featured snippets that discouraged Google’s role as a partner to publishers.
I feel not sure about the harmful nature of AI generated content, yes, it can be harmful for content farms, but I've always chosen to go deeper in arguments I was interested in, bringing traffic, because in the end, those responses are just overviews, so let's hope that AI will kill content farms once and for all
Re:&udm=14 for Safari (iOS/iPadOS)
by pavel_lishin on Tuesday August 20, 2024 @07:42AM
(#41299074)
If you don't trust it, why would you like it?
I never trusted the Google search results enough not to click through and verify their accuracy when it mattered, but I still like using Google? Not sure what your point is here.
On the whole I prefer the search results without it on iPhone, most of the time I know what I am looking for. If I want the AI results, I can simply reload the page with this extension disabled and see them. Basically, this extension returns control of the experience to the user.
Maybe I just haven’t been brainwashed enough yet to trust Google blindly (something I legitimately worry about and actively try to avoid) but as long as AI is obviously AI and is declared as such, I’m not sure it really bothers me.