> ignorant cops
This is an important, but orthogonal topic.We are talking about something fairly basic, so if our standards of policing are that it is excusable that a cop does not understand... the 4th amendment... then I'm not sure it is worth distinguishing from abuse. As such level of incompetence would necessitate willfulness.
> deceptive
I fail to understand how you are distinguishing an antagonistic cop who understands you are not breaking the law and is actively trying to trick you into (or trick you into revealing that you are despite no meaningful evidence that a crime is taking place) is different from one that is abusing their authority. I'd go so far as to say that this is a literal act of that.Look, I am happy you are willing to give the benefit of the doubt. We need people to provide such perspectives. In all honesty, I do appreciate your comment and that you are pushing back, but I think you'll need to take a significantly different route if you are to sway me. I think continuing down this train of reasoning will fail to persuade those with similar views. This does not mean there isn't an argument that would, just not this one.
It does not. You really should engage in a genuine debate.
Deception and abuse are not the same thing. It's perfectly legal for a cop to say "I'm searching your car, ok?". If you say "ok", you just consented. This is completely different that someone making up probable cause.
"Look, I am happy you are willing to give the benefit of the doubt."
No, I'm not. There are many situations and benefit of the doubt can only be applied to a few. It's simply incorrect from a logical perspective to frame the things you have as always being willful and corrupt. If you've had any experience with the law you will find that incompetence is rampant, but not usually willful. I understand that you may not be open minded, as evidenced in your hardline and unsupported generalized statements, but it's important for others to see these flaws.
> It does not.
There is a level of incompetence one can be at their job in which it is clear that they do not seek to do their job well. > You really should engage in a genuine debate.
You should respond to the things I say, not the things you wish me to say. Disagreement with you does not mean I am not being genuine, just as a circle jerk is not a genuine debate. > It's perfectly legal for a cop to say "I'm searching your car, ok?".
To again reference the level of incompetence... > The Fourth Amendment requires that before stopping the suspect, the police must have a reasonable suspicion that a crime has been, is being, or is about to be committed by the suspect.[0]
> The term “unreasonable” refers to any action or result that exceeds a reasonable expectation, or refers to anything beyond what would be considered “common sense.” In criminal cases, the prosecutor should explain the evidence so clearly that the average person would agree with it; if the logic of the prosecution or the certainty based on the given evidence could not be accepted by the common public, it would be unreasonable. [1]
Even if you disagree with the interpretation, I hope you are able to distinguish the difference between "what is right" and "what is legal". Because if your argument is "it is legal, therefor morally correct" we will never agree, just as I will not condone the actions of cheaters, and those that manufactured the housing crisis.In the US, we do have the presumption of innocence. Questioning to search without probably cause is, legal or not, an abuse of power.
I do wish you think deeply about what the "power" is that is being abused. What "authority" mean. Because if your argument is "it's legal" then I do not believe you understand this and I ask you to think a little deeper. Perhaps you're familiar with "malicious compliance?" That's enough of a hint.
And you can't apply that to everyone who is doesn't know every law.
"You should respond to the things I say, not the things you wish me to say."
Check the quotes then. You're making blanket statements without any backup.
'distinguish the difference between "what is right" and "what is legal".'
The question is about what is legal. If you know anything about the law, then you know it is a combative process. In order for the truth to come out it needs to be a fair fight between two sides. There is nothing wrong with asking to search if already engaged (reasonable suspicion). Just as there's nothing wrong with saying "no". There's no basis for that being immoral.
> And you can't apply that to everyone who is doesn't know every law.
If you're going to move the goal post can you at least keep it on the same planet so we can pretend this is civil?But you’re right, we shouldn’t be in this place as a nation, wondering if police are going to be ethical even most of the time.
Most police officers will bully you within the extent of their authority and try to deceive you into complying beyond their authority, but will not physically break the law.
With those police, being polite but firm is a good strategy.
- - - - -
Example: you’re in the parking lot of a business after hours, sitting there with a backpack; two officers in a cruiser park and get out to find out what you’re doing.
1. Well — legal or not, they’re going to detain you for a moment until they decide how to proceed
2. and they’ll pretend the only way to make that stop is let them search your bag to “prove you didn’t steal anything”
3. but if you politely repeat that you’re not consenting to any searches and would like to leave, they’ll let you go because at best they have probable cause for trespassing.
"most" is probably correct, but of course cops that don't break the law don't make the news because it's uninteresting.
I think the real problem we have is the cops that DO break the law and violate your rights and absolutely nothing happens.
A cop that searches your bag without probable cause or consent needs immediate retraining on the first offense, and needs to be fired on the second offense. If the cop gets fired and then gets hired as a cop somewhere else and commits the same offense, they need to be permanently banned from being a cop.
Again, this is not true. There are other situations where this info can be beneficial (ignorant cops or deceptive but not corrupt cops).