News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:"Frost Crack" Sounds May Come from Sky, Not Trees by karaterobot on Friday August 16, 2024 @10:55PM (#41271967)
> It’s not to say that trees don’t crack—but rather that spooky noises long attributed to trees may emerge from the night sky itself.

Well, it seems like he demonstrated that the night sky itself can make sounds under certain conditions, not that these sounds are always the night sky.

By the way, I don't recall ever hearing the supposed tree cracking sound in an area where there were no trees. If it's always just the sky, you'd expect to hear it at least occasionally on the plains, or coming from 250' in the air above you when you're on a frozen lake.

Re:"Frost Crack" Sounds May Come from Sky, Not Trees by maxbond on Saturday August 17, 2024 @12:16AM (#41272157)
[delayed]
Re:"Frost Crack" Sounds May Come from Sky, Not Trees by RHSeeger on Saturday August 17, 2024 @08:43AM (#41274157)
That quote seems odd to me. Specifically,

1. The sound is attributed to trees cracking

2. The cracking is caused by sap freezing and expanding

3. Sap freezing produces sound in the ultrasonic range

4. So it's not the trees

Point 4 is not a valid conclusion from 1-3, because it was never stated that the sap freezing is what is being heard. Rather, it's the trees cracking, which is _caused_ by the sap freezing... but its own thing with its own sound.

Re:"Frost Crack" Sounds May Come from Sky, Not Trees by nardi on Saturday August 17, 2024 @11:58AM (#41275427)
I think you missed the last bit:

> scientists have found no evidence this phenomenon might make sounds that are audible to the human ear.

Which I take to mean they’ve measured ultrasounds but no audible sounds.

Re:"Frost Crack" Sounds May Come from Sky, Not Trees by bmicraft on Saturday August 17, 2024 @01:59PM (#41276503)
"Found no evidence" and "didn't even try to measure" isn't really the same, is it?
Re:"Frost Crack" Sounds May Come from Sky, Not Trees by RHSeeger on Saturday August 17, 2024 @09:27PM (#41279433)
I'm not sure why you say I missed that. I didn't. Can you expand on what you meant by your reply.

To me, your reply actually highlights what I was talking about; because your use of "this phenomenon" is _somewhat_ ambiguous.

1. "this phenomenon" can be the sound of "large pressure splits in tree trunks, caused by sap freezing and expanding" (presumably audible to humans)

2. "this phenomenon" can be the sound of "freezing sap in trees" (presumably not audible to humans)

Re:"Frost Crack" Sounds May Come from Sky, Not Trees by solardev on Sunday August 18, 2024 @08:08AM (#41281856)
Seems like they would've recored both in the field, no? If they were recording sap freezing in the field, presumably the mics would pick up on other parts of the tree undergoing stresses and making audible sounds.

For that to have not been the case, either they would've had to freeze sap in the lab, or they would've had to go way out of their way to isolate recordings of just the sap in the field without the rest of the tree (is that even possible with normal recording tech?)

Re:"Frost Crack" Sounds May Come from Sky, Not Trees by tbugrara on Saturday August 17, 2024 @04:24PM (#41277674)
Point 4 seems to have been made by you, not the article.
Re:"Frost Crack" Sounds May Come from Sky, Not Trees by RHSeeger on Saturday August 17, 2024 @09:23PM (#41279423)
I guess maybe it depends on how you read it? To me, it read like

> This sound is often attributed to X. But <some component of X> doesn't make sound that humans can here.

The "people say it's this, but actually ..." reads, to me, like they're saying it's _not_ this. Which was point 4.

Re:"Frost Crack" Sounds May Come from Sky, Not Trees by dylan604 on Friday August 16, 2024 @11:26PM (#41272039)
> or coming from 250' in the air above you when you're on a frozen lake.

If you're on a frozen lake, you much prefer the crack coming from above than below.

Re:"Frost Crack" Sounds May Come from Sky, Not Trees by greenbit on Saturday August 17, 2024 @02:46AM (#41272490)
And then of course, there are the "ice making" sounds that do come from below. And different lakes and ponds even seem to have somewhat different voices in that way.
Re:"Frost Crack" Sounds May Come from Sky, Not Trees by idatum on Saturday August 17, 2024 @04:56PM (#41277890)
And something equally chilling -- the sound of a glacier cracking (more of a deep thud sound).
Re:"Frost Crack" Sounds May Come from Sky, Not Trees by rini17 on Saturday August 17, 2024 @04:18AM (#41272767)
Depends whether the landscape is prone to inversions. They happen most often in wide and enclosed valleys.
Re:"Frost Crack" Sounds May Come from Sky, Not Trees by slashtab on Saturday August 17, 2024 @04:42AM (#41272850)
Maybe trees are affecting the rate and intensity of Inversion.
Re:"Frost Crack" Sounds May Come from Sky, Not Trees by nuc1e0n on Saturday August 17, 2024 @08:27AM (#41274048)
Well thunder and lightning comes from the sky and lightning is caused by static effects of ice crystals in thunder clouds. So maybe it's something similar.