Re:LLM and Bug Finding: Insights from a $2M Winning Team in ...
by saagarjha on Saturday August 17, 2024 @12:37AM
(#41272206)
The real question here is who is willing to pay $10 million for such a bug.
Re:LLM and Bug Finding: Insights from a $2M Winning Team in ...
by tptacek on Saturday August 17, 2024 @02:10PM
(#41276612)
Nobody. That far exceeds the current market prices of the most in-demand bugs.
Re:LLM and Bug Finding: Insights from a $2M Winning Team in ...
by doctorpangloss on Saturday August 17, 2024 @02:57PM
(#41277021)
What is this market you speak of? Can you link me to it and show me the prices you are talking about? The Microsoft key vulnerability leaked all the State Department emails, and probably a lot more. It could have been used to compromise a lot of Azure. What is comparable?
Re:LLM and Bug Finding: Insights from a $2M Winning Team in ...
by necovek on Saturday August 17, 2024 @02:00AM
(#41272378)
It's not as simple: those billions of dollars are not just for this particular issue, or even just for security support.
It's also a difference between keeping a software engineer on staff and hiring a contractor as needed. One is cheaper for the company even if the hourly rate is higher.
The better question is how we can improve the overall security of the software we write, which this article is more focused on. But we understand that there will be bugs, and security bugs even, no matter how hard we try.
Even DJB (of qmail fame) and Knuth (of TeX and TAOCP fame) pay out bug bounties, and they heavily focus on software correctness over large feature sets.
So what should the prices really be? For which vulnerabilities? The SolarWinds issue is probably worth more than $10m, if people are willing to pay 100x more to CrowdStrike for nothing.