News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Judge tells Google: Play Store shakeup coming; punishment... by gjsman-1000 on Thursday August 15, 2024 @02:56PM (#41259241)
Simple.

Apple never allowed side loading, from the beginning, even when they had 0.0% market share. This means it’s basically impossible to show that they have illegally acted to maintain a monopoly - when they didn’t change anything. Having a monopoly is not illegal - changing things to keep a monopoly, is.

This came up during Apple vs Epic. Did Apple change the rate to 50% when they had a monopoly? No. Did Apple retroactively ban a major app category? No. Did Apple add various fees and fines that weren’t there from the beginning? No. Did Apple force IAP, when this wasn’t initially required? No.

Android, on the other hand, had a time before the Play Store and before the heavier restrictions on sideloading…

Re:Judge tells Google: Play Store shakeup coming; punishment... by throwaway48476 on Thursday August 15, 2024 @03:00PM (#41259261)
Never allowed without jailbreaking. My iOS 3 device still has Cydia.
Re:Judge tells Google: Play Store shakeup coming; punishment... by gjsman-1000 on Thursday August 15, 2024 @03:00PM (#41259269)
Jailbreaking and Unlocking phones was not even legal at the time, and did not receive a DMCA exemption until 2012, so it’s legally irrelevant.
Re:Judge tells Google: Play Store shakeup coming; punishment... by throwaway48476 on Thursday August 15, 2024 @11:54PM (#41263021)
If jailbreaking was ever illegal that just shows what a grip the copyright mafia has over this country.
Re:Judge tells Google: Play Store shakeup coming; punishment... by mvdtnz on Thursday August 15, 2024 @03:05PM (#41259308)
No, this is not the reason at all. Can you point to where in either lawsuit or decision this came up?

The fact is these were two different lawsuits with different judges with disagreeing outcomes. It's a real shame it happened this way - I feel no sympathy whatsoever for Google but it's unfair that Apple is free to continue their anticompetitive practices while their only potential competitor is going to be hamstrung. At least in USA.

Re:Judge tells Google: Play Store shakeup coming; punishment... by dagmx on Thursday August 15, 2024 @03:10PM (#41259349)
No, they were correct and you are not.

The cases are fundamentally different, and rest on the actions the two companies took.

Google actively harmed other stores. Apple has no other store to harm.

In the Google case, epic was able to prove anticompetitive behaviour. In the Apple case they could not prove anything outside of anti steering.

The judge doesn’t even need to factor in to the case at the point that Epic failed in the Apple case. They would have failed with any judge because their case was weakened by the lack of anti competition actions

Re:Judge tells Google: Play Store shakeup coming; punishment... by gjsman-1000 on Thursday August 15, 2024 @03:07PM (#41259321)
A. Listen to Virtual Legality for almost a day’s worth of legal analysis by an actual lawyer. This was a substantial part of the reasoning, and why Epic’s own claim of anti-competitive conduct imploded.

B. You’re assuming the facts are similar for Google, as to Apple, in regards to their legal standing. They are not.

Re:Judge tells Google: Play Store shakeup coming; punishment... by mvdtnz on Thursday August 15, 2024 @03:09PM (#41259340)
I'm not going to listen to "almost a day’s worth of legal analysis" no. If you have a link to a part of the decision I'd be happy to read it.
Re:Judge tells Google: Play Store shakeup coming; punishment... by dagmx on Thursday August 15, 2024 @03:30PM (#41259510)
I can’t find the published decision anymore but did read it, but there are several summaries of the discovery that show why Epic won

https://www.theverge.com/23959932/epic-v-google-trial-antitr...