News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Haiku OS (BeOS clone) by eloisant on Monday June 18, 2012 @07:29AM (#4125887)
Then why don't they keep the OS and API and write a brand new UI, like Apple did when they made OSX from Nextstep?
Re:Haiku OS (BeOS clone) by gecko on Monday June 18, 2012 @08:53AM (#4126146)
Well, they kind of are.

When OS X came out (both the Mac OS X Server 1.0 and Mac OS X 10.0 varieties), the UI might have looked different, but you were basically running OPENSTEP 5 with a new coat of paint. Haiku could do a new theme fairly easily at this point, and there are already quite a few touch-ups of the new-slab-of-paint variety (e.g., subpixel antialiasing, support for tiled windows, various improvements to OpenTracker).

The other thing that OS X brought to the table were new APIs, but most of these APIs weren't really user-visible per se. (E.g., QuickTime was a genuinely new addition to OPENSTEP, but the end-user would just see it as more videos played now, and they played with lower CPU usage.) Here, too, Haiku has delivered: it has new APIs for component layout, new APIs for end-user notifications, and more.

So your comparison to what Apple did with OS X is actually quite apropos. Be just hasn't felt a need to overhaul the UI as radically as Apple did in going from OPENSTEP to OS X--in large part because, while some of those changes were functional, many of them were more about making a statement than being genuinely easier-to-use. (Note how much OS X 10.6 and 10.7 have largely reverted to a kind of brushed-up version of the old Platinum interface: no more pinstripes, flat grey buttons in most cases, flat grey title bars, etc.) So I think they're doing exactly what they ought to be doing.

Re:Haiku OS (BeOS clone) by pkennedy on Monday June 18, 2012 @09:47AM (#4126361)
It's entirely time and money. They only have so many devs, most of whom have day jobs, and pretty limited funding to support them, so the UI (and many other polish-and-details things) had to take a back seat to more important core functionality.
Re:Haiku OS (BeOS clone) by geon on Monday June 18, 2012 @07:37AM (#4125918)
Because it is extremely much work, both in the research/prototyping/design and in the implementation. And when you are done, there are no apps that supports it.
Re:Haiku OS (BeOS clone) by hellerbarde on Monday June 18, 2012 @07:36AM (#4125915)
why don't you?

I assume they don't exacly have a huge community of active devs. combine that with the fact that user interface design is hard and needs experienced people working on it and you got the reason for cloning a perfectly functional UI instead of completely messing up while innovating a revolutionary new one.

This is pure conjecture, of course :)