News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A wonderful coincidence or an expected connection: why π²... by phkahler on Saturday August 10, 2024 @10:18AM (#41209708)
Doesn't the relationship hold if we change units? It seems like it must.

When I worked with electric water pumps I loved that power can be easily calculates from electrical, mechanical, and fluid measurements in the same way if you use the right units. VoltsAmps, torquerad/sec, pressure*flow_rate all give watts.

Re:A wonderful coincidence or an expected connection: why π²... by eigenket on Saturday August 10, 2024 @10:33AM (#41209807)
Nope, it completely vanishes in other units. If you do all your distance measurements in feet, for example, the value of pi is still about 3.14 but the acceleration due to gravity at the earth's surface is about 32 feet s^(-2). If you do your distance measurements in furlongs and your time measurements in hours then the acceleration due to gravity becomes about 630,000 furlongs per hour squared and pi (of course) doesn't change.
Re:A wonderful coincidence or an expected connection: why π²... by ValentinA23 on Saturday August 10, 2024 @10:59AM (#41209987)
Only because you're using metric seconds instead of "imperial seconds" (the time it takes for a 1 foot long pendulum to complete a full oscillation).
Re:A wonderful coincidence or an expected connection: why π²... by eigenket on Saturday August 10, 2024 @11:12AM (#41210079)
Sure, if you change either of the units you can always change the other one to fix the equation again.
Re:A wonderful coincidence or an expected connection: why π²... by koolala on Saturday August 10, 2024 @05:08PM (#41212222)
But does it work when you use the right Imperial technique?
Re:A wonderful coincidence or an expected connection: why π²... by ValentinA23 on Sunday August 11, 2024 @08:53AM (#41215806)
If I come up with my own measuring unit, let's call it the sneezle (whatever the actual length I assign to it) I will be able to also define a duration unit (say, the snifflebeat) based on the time it takes for a pendulum one sneezle long to complete a full oscillation, and vice versa I can define the sneezle by adjusting the length of a pendulum so that it oscillates in two snifflebeats. Here are the maths:

T = 2π√(l/g)

T/2π = √(l/g)

(T/2π)^2=l/g

g = l/(T/2π)^2

g = l/(T^2/4π^2) = 4π^2xl/T^2

Now substitue T with 2 and l with 1 an you get

g = 4π^2x1/2^2 = π^2

It doesn't matter what the pair of units assigned to T and l are. However, they'll be interrelated.

There is nothing arbitrary, and no coincidences behind g =~ π^2. It just requires to do some history of metrology and some basic maths/physics.

If you want to discuss coincidences, may I suggest you to comment on this remark I made and which hasn't received any attention yet ?

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41209612

Re:A wonderful coincidence or an expected connection: why π²... by koolala on Tuesday August 13, 2024 @11:14PM (#41242200)
Different planets, Different Sneezle length, Same Sneezle Beat

I'll try to see these units you linked thanks

Re:A wonderful coincidence or an expected connection: why π²... by mannykannot on Saturday August 10, 2024 @11:23AM (#41210157)
This is not quite the same situation, as you are calculating a value having a dimension (that of power, or energy per second) three different ways using a single consistent system of units, and getting a result demonstrating / conforming to the conservation of energy. If you were to perform one of these calculations in British imperial units (such as from pressure in stones per square hand and rate of flow in slugs per fortnight) you would get a different numerical value (I think!) that nonetheless represents the same power expressed in different units. The article, however, is discussing a dimensionless ratio between a dimensionless constant and a physical measurement that is specific to one particular planet.
Re:A wonderful coincidence or an expected connection: why π²... by usaar333 on Saturday August 10, 2024 @11:11AM (#41210073)
No, the equality requires the length of a 2 second period pendulum be g / pi^2. Change your definition of length - that no longer holds true.

g in imperial units is 32 after all. g has units; pi does not

Re:A wonderful coincidence or an expected connection: why π²... by lupire on Saturday August 10, 2024 @11:35AM (#41210215)
A more natural way to say it is that equality requires that the unit of length is the length of an arbitrary pendulum and the unit of time is the half-period of the same pendulum.

The pendulum is a device that relates pi to gravity.

Re:A wonderful coincidence or an expected connection: why π²... by koolala on Saturday August 10, 2024 @05:13PM (#41212247)
Sounds universal. Get a different value on the Moon? Of course... pi squares differently on the moon :)
Re:A wonderful coincidence or an expected connection: why π²... by theginger on Saturday August 10, 2024 @08:00PM (#41213080)
The arbitrary length pendulum with a period of 2 seconds which is your unit of length, (or 1 Catholic meter) is much shorter on the moon. In local Catholic meters gravity would be pi squared Catholic meters / second. As it would on any planet.
Re:A wonderful coincidence or an expected connection: why π²... by koolala on Tuesday August 13, 2024 @11:09PM (#41242175)
I think I understand. Distance scales with Planet Size? That actually makes a lot of sense.
Re:A wonderful coincidence or an expected connection: why π²... by phkahler on Saturday August 10, 2024 @01:33PM (#41210962)
The equation holds in imperial units as well. The length of the 2 second pendulum needs to be in feet AND the value of g in ft/sec2.
Re:A wonderful coincidence or an expected connection: why π²... by SAI_Peregrinus on Saturday August 10, 2024 @04:10PM (#41211870)
π^2 ≈ 32 to you?
Re:A wonderful coincidence or an expected connection: why π²... by koolala on Saturday August 10, 2024 @05:10PM (#41212233)
Replace s in your calculation with imperial s instead of metric s and it isn't imperial feet per metric seconds.
Re:A wonderful coincidence or an expected connection: why π²... by SAI_Peregrinus on Saturday August 10, 2024 @07:54PM (#41213059)
Imperial seconds were very, very close to metric seconds.
Re:A wonderful coincidence or an expected connection: why π²... by phkahler on Saturday August 10, 2024 @05:39PM (#41212415)
Solving the equation for pi we get:

PI = sqrt(g/L)

g = 9.81. L=1

or

g = 32.174. L=3.174

Either way works to approximately pi. There is a particular length where it works out exactly to pi which is about 3.2 feet, or about 1 meter. My point was that equations like that remain true regardless of units.

The reason pi squared is approximately g is that the L required for a pendulum of 2 seconds period is approximately 1 meter.