Re:DARPA wants to bypass the thermal middleman in nuclear po...
by thayne on Friday August 09, 2024 @08:13PM
(#41206449)
I think in a Deutritium-Tritium fusion reaction a lot the energy is in the neutron. And since neutrons are neutral you can't really directly convert that into electrical energy.
Re:DARPA wants to bypass the thermal middleman in nuclear po...
by DennisP on Friday August 09, 2024 @09:02PM
(#41206622)
Yep, for D-T 80% of the energy is in neutrons. Helion is using D-D/D-He3, and for that it's about 5% in neutrons, and most of the rest in fast-moving charged particles.
So they have a simple way to extract electricity directly. They squeeze the plasma with a magnetic field from a copper coil, then there's an explosion of charged particles, which pushes back against the magnetic field and causes electricity to flow in the coil.
Re:DARPA wants to bypass the thermal middleman in nuclear po...
by sigmoid10 on Monday August 12, 2024 @02:41AM
(#41221715)
D-D (which they are going for right now) is still 50% neutrons. D-He3 is the only aneutronic reaction, but it has tons of other issues.
Re:DARPA wants to bypass the thermal middleman in nuclear po...
by DennisP on Monday August 12, 2024 @06:30PM
(#41230093)
As I said, the combined reaction generates 5% of its energy as neutron radiation. The reason it's only 5% is that D-He3 is a much more energetic reaction.
The main issue with D-He3 is that it's more difficult.
Re:DARPA wants to bypass the thermal middleman in nuclear po...
by sigmoid10 on Tuesday August 13, 2024 @10:23AM
(#41235762)
That's what I said. But all things equal, D-D is definitely not the best path for direct energy production because of the vast amount of neutrons.
Re:DARPA wants to bypass the thermal middleman in nuclear po...
by selectodude on Friday August 09, 2024 @07:26PM
(#41206237)
I think the concepts are the same but the execution (heat up water with plasma) is still a work in progress.
Re:DARPA wants to bypass the thermal middleman in nuclear po...
by Intralexical on Friday August 09, 2024 @07:30PM
(#41206260)
That's the "thermal middleman" part they're trying to cut out.
By analogy, compare Concentrated Solar Power versus Photovoltaics.
Is the direct energy capture part also harder for glowy fusion gas than scary fission rocks?