Re:Please do not attempt to simplify this code
by mckn1ght on Wednesday August 07, 2024 @03:00AM
(#41178885)
I’m not sure brevity and explicitness are totally orthogonal, explicit sort of implies spelling things out in a longer way. That doesn’t mean that something that is long is thorough, however.
I like the tradeoff the Swiftlang project talks much about: brevity vs clarity (because explicit doesn’t necessarily mean clear, either, as your example shows). I think those are more orthogonal concerns, both important to think about, for different reasons that may often compete.
I never could understand that code. I know it wasn't brief, does that mean it was explicit?
I think the truth is brevity and explicitness are orthogonal. Let me ask you this: can code be both brief and explicit? What would that look like?