* Threatening a lawsuit against The Oatmeal, who in turn responds with charity and humor does not make FJ seem cool.
* DDG is obviously returning some pretty bad relevance, considering a search for "the oatmeal" on Google doesn't return a single reference to FJ except in the News section talking about what huge dicks they are. This is not positive SEO. Also, when I search DDG in an empty session, I only get 2/6, not 4/6, so either they've already fixed this oversight or you're getting some unique results because of your history.
* FJ does not get DMCA protections. As pointed out in the above letter, they don't have a DMCA agent on file, which means that even though Inman isn't going to go after them, as a result of this bogus legal threat against him, they've just painted a big bullseye on themselves. Anyone who feels like they want to pile on and get some free money out of FJ can now point to their works being online and sue. Someone less courteous could extract up to $150,000 per infringement, especially since there is clearly commercial intent behind this "unauthorized sharing".
I hate to say it, but you've completely read this situation wrong, and if anything, The Oatmeal has come out with vastly more positive press from this than FJ ever will.
Best homophone mistake ever.
Probably they didn't expect TO to draw attention to it, but didn't they have this exact same exposure before?
Wait a minute, wasn't Megaupload talking about filing some kind of lawsuits against content owners right before they were raided?
> The Oatmeal has come out with vastly more positive press
Oh absolutely. I didn't say anything about press TO might have received or that FJ had received anything but tons of negative press for it.
But FJ needed press and they got it. The question is in what ways is FJ actually worse off for having it been negative press which they received?
What's that based on? Their traffic has almost tripled in the last year. They publish their traffic statistics, as you can see here: http://funnyjunk.com/stat/
Yesterday they had 23,282,449 page views. 1 year ago today they had 9,978,711 page views.
That's a little different. That is more like "keep your enemies closer" type situation. Different strategy it's like a news outlet pissing off the White House in order to have a sensational story and then having access cut off.
As I've said before things like this are like wd-40. The carrier wears off and the active ingredient remains to provide the benefit.
"consider how little people are going to remember about this incident in just a few weeks."
Exactly. One of the reasons people pick fights with market leaders. It gets them exposure. Even if they loose the fight.
* Legal fees for sending a couple of threating letters.
What have they gained?
* A full-page spread in The Oatmeal advertising the fact to all readers of Slashdot, HN, and many other social media sites that Funnyjunk exists, carries user-submitted comics such as would be interesting to readers of The Oatmeal, and are friendlier to content submitters than they are to the DMCA.
* Massive SEO links. Four out of the first six search results for "the oatmeal" from DDG refer to Funnyjunk. Funnyjunk has an entire section on http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Oatmeal#FunnyJunk_legal_dis... and an entire article dedicated to the dispute.
Now most of us want to believe "But this is negative publicity and Funnyjunk couldn't possibly want that". But before you conclude that, consider how little people are going to remember about this incident in just a few weeks. For example, do you remember even today the name of the Funnyjunk CEO or of his lawyer? I don't, but I remember Funnyjunk whereas I had never heard of it at all before. I've even been to their site several times now (following up on links posted at The Oatmeal).
I hate to say it, but this was brilliant and The Oatmeal fell for it.