News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Stop Killing Games – Almost at 160k signatures by usrbinbash on Monday August 05, 2024 @06:31AM (#41159799)
Someone please define "reasonable playable state".

Because, for something like an MMORPG, "playable" means being able to run a server. So, what does "playable" entail? Source and internal sysops documentation? That isn't "playable" for the vast majority of people. Working binary? Now you may be required to develop these specifically for consumer hardware, and/or in different versions.

Example: MOBAs with ladders and matchmaking algorithms. You will likely need a separate server architecture that works independently of the userlist and matchmaking system. Bear in mind these systems are usually not made to be modular, they are custom-built to work in a given environment.

Not saying that it cannot be done, I am also supporting the idea, but there should be a VERY CLEAR definition of what counts as "reasonable playable state".

Re:Stop Killing Games – Almost at 160k signatures by beltsazar on Monday August 05, 2024 @06:46AM (#41159903)
I think it aims mainly at games that use an online connection as a DRM mechanism, such as Hitman 3 and Gran Turismo 7. Both games are single player games that shouldn't necessitate online connection in the first place.
Re:Stop Killing Games – Almost at 160k signatures by worble on Monday August 05, 2024 @07:24AM (#41160159)
>but there should be a VERY CLEAR definition of what counts as "reasonable playable state".

There's a weird idea online that laws are super specific and technical and that if you don't nail things down exactly people can side-step and go "wahaha I didn't break any rules!" when that's simply not the case.

Laws are more general and very much about the spirit of actions, and then the specificities get proven in court down the line. Those cases then get referenced in further court actions and end up informing the law overall, without having to have hyper specific wording for all edge-cases enshrined forever. This also provides fluidity for a changing and evolving legal and social system as a judge can take the specifics of that case into account. Every games definition of playable is going to be different, you can't codify something like that.

Re:Stop Killing Games – Almost at 160k signatures by jcranmer on Monday August 05, 2024 @07:33AM (#41160230)
Europe is a civil law system, which places much higher prominence on proper codification of law than the common law systems common in the Anglosphere, which is generally closer to the procedure you're talking about.
Re:Stop Killing Games – Almost at 160k signatures by sighinggoldfish on Monday August 05, 2024 @07:47AM (#41160331)
Yes, this is correct. But an ECI just requires that something happen from the Commission. In fact, revisions are basically expected if the Commission decides legislation is the path forward as past successful ECIs have demonstrated.
Re:Stop Killing Games – Almost at 160k signatures by NoboruWataya on Monday August 05, 2024 @08:47AM (#41160871)
If you look at EU laws you'll still find plenty of examples of primary legislation setting out general, high-level concepts, which are then given more specificity in delegated regulations, regulatory guidance or court decisions.
Re:Stop Killing Games – Almost at 160k signatures by galdosdi on Monday August 05, 2024 @10:40AM (#41161788)
It may not be a total coincidence that the common law based UK and US became so much more dominant in commerce. Obviously their imperial holdings had a lot to do with other factors too, like the UK's early lead in the industrial revolution, and the US's massive natural resources, but it's hard to ignore the advantage of a more nimble, flexible, yet predictable legal system for commerce in a time of rapidly changing technology.
Re:Stop Killing Games – Almost at 160k signatures by snowpid on Monday August 05, 2024 @11:11AM (#41162094)
UK is one the poorer countries in Western Europe and it has oil.
Re:Stop Killing Games – Almost at 160k signatures by galdosdi on Monday August 05, 2024 @02:02PM (#41163706)
Sorry if it wasn't obvious, I was talking about the historical UK that owned and operated the British Empire up until the world wars and then almost seamlessly ceded the mantle to the US.

I bet you also are unable to learn any lessons from the ancient Roman empire since Rome is now just some touristy city with a lot of litter, or something?

The US produces around 13% of the world's oil today (and also produced most of the oil and gas for a period when it was new), around the same as Saudi Arabia, and has constantly benefitted from its natural resources (not just oil-- even going back to trees and iron ore)

But none of those things are in any way central to my point-- the advantage of being in a common law country when you run a business in a complex evolving commercial industry, so you can both depend on reliable consistent law, but also expect it to naturally and flexibly extend itself to new situations faster and more consistently with older expectations than a political legislature possibly can.

Re:Stop Killing Games – Almost at 160k signatures by snowpid on Monday August 05, 2024 @04:55PM (#41165514)
Well, Continental law was strongly inspired by Roman law and Roman law was prefered by Europea law experts when England was an Island kingdom while Roman Empire was ... An Empire. I don't think you are an expert in law systems comparision and your statements seems to be very broad and unsourced. (random economical number isn't a source)

Some companies like BASF struggle in the American law environment in a combination of jury responsibility (very old concept!), high penalties and jury don't have any clue about science.

I've never heard any such complaint about the European law systems.

Re:Stop Killing Games – Almost at 160k signatures by andybak on Monday August 05, 2024 @06:42AM (#41159876)
I think massively online games are the tricky part.

I'd be happy if this stopped publishers killing games were small teams on a private server were viable.

Hell - I've had games I bought killed where there was a viable single player mode. There's no justification for that.

Re:Stop Killing Games – Almost at 160k signatures by helloiamsomeone on Monday August 05, 2024 @10:41AM (#41161807)
What exactly is tricky about MMOs? World of Warcraft private servers are a thing and there are many more MMOs with private servers.

The tricky part for private servers right now is someone having to apply elbow grease, reverse engineer things, while the publisher has the legal power to shut it down and punish people for trying to bring back a dead game they don't even support anymore.

Re:Stop Killing Games – Almost at 160k signatures by whstl on Monday August 05, 2024 @06:39AM (#41159853)
The FAQ mentions does "server emulators" made by fans, so "reasonably playable" could possibly mean just removing restrictions to using those. Basically removing the phone-home restrictions.

Keeping the game working but offline-only also seems to be a suggestion, the list of "real-world examples of publishers ending support for online-only games in a responsible way" include some games that are playable offline-only.

But your point stands, this should be discussed with more clarity before turning into law.

https://www.stopkillinggames.com/faq

Re:Stop Killing Games – Almost at 160k signatures by ffsm8 on Monday August 05, 2024 @06:44AM (#41159883)
This isn't a draft for a law though, this is a petition to create such a draft. These kinds of critique are kinda premature - even if they're done by Internet famous people like pirate software
Re:Stop Killing Games – Almost at 160k signatures by whstl on Monday August 05, 2024 @08:45AM (#41160858)
Yes, I totally agree.
Re:Stop Killing Games – Almost at 160k signatures by johnnyanmac on Monday August 05, 2024 @04:13PM (#41165087)
If it causes enough in-fighting to turn people off, then I'd say the critiques are needed. There's already so much going against the law without the people themselves wondering if this would force their favorite MMO to shut down.
Re:Stop Killing Games – Almost at 160k signatures by CRConrad on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @04:45AM (#41168924)
What does this:

> These kinds of critique are kinda premature - even if they're done by Internet famous people like pirate software

mean? “Internet famous people like pirate software” — is “pirate software” a person on the Internet, or what?

Re:Stop Killing Games – Almost at 160k signatures by ffsm8 on Wednesday August 07, 2024 @03:16PM (#41184405)
He's a twitch streamer that usually gets around 15-30 thousand concurrent viewers while he develops and plays indie games live, on-stream

This was his video after he ranted for a while live.

https://youtu.be/ioqSvLqB46Y?si=Iggw95x1fnZvBJ3O

His issues boil down to

1. it's too broad/non-specific, that makes it bad for developers and will harm the industry

2. The announcement/marketing video for this initiative had several questionable points in it which make the industry look bad

Re:Stop Killing Games – Almost at 160k signatures by CRConrad on Sunday August 11, 2024 @02:10PM (#41218161)
Yeah yeah, but that doesn't explain the grammar of the sentence fragment I quoted and italicized. I still don't understand what that bit is supposed to mean. Can you explain it?
Re:Stop Killing Games – Almost at 160k signatures by ffsm8 on Monday August 12, 2024 @10:49AM (#41225044)
My comment explained what he is, with a small note of what he usually does and a summary of his points, what more could you conceivably want answered?

Click on the provided link if you can't understand what I wrote and take notice of his username.

Re:Stop Killing Games – Almost at 160k signatures by jcranmer on Monday August 05, 2024 @07:51AM (#41160372)
I agree. This is a heavily vibes-based petition, seemingly designed to be emotive at the expense of clarity. Is it about DRM stopping games from working? MMOs being shut down? Live services dying?

In the best case scenario, this would be relatively narrowly targeted at something like DRM servers, requiring a final patch to strip DRM. What I fear is more likely to happen is that you end up with something with loopholes that causes many more games to go down the SimCity (the shitty version) route of faux online features to get them to fall into some sort of online-required carve-out. Or you end up with the GDPR route, where the big names will violate it anyways and just don't care about the penalties for doing so.

Re:Stop Killing Games – Almost at 160k signatures by jwueller on Monday August 05, 2024 @12:49PM (#41163021)
"No planned obsolescence" seems like a pretty clear goal to me. No carve-out for online games required.

They don't care about GDPR penalties? I'm going to need a source for this one.

Re:Stop Killing Games – Almost at 160k signatures by johnnyanmac on Monday August 05, 2024 @04:17PM (#41165139)
Funny thing is server shutdowns are rarely as "planned" out as you'd imagine. Look at GameInformer as we speak. In less than 1 business day the staff was kicked out with no warning, its 20+ year old website taken down, and its twitter handle deleted, hours after making a goodbye statement. This was clearly not planned more than a month in advance by Gamestop. Planned Obscolecense implies (if not, is outright defined) as designing a product to fail in a specific amount of time. No game service worth its salt is designed to shut down in 6 months (you can probably find some chinese asset mills to prove me wrong. so take a charitable interpretation of "worth its salt")
Re:Stop Killing Games – Almost at 160k signatures by account42 on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @08:46AM (#41170340)
There may be premature shutdown but no buiness plans to run servers for free forever. Ongoing server costs will be part of the business plan from the start.
Re:Stop Killing Games – Almost at 160k signatures by CRConrad on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @04:49AM (#41168947)
> This is a heavily vibes-based petition, seemingly designed to be emotive at the expense of clarity. Is it about DRM stopping games from working? MMOs being shut down? Live services dying?

Por que no los dos?

Both are dick moves, verging on fraud if you've made money by ostensibly “selling” something that the customer finds themselves not actually owning, aren't they? Why should either of them be legal?

Re:Stop Killing Games – Almost at 160k signatures by armarr on Monday August 05, 2024 @06:34AM (#41159821)
Legislation is always intentionally vague so that edge cases can prove themselves in court. I think they made the right choice by adapting the demands and wording to something that appeals to legislators.
Re:Stop Killing Games – Almost at 160k signatures by sighinggoldfish on Monday August 05, 2024 @07:42AM (#41160295)
Online games that aren't sold as services (like WoW with a subscription) wouldn't need to work online or with servers. The bare minimum this asks for is some state of playable which could include just the ability to run around on the map on a local machine... Ross Scott has talked about this a lot. We would love more, but we are asking for bare minimum.

I'm really skeptical of modern online infra. I've worked on two MMOs as a Tech Artist and the way artists, designers, etc worked on the game was with a local only build! One of these companies actually barred WAN access from our dev machines so LAN only also worked for internal playtests! Trends to make dev builds online only are quite awful for developers in the trenches and are more about exec control than any usefulness added by such requirements.

Complex server infrastructure that you mention is also not needed if you ask me, at least not to the point to make it too hard to widely ship. I'd be fine if someone still had to stand up a centralized matchmaking server still, just allow any player to do it.

As an example, compare Helldivers 2 and WoW. WoW is vastly more complex but Helldivers 2 uses more modern cloud "tech" that didn't exist 20 years ago. Both had issues keeping up with player demand on launch. So what's the point of this newfangled tech? Well, it's devs convincing players they're getting a better service or good (don't know which!) and that this complexity based lock in is worth it. And it's also cloud providers like AWS and Azure convincing devs to create architectures like this which lock devs into these platform holders. I'm not convinced were seeing real improvements on the dev or player side... Scamming turtles all the way down if you ask me.

It also turns out a lot of this stuff is able to reverse engineered. I'm right now playing original Demons Souls with full multiplayer connectivity (including matchmaking from a central private server) which required PSN support of the PS3 days. WoW private servers also required a great deal of reverse engineering. If online randos can do it...

Plus WoW private servers literally revealed a new revenue stream to Blizzard in the form of WoW classic: "After a month or so of large scale protests, Blizzard invited the Nostalrius team to the Blizzard HQ to present the case for Vanilla. An eighty-page "post-mortem" document describing the development of Nostalrius, the problems that happened and some marketing strategies was presented to Blizzard, and after some time, released on the Nostalrius forums" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/World_of_Warcraft_Classic

Others have also mentioned middleware licenses as a problem. Those licenses would adapt just fine. A single game will ship with multiple binaries of RAD Tools, Havok, SpeedTree, etc. So now a player has potentially hundreds of copies of different versions of all these binaries and libraries. This is a completely solvable problem that won't stifle development or even require leaking of trade "secrets".

Also, this is relatively new problem in the industry. The market grew just fine allowing for players to use their goods more freely. That any such regulation would hurt the industry is dubious at best, corporate speak at worst. In fact, I'd argue that enabling player freedom an creativity over their purchased goods has helped the industry grow to where it is today! Counter Strike was a mod, TF2 was a mod, PUBG was a mod (Fortnite wouldn't exist with out it), DOTA was a mod! Minecraft in part exploded cause of mods. A healthy and innovative free market demands player and user freedom!

Re:Stop Killing Games – Almost at 160k signatures by maccard on Monday August 05, 2024 @08:47AM (#41160876)
> I've worked on two MMOs as a Tech Artist and the way artists, designers, etc worked on the game was with a local only build! One of these companies actually barred WAN access from our dev machines so LAN only also worked for internal playtests! Trends to make dev builds online only are quite awful for developers in the trenches and are more about exec control than any usefulness added by such requirements.

I'm an online dev for multiplayer games, and I disagree with your take. In my experience the sheer number of bugs we've seen from "I tested it in the local only build mode so it's fine" and the impact that has on the project makes it worth _not_ supporting an offline mode. I'm not an exec, but practicing good habits during development (there's a phase where it's not worth it sure, but by the time you're on a live project...) makes actually building a game easier.

> As an example, compare Helldivers 2 and WoW. WoW is vastly more complex but Helldivers 2 uses more modern cloud "tech" that didn't exist 20 years ago. Both had issues keeping up with player demand on launch. So what's the point of this newfangled tech?

https://x.com/Pilestedt/status/1760077808146014340 - helldivers backend team was 4 people. _That's_ the point of this newfangled tech.

> Those licenses would adapt just fine.

Handwaving away this problem doesn't make it just og away.

Re:Stop Killing Games – Almost at 160k signatures by sighinggoldfish on Monday August 05, 2024 @10:55AM (#41161945)
> I'm an online dev for multiplayer games, and I disagree with your take. In my experience the sheer number of bugs we've seen from "I tested it in the local only build mode so it's fine" and the impact that has on the project makes it worth _not_ supporting an offline mode. I'm not an exec, but practicing good habits during development (there's a phase where it's not worth it sure, but by the time you're on a live project...) makes actually building a game easier.

Both should be available cause yes, you need to test like you said. But if I'm setting up skinning on a character or cloth simulation on a cape, I want my turn around time as fast as possible from DCC to engine. Maybe I just want to validate my PBR materials with a specific level's lighting rig and baked GI/reflection probes. Those specific examples are client side only, so I absolutely want that to work on an offline build. The longer a roundtrip to the engine takes for content (including the time it takes to start the game up), the harder it is to iterate and thus quality also falls. Forcing online always for devs at the very least, makes booting the game slower (or just fail) and you need to reboot the game constantly (even with hot reload). That cost adds up quick across many devs and many years. You need both lest you drive your artists and TAs insane. My last company hemorrhaged artists to literally go work next door on very similar styled art content from one live service game to another just because our tools were so exhausting to them to roundtrip, and online wasn't even forced!

>https://x.com/Pilestedt/status/1760077808146014340 - helldivers backend team was 4 people. _That's_ the point of this newfangled tech.

WoW took 4-5 years to develop with "The original World of Warcraft was created by a team of 40 people, which eventually doubled in size as the launch drew close." https://www.polygon.com/2020/1/20/21070494/world-of-warcraft...

Where as as Helldivers 2 has about 100 devs at the end of development taking 8 years according to their CEO. So not seeing the wins there. In terms of concurrent players around launch, WoW had around 0.5 million within months and Helldivers 2 seemed to have peaked at 0.75 million across PC and PS5. 19 years apart and not really seeing that 5x in practice... None of this suggests to me that this "tech" is a useful as many think.

> Handwaving away this problem doesn't make it just og away.

I mean, we have tons of precedent of these middleware licenses working just fine when redistributed as binaries to users' devices, so how is this handwavy? Like yes, there's an issue with already shipped games that make use of such licenses, but after such a law passes, the licenses will have to adapt to licenses similar to what already exist. And prior to this recent problem in games, middleware licenses worked just fine too and often shipped with server binaries. These licenses are not the norm as explained by all the middleware that does get packaged with almost every game today...

Re:Stop Killing Games – Almost at 160k signatures by maccard on Monday August 05, 2024 @12:06PM (#41162607)
Providing testbed maps for rapid iteration and is not the same thing at all as allowing you to play offline.

> WoW took 4-5 years to develop with "The original World of Warcraft was created by a team of 40 people, which eventually doubled in size as the launch drew close."

You’re moving the goalposts here. You asked about cloud tech initially. The topic of “have game budgets and teams gotten out of control” is a totally different one.

> so how is this handwavy?

These aren’t just game middleware technologies that we’re talking about - things like Java, SQL Server, have non distributable licenses. Systems like LaunchDarkly require active subscriptions and don’t allow for redistribution and are often deeply embedded in applications.

> And prior to this recent problem in games, middleware licenses worked just fine too and often shipped with server binaries

Some games still do ship with server binaries. Valheim is a good example. But, to your point earlier about WoW vs Helldiverd - games aren’t developed the same way as they were “prior to this recent problem”, player behaviour and expectations have changed. You can’t just go back to the way things were here any more than you can with social media, banking, email, movie rentals, etc.

Re:Stop Killing Games – Almost at 160k signatures by sighinggoldfish on Monday August 05, 2024 @01:52PM (#41163614)
> Providing testbed maps for rapid iteration and is not the same thing at all as allowing you to play offline.

Sure, but I mean, at this point, I'll even take a guarantee that I can just run around on a map without spawns just so the world art is preserved. The initiative is pretty broad about what it means to be playable for this reason. Actually, that's the whole point of this initiative is to establish such a bare minimum. And if the game is truly a service, and not a good, than this wouldn't even apply! Companies would just have to be explicit about the service nature of the product which they are not unless you pay a subscription like in the WoW case, which this doesn't affect. So you could still do all this tight coupling that is apparently good for development and ship games just fine if players are properly informed on the service nature (which means some kind of expectation for how long the service will last). I agree that a testbed map isn't the same as playing offline, but I don't agree that it's preferred, or even natural, that development require that offline play be so arduous to accomplish. Especially when something as complex as WoW or PSN matchmaking + a game's specific netcode (Demons Souls PS3 emulation case) can be reverse engineered without any support from devs. Most arguments along the lines of "it's just too technically difficult" do not past the smell test to me.

> You’re moving the goalposts here. You asked about cloud tech initially. The topic of “have game budgets and teams gotten out of control” is a totally different one.

I feel like I pretty succinctly explained that this tech did not provide a huge boost in productivity in development nor did it allow for substantially more scalability of players. Not sure how that's moving the goalpost. You posted a tweet highlighting 4 people allowed for 5x the player capacity in a week. I don't know how many multiplayer engineers worked on WoW pre initial launch but considering the team was smaller than Arrowhead, I doubt it's significantly more than 4 and their concurrent player numbers around launch weren't significantly different (certainly not 5x). I get that Blizzard probably predicted bigger launch numbers than Arrowhead so there's at least some merit to being able to scale up fast.

But overall, I think, like most modern software "advances", we've been duped on their actual performance and efficiency gains, while most gains have actually come from better hardware and internet connections (hardware again). And end users really aren't feeling much of an improvement. I think more has been lost to users and players actually. Less mods, less weird community servers with new game modes, etc. And as mentioned earlier, this actually helped incumbent devs find new revenue streams! The new supposed features of this tech is more to serve all the meta stuff like progression tracking and matchmaking which requires greater centralization of online services. Ye in many cases, like Helldivers 2, the actual gameplay is P2P. So the only thing players get out of the this new "tech" is the thing designed to keep them addicted which is stuff like lootboxes and Skinner box progression mechanics. (I acknowledge my last points here on meta mechanics as goalpost moving, I do view this as part of a much larger issue)

> Systems like LaunchDarkly require active subscriptions and don’t allow for redistribution and are often deeply embedded in applications.

I mean, this is just a bad state. I view this initiative as fighting shit like this. It's bad for devs too. What happens if LaunchDarkly or some other platform holder goes down or cuts off access to a dev for some perceived breach of conduct or license agreement? That's so damaging to a developer, and if they aren't established, existentially threatening. We shouldn't encourage this kind of coupling. As for the non distributable licenses of common distributable like Java and SQL, I'm not terribly worried the economics won't catch up to make it feasible to just use distributable license. We've already seen lots of Java technologies relicensed to GPL 2 over a decade ago. It's all possible without collapsing the economics of it all.

> games aren’t developed the same way as they were “prior to this recent problem”, player behaviour and expectations have changed. You can’t just go back to the way things were here any more than you can with social media, banking, email, movie rentals, etc.

We certainly can go back, or better yet, do better than we used to! I really don't think there's a good technological arguments for why we dev this way now. It's mostly political and I think we should resist this type of excusing of rent seeking style software as "tech advancement". All those areas you mentioned are the way they are not because of technological necessity but because of political and cultural forces. We can style them in a way that's more compatible with a more free and expressive user base, and ultimately, a freer market. The more, but still limited, openness of the pass certainly contributed greatly to the grown of games!

Re:Stop Killing Games – Almost at 160k signatures by johnnyanmac on Monday August 05, 2024 @04:34PM (#41165322)
>WoW took 4-5 years to develop with "The original World of Warcraft was created by a team of 40 people, which eventually doubled in size as the launch drew close." Where as as Helldivers 2 has about 100 devs at the end of development taking 8 years according to their CEO. So not seeing the wins there.

Even if we were only comparing cloud teams, I don't see the wins from WOW from 20 years ago working on asset pipelines that was simply 1 3d modeler, compared to an HD release in 202X. Bandwidth hasn't really kept up with asset fidelity, and at the same time consumer demands for ping also went up (as in, lower ping haha).

>we have tons of precedent of these middleware licenses working just fine when redistributed as binaries to users' devices, so how is this handwavy?

Every license is different, and it only takes one important middleware being difficult to stall the whole thing by months. I imagine licenses for server tech are more prohibitive than middleware tools that can work offline (which needs to be distributed for the game to run).

Re:Stop Killing Games – Almost at 160k signatures by usrbinbash on Monday August 05, 2024 @03:39PM (#41164706)
> Online games that aren't sold as services (like WoW with a subscription) wouldn't need to work online or with servers.

Absolutely agree, but fact is, games which rely on a centralized server architecture for the actual purposes of playing them do exist, and are thus a factor that needs to be considered.

Re:Stop Killing Games – Almost at 160k signatures by A4ET8a8uTh0 on Monday August 05, 2024 @08:32AM (#41160720)
I am honestly not sure where I stand on this ( MMORPGs especially, because those were designed for being played on the internet -- unlike offline games that merely have internet connection requirement ), but FFXI darkstar project was likely a good example of what could be done.

<< Bear in mind these systems are usually not made to be modular, they are custom-built to work in a given environment.

Lets say that somehow this requirement ( 'reasonable playable state' ) was mandated. It would likely result in more modular architecture. I call that a win.

Re:Stop Killing Games – Almost at 160k signatures by usrbinbash on Monday August 05, 2024 @03:37PM (#41164676)
> Lets say that somehow this requirement ( 'reasonable playable state' ) was mandated. It would likely result in more modular architecture. I call that a win.

It would also raise the cost of development, and raise the barrier of entry into markets.

Again, I am not against this proposal quite the opposite. But it should be made clear very early on what "reasonable playable state" means, and ideally in a way that would not constitute a huge competitive disadvantage for smaller developers.

Re:Stop Killing Games – Almost at 160k signatures by johnnyanmac on Monday August 05, 2024 @04:36PM (#41165349)
>It would likely result in more modular architecture.

I just see more workarounds rather than better tech. These laws almost never give better tech practices in the short run.

I imagine many games will switch to a f2p model (which seems to be an exception here) and hike up BP costs to make up for the lack of consistent $30-60 before we get a better modular architecture.

Re:Stop Killing Games – Almost at 160k signatures by slightwinder on Monday August 05, 2024 @09:21AM (#41161144)
> Someone please define "reasonable playable state".

Wouldn't this be the job of the lawmakers?

> Source and internal sysops documentation?

Maybe, why not. MMORPGs are the exception here, so most games will not necessarily be forced to deliver them.

> You will likely need a separate server architecture that works independently of the userlist and matchmaking system. Bear in mind these systems are usually not made to be modular, they are custom-built to work in a given environment.

Just open the APIs and let the community build their own. Maybe, the gaming-industry could even move to open standards, have open source-projects for most of those stuff, which would be beneficial for everyone.

> but there should be a VERY CLEAR definition of what counts as "reasonable playable state".

Why? In worst case, it has to be decided game by game. And for most games this is probably not a big deal, as they are not that hard entangled with online-features. I think any law should also giver the industry some leeway to establish a useful ground on their own.

I mean, a solution here could go from removing licensing and allowing people debugging, so they can build their own backends. Or forcing companies to deliver the whole backend, including documentation and whatever. This is a pretty big range of options.

Re:Stop Killing Games – Almost at 160k signatures by jwueller on Monday August 05, 2024 @04:34PM (#41165323)
See Directive 2019/770 for the definition of "functional" in this context. It's already a codified term: The digital content or service must be able to perform its intended functions reliably, meet the quality and performance expectations set forth in the contract, and be compatible with other systems as expected by the consumer.