For a high stakes election I would take the most trustworthy system. So give me an argument why I should invest money into building a less trustworthy one?
Because it I get results faster? I don't care about speed, high stakes elections are rare enough for that not to matter.
Because it is more efficient? I don't care about efficiency, I want the result to be accurate and the process to be understandable by the stupid bloke in the pub with whom I have to discuss the result.
There is literally no reason why this should be replaced by a digital system other than it makes us needs feel special.
My point was narrowly that most of the argument made in https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41156898 applies to paper voting as well.
For what it's worth, I prefer paper ballots, but I don't think that makes all arguments for them automatically valid.
Exactly, so the rest of your criticism isn't nearly as strong, if it applies to all means of voting.