News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple's "benign dictatorship" of the App Store leaves use... by cube13 on Thursday June 14, 2012 @03:39PM (#4113139)
>If Speak for Yourself had developed an app for Android they would have had none of these problems.

No, they would still have the same problem. Google has the killswitch ability. Amazon and Google do remove applications from the store on a regular basis for copyright violations.

EDIT: And the ability to install an APK from anywhere still doesn't mean that they'll be able to keep selling it while the court proceedings are going on. This problem isn't a technical issue. It's a legal one.

Re:Apple's "benign dictatorship" of the App Store leaves use... by josteink on Thursday June 14, 2012 @03:44PM (#4113168)
But you can still install any APK you can download. You don't even need a store. You, as a user, are protected from this modern-day corporate censorship.

And that makes the platform infinitely more attractive to anyone who values freedom.

Re:Apple's "benign dictatorship" of the App Store leaves use... by bad_user on Thursday June 14, 2012 @04:29PM (#4113370)

     And the ability to install an APK from anywhere 
     still doesn't mean that they'll be able to keep 
     selling it while the court proceedings are going on.
That's bullshit. Sure they can send you a DMCA take-down notice, but if it's your domain you can use it as toilet paper.

And btw, I haven't seen Google pulling Android from the market in the eve of Oracle's lawsuit. That's because you are still free to sell your products until infringement is actually proved !

Re:Apple's "benign dictatorship" of the App Store leaves use... by cube13 on Thursday June 14, 2012 @05:17PM (#4113559)
Google didn't pull Android from the market during the lawsuit because the judge stopped that motion from Oracle.

If PRC made that motion, and the judge allowed it, Speak for Yourself WOULD have to pull the APK.

Re:Apple's "benign dictatorship" of the App Store leaves use... by fpgeek on Thursday June 14, 2012 @09:48PM (#4114534)
Yes, but actually making that motion and convincing a judge is a lot more work than just sending a letter (to any or all of Apple/Google/Amazon/etc). That's one of the important checks and balances in the legal process that PRC was able to work around (with Apple's help).
Re:Apple's "benign dictatorship" of the App Store leaves use... by myko on Thursday June 14, 2012 @03:44PM (#4113176)
But on Android one can install a secondary application downloading service, or even download an application from a web site and easily install it.