Re:Hacking and defeating Google's reCAPTCHA with a 99% accuracy
by omonra on Thursday June 14, 2012 @09:48AM
(#4111298)
This may be very interesting to crack, but who is responsible for Google making their CAPTCHA almost impossible for human to decipher now? I seriously have to click 5 times before even seeing anything resembling letters I can parse
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Hacking and defeating Google's reCAPTCHA with a 99% accuracy
by duiker101 on Thursday June 14, 2012 @09:59AM
(#4111349)
I didn't go in depth of the article/method but from what I've read it takes advantages of the audio function not the images.
Re:Hacking and defeating Google's reCAPTCHA with a 99% accuracy
by joelthelion on Thursday June 14, 2012 @03:03PM
(#4112964)
This simply means computers are getting really good at this game. And that Google, with all its power, hasn't found a better alternative to Captchas yet.
I find that pretty worrying for the future of the internet. An internet without working captchhas will probably be full of bots and spam.
Re:Hacking and defeating Google's reCAPTCHA with a 99% accuracy
by Jach on Thursday June 14, 2012 @04:54PM
(#4113471)
Naive Bayes spam classifiers are fast enough that I think they could be used as drop-in replacements, and they'd be well-trained too considering Google's existing success with spam in email. And Naive Bayes isn't the only solution, there are plenty of other heuristics. Even something as dumb as "first post from this user/IP/'identity' and full of links?" would catch a lot of common spam.
Re:Hacking and defeating Google's reCAPTCHA with a 99% accuracy
by Jach on Friday June 15, 2012 @05:30AM
(#4115713)
I really wish HN required a comment with a downvote on accounts with more than 100 karma (where one can reasonably assume the user isn't a newbie leaving empty comments like "I agree"). I'd ask that person to think it through: why doesn't gmail require a captcha every time you want to send an email? What about other mail providers? What about your own native client? An internet without working captchhas[sic] will probably be full of bots and spam. Is your inbox full of bots and spam? Mine isn't. Even my spam box is at less than 800 over the period of a month; before one of the big botnets was taken down a few years ago that was generating most of the world's spam I still had less than 4000 over a month.
Re:Hacking and defeating Google's reCAPTCHA with a 99% accuracy
by masonlee on Thursday June 14, 2012 @03:44PM
(#4113171)
Is this an argument that future web services may depend more heavily on identity/reputation services?
Re:Hacking and defeating Google's reCAPTCHA with a 99% accuracy
by verroq on Thursday June 14, 2012 @10:19AM
(#4111434)
You only have the type one word correct, and they make sure one word is readable so with some practice you can easily recognise which word is the key-word.
Re:Hacking and defeating Google's reCAPTCHA with a 99% accuracy
by btilly on Thursday June 14, 2012 @10:52AM
(#4111573)
With practice and decent eyes. Once your eyes go downhill, it is amazing how much changes.
Most software developers are under 40 and therefore have little to no appreciation for what happens to people's eyes after they are past 40.
Re:Hacking and defeating Google's reCAPTCHA with a 99% accuracy
by ohgodthecat3 on Thursday June 14, 2012 @10:25AM
(#4111457)
He isn't speaking of reCAPTCHA but google's nearly impossible to read captchas that take way too much time to decipher.
If you'd like to see it you can usually get it by putting in a bad password to a gmail account too many times (though I don't know if that has other consequences).
Edit: Here is an image example http://www.techian.com/wp-content/uploads/captcha.png
Re:Hacking and defeating Google's reCAPTCHA with a 99% accuracy
by sp332 on Thursday June 14, 2012 @10:35AM
(#4111497)
I wonder what they do for non-Latin locales?
Re:Hacking and defeating Google's reCAPTCHA with a 99% accuracy
by simonbrown on Thursday June 14, 2012 @10:28AM
(#4111465)
Strange they don't use reCAPTCHA for this.
Re:Hacking and defeating Google's reCAPTCHA with a 99% accuracy
by verroq on Thursday June 14, 2012 @10:28AM
(#4111466)
Oh those, yeah they are very hard to decipher.
Re:Hacking and defeating Google's reCAPTCHA with a 99% accuracy
by dkersten on Thursday June 14, 2012 @11:26AM
(#4111743)
For me, the key word is usually the unreadable one. I've never had success typing only the readable one.
Re:Hacking and defeating Google's reCAPTCHA with a 99% accuracy
by conradfr on Thursday June 14, 2012 @10:45AM
(#4111537)
After reading that previously on HN, I tried and sadly had to type both word.
Re:Hacking and defeating Google's reCAPTCHA with a 99% accuracy
by fibertbh on Thursday June 14, 2012 @11:53AM
(#4111910)
Agreed. They are unbearable. But name a better alternative!
Anything that I can think of like adding to the CAPTCHA such as a half-line of letter above and below or adding noise would probably make cracking them programmatically even easier.