Is there really no demand for new downtown developments?
But even without, it’s crazy that you can afford the mortgage with the parking fees.
Let's say on an average workday your lot is like 60% full. You charge like $8/day for normal workdays or something. 252 spaces * 8/day ~$10k/wk. Lets say 50 of these normal weeks in a year, that's $504k in parking for the normal workdays.
Normal workday and baseball games gives you ~$1.35M in revenue for something you need to repave every decade and paint every couple of years.
In arglinton, Texas, often called one of the least walkable cities on Earth, there's a requirement that each building has a parking lot proportional to it's occupancy. So if you build a 200 person building, you need a parking lot to handle 200 people. I can't remember the exact ratio, I doubt it was 1:1 like that.
So the parking lots are there by force, not convenience or cost.
Slap some paint on the ground, put up a booth and a sign, and you’re good?
Whereas an elevated garage is probably a years-long project?
I also think most of these parking lots are probably owned by small time chumps, not consolidated mega parking companies.