News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The irrational hungry judge effect revisited by NoMoreNicksLeft on Monday July 29, 2024 @09:56AM (#41100467)
It's not as if the judge does not have all the details of the case prior to sentencing. The order can't possibly supply more information than the fact that he just sat through the trial himself days or weeks prior. At least in the United States, the same judge who presides over a trial is the one who sentences the convicted. The only time a defendant gets different judges for anything is early in the process, like during arraignment.
Re:The irrational hungry judge effect revisited by Retric on Monday July 29, 2024 @10:24AM (#41100715)
Knowing the details and being subconsciously influenced are different questions. Ambient music in stores doesn’t change the prices, products, or a shoppers needs yet it still influences buying behavior.

Suppose a taste tester is asked to rank something on a scale of 1-100, but before giving a number they need to presort them into terrible, ok, good, great then go back to each group and give a specific score to each item. My guess is there would be different clustering vs someone doing the same task in one go.

Re:The irrational hungry judge effect revisited by bumby on Monday July 29, 2024 @12:58PM (#41101855)
Adding to this, even knowing the subconscious biases doesn't necessarily mitigate them. Kahneman talked about how he was still subjected to such biases, even though he was an expert in studying and identifying them.
Re:The irrational hungry judge effect revisited by sea9 on Monday July 29, 2024 @05:29PM (#41103985)
What ‘subconscious influence’ are you assuming here? The cases are ordered in a known, public, obvious way by known, public, obvious criteria. Are you thinking that a judge would not know the difference between the severity of charges if they weren’t grouped together? That he would be inclined to think a jaywalking case sandwiched between two murders was just as serious? This argument seems unlikely in the extreme.
Re:The irrational hungry judge effect revisited by Retric on Monday July 29, 2024 @06:52PM (#41104520)
I’m suggesting the exact opposite situation, ie groups of equal severity create a subconscious bias even if it’s the Judge that makes them.

A jaywalking case seems meaningless when sandwiched between just about anything because objectively it’s not serious. However 20 murder cases and you might start benchmarking things to the pedo cannibal not each case on it’s own merits.

If all you see is 20 white collar crimes row with several 10+ million dollar cases someone who ‘only’ stole 100 thousand seems almost meaningless even if objectively it’s a lot of money. And that exact loss of objectivity is a problem.

Re:The irrational hungry judge effect revisited by sea9 on Thursday August 01, 2024 @05:49PM (#41134001)
What loss of objectivity? What you are describing bears no relationship to the study or… any real case that we’re discussing.
Re:The irrational hungry judge effect revisited by Retric on Saturday August 03, 2024 @03:20PM (#41148615)
> What loss of objectivity? What you are describing bears no relationship to the study or… any real case that we’re discussing.

Bias is a loss of objectivity.

Study says before lunch cases are meaningfully different than the after lunch case, thus it’s a like with like grouping.

I referenced a known effect where grouping like with like can create a subconscious bias. Sure it’s best known in other contexts, but there’s little to suggest sentencing is somehow uniquely unbiased.

Re:The irrational hungry judge effect revisited by mrgoldenbrown on Monday July 29, 2024 @03:45PM (#41103137)
The study involved parole boards, not initial sentencing from an initial trial.
Re:The irrational hungry judge effect revisited by NoMoreNicksLeft on Tuesday July 30, 2024 @09:57AM (#41109253)
So these people have already received fair sentences, and they have to serve them out? What's the problem?