Re:The irrational hungry judge effect revisited
by parpfish on Sunday July 28, 2024 @05:07PM
(#41095969)
Did anybody ever ask the judges/clerks about this finding? It seems like the whole thing could have been rebutted with one phone call and the judge saying “yeah, we make the schedules and intentionally backload the negative/easy ones”
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:The irrational hungry judge effect revisited
by trashface on Monday July 29, 2024 @03:26PM
(#41103000)
They have incentive to hide it. Ordinary people want to think the justice system actually does justice. Not group cases by time slot because they are likely to be simply denied, which is clearly biased.
Personally this is more disturbing to me than the alleged earlier finding that the judge was in a bad mood because he was hungry. At least that is correctable and avoidable; systemic discrimination by case type isn't.
Re:The irrational hungry judge effect revisited
by sea9 on Monday July 29, 2024 @05:33PM
(#41104022)
It is absolutely correct to systematically discriminate by ‘case type’ if ‘case type’ means severity of charges. You don’t want arsonists to be granted parole as easily as jaywalkers.
You are maybe forgetting that the job of judges is judgment.
Re:The irrational hungry judge effect revisited
by trashface on Wednesday July 31, 2024 @11:51PM
(#41125991)
Not forgetting, just don't agree. The job of judges is justice. Presuming bias by stacking case type is not justice.
Re:The irrational hungry judge effect revisited
by sea9 on Thursday August 01, 2024 @05:49PM
(#41134005)
That’s not what’s happening. What do you think is happening?
Re:The irrational hungry judge effect revisited
by parpfish on Monday July 29, 2024 @05:53PM
(#41104153)
They arent hiding anything nefarious, they’re just organizing their day. Start a session with the cases most likely to run long and have extra paperwork so you’re more likely to finish at the right time and not go over