They didn't give up on it, they simply added alternative options for those that didn't like it.
As far as I know the old mode is also no longer the default. At least it isn't in Fedora and in GIMP's own release notes they also don't use the old mode [1]
GIMP (the OSS Photoshop-style tool) had this idea for literally over a decade and eventually gave up on it because they never got it to work well.