In the language of hypothesis testing you have your null and alternative hypotheses.
So for alternative hypothesis that the sun comes up in the morning, the null hypothesis would simply be that the sun does not come up in the morning.
Each of the negative results, reads to me like a separate 'alternative' hypothesis.
So let's say I claim that the sun goes in a circle in the sky in the morning. The null hypothesis is that it doesn't do that. Perform experiment. Null hypothesis wins. Write up paper! This is a negative result.
The point is that for every result where the alternative hypothesis wins, there are a massive, if not infinite, number of results where the null hypothesis will win. Are these publishable?
> It ain't what you don't know that gets you into trouble. It's what you know for sure that just ain't so.
??? As I had said originally, that's one of the primary situations where a negative result should be published.
But the huge, huge, huge majority of negative results are trivial and uninteresting. Thus the fundamental issue with negative results is that you have to provide rather more compelling justification for why such results should be published.
Positive result claim: the sun comes up in the morning.
Negative result claims: the sun moves sideways in the morning. The sun was always there. The sun peeks up in the morning and immediately goes back down. And so on.
Positive result claim: aspirin is an effective pain reliever.
Negative result claims: eating sawdust is an effective pain reliever. Snorting water is an effective pain reliever. Crystal Healing is an effective pain reliever. Etc.
Because there are so many negative results, it's trivial to construct an experiment which produces one. So why should that be published?
Negative results should be published when people in the community are asking that question, or have a wrong belief in the answer (hence the replication crisis). But if nobody cares about the question, it's hard to argue for why a given negative result would be preferred over any other negative result for purposes of publication.