Re:You got a null result. Will anyone publish it?
by nick238 on Thursday July 25, 2024 @12:29PM
(#41070542)
Yeah, I agree with your first point, but maybe misunderstood your reply? If there's nothing "surprising" about the result, it's not interesting, so not publishable. The article's first example, however, did seem to be surprising to the researcher's community, so it should have been published.
Re:You got a null result. Will anyone publish it?
by SeanLuke on Friday July 26, 2024 @03:48AM
(#41076643)
Sure. What I said, or had meant to say, was in reply to people complaining that there was some kind of cartel against negative results. Rather, what we're seeing is just the natural, if unfortunate, response to the basic problem with negative results as a whole. You can't just treat them as the same as positive results: because of their numerosity they require unusual justification for their publication.
??? As I had said originally, that's one of the primary situations where a negative result should be published.
But the huge, huge, huge majority of negative results are trivial and uninteresting. Thus the fundamental issue with negative results is that you have to provide rather more compelling justification for why such results should be published.