So, you're saying we should still keep all the money in that silo? That we should keep letting "risk modelers" who have exacerbated every speculative bubble since the Great Depression keep investing in Color and Groupon and boo.com and flooz because the masses are too stupid to do it for themselves?
Well, okay. But, I disagree.
Personally, I think it's okay that regular people risk (extremely small, in relative terms) money and, more often than not (in the long term), lose it. It's okay to build businesses that only profit because of human irrationality. It's their money to spend (or lose) as they please--and, in aggregate, as businesses, it's our profit. Just so long as nothing's coercing anyone into doing this--like, say, a gambling addiction--we have no reason to feel bad for allowing people to bet on us and then, potentially, flopping.
If point of capitalism is the efficient distribution of resources to the places they need to go then the VC's are actually doing a pretty bad job of it (on average)
At least with crowd sourcing it's a step in the right -direction- toward funding ideas that seem popular, that a bunch of consumers who invest would hopefully be doing so because they also want to use the product.
I'm sure there'll still be serial swindlers and greedy investors who get scammed, but in a utopian world it'd be great if it was sort of like Kickstarter, where you put in $50 with no guarantee of actually getting what you're funding, but now there's a chance you'll not only get that product, plus your money back, plus a nice little bonus sum if the company succeeds. I guess the key is managing the expectations of the investors
Do you really think laymen understand risk, though? Casinos make billions of dollars each year off people who can't correctly model risk even after risking, and losing, large sums of money. Of course, VCs wouldn't put their money on black at the Roulette table--but VCs (and stock-brokers, and investment-bankers) model risk for a living, whereas the median layman micro-investor will have given their one or two investments maybe five cumulative minutes of thought in their lifetime.
To put it another way: there's a sucker born every minute--but no-one stays a sucker for very long, once they've been burned. This means that, when there is friction to investment, the suckers will slowly drain from the pool until only the sharks are left; whereas, when fiction is low, each sucker leaving the game will be replaced by a new sucker joining in, fresh and naive. When 90% of your revenue comes from people who have never invested in anything before, you can build your business model on the mob's irrational overconfidence in your ability to deliver.