I honestly never use it because I only use unreal alone, so can't say how good or bad it is in real world project.
Basic demo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XYZsvouytVQ
As long as there's some structured record of changes made to permissions and structure, those can be visualized.
I have an idea that I think would be suitable for visual programming. Every time I think about it, I come to the conclusion that first you need a DSL, or at least a JSON Schema or something.
If you have a DSL/schema, then you also have a way to diff.
Then, you implement your visual programming environment, and visual diffs turn into effectively communicating those differences visually. Faded color to indicate a deleted node and connector, bold parameter and value to indicate a change, etc.
In other words, not only does understanding these diagrams assume a ton of knowledge in the problem domain, but the crude tools at hand for creating them (lines, words, symbols, shapes, colors) can be repurposed in so many ways by different people and different projects that I don't see how generic motion detection will be able to detect high level changes. Sure, detecting changed nodes and descriptions might be easy, and possibly useful, but I think there will never be a substitute for human comments like "removed XYZ because the boss said so" or "renamed foo to bar because of IRS regulation so-and-so."
It is a big problem if you are trying to develop a genric visual programming language. But much less of a problem if you restrict the problem domain to something like data processing, signal processing or image processing.
I suspect that the fundamental problem with visual languages is that you have to reify _something_ as the objects/symbols of the language. The most widely used text languages tend to be multi-paradigm languages which have significant flexibility in developing and integrating new abstractions over the lifetime of projects and library ecosystems.
It's not clear to me how this can be overcome in visual languages without losing the advantages, and instead ending up with a text language that is just more spread out.
Make the abstractions purely high level, and let people write Python plugins for new blocks with an app store to share them.
Visual can easily provide enough flexibility for gluing blocks together.
IFTT, Excel, and lots of others do it perfectly well.
The issue is programmers like to program. Mostly they like "programming in circles", making little apps to help make more other little apps to explore ideas.
They see it mathematically, as a human centered activity all about understanding, while users see machines as a box you put stuff in to make it not your problem anymore.
They're always talking about empowering users to create their own fully custom ways of using computers... But.... I like apps that have a canned, consistent workflow that I don't have to fuss with or maintain or reinstall.
Software like Excel has the appropriate amount of power for working on a project that uses computers but isn't really related to programming or done by developers.
I get what you are trying to convey but that usage of the term is not helpful in the general case as it confuses what mechanical sympathy actually means.
Mechanical sympathy is simply this: abstractions that acknowledge the underlying embodying stratum of a dynamic construct. In code, that translates to software that attempts at harmonizing the software abstraction with the operational characteristics of the underlying computing device.
The victory of plaintext coding over visual programming is another example of worse is better. Semantic, language-aware diffs exist, but I see them much less frequently than dumb plaintext diffs. Intelligent code search exists, but in many cases grep is just as good. IDEs come with very advanced refactoring tools, but I still prefer to refactor using vim macros.
When we write code in plaintext, we're expressing our code in a lower level of abstraction with really great tooling. Doesn't matter if it's java or yaml or something custom—plaintext tools work on all of them. Visual programming languages can't do this. There's no language-agnostic vim or git for visual programming. Even if we wanted to invent sort of unified language-agnostic visual programming abstraction, the ecosystem isn't there, and there's no guarantee it'd get adopted.
So I think plaintext will remain king for the foreseeable future. Visual tools have to use human-readable, human-editable plaintext as their source of truth, if they want to succeed.
The pictures are easier to learn and use but they are not as expressive and precise as the more abstract text. Text is a marvelous innovation. The fact that most people on the planet can communicate complex ideas and emotions as well as program machines with it (in many different dialects) is mind blowing.
Using pictures to program feels like a regression.
I don't know of any non-proprietary tools, but at least the tech is out there.
Anything else breaks the ability to use Git, or requires adding plugins which you might have to compile yourself or something, and I'm a big fan of just using Git and having VCS be a solved problem.
If this then that rules map nicely to LISP-like expressions in JSON or YAML.
Freely positionable elements are a pretty bad idea for a lot of things. They make extra noise in the diffs and can't be automatically formatted in a fully satisfying way, short of making an AI for it, plus they can't be edited easily on a mobile device, and they can easily become a literal picture of some spaghetti.
For a little background, I’ve maintained that visual programming goes absolutely nowhere until we have visual diffs that work (work as in workflow). I’ve been saying that since before the UML Trough of Disillusionment kicked into high gear. Without diffs, without analysis, we are going nowhere fast. Almost every other link of the lifecycle is still intact with visual code but focusing on an editor without diffs breaks the chain. There’s no producing and maintaining commercial grade software without it. It’s either toy programs, or absolutely heroic effort, and what else could you have done with that much energy?
The epiphany was this: motion detection has been a feature of digital video since at least the MPEG days. Someone with a background in video compression needs to tackle the problem of doffing visual code. Figuring out how the code should look (mechanical sympathy) to facilitate this.