News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Microsoft Blames European Commission for Major Worldwide ... by isodev on Monday July 22, 2024 @03:34PM (#41038845)
This is ridiculous though. Nothing is stopping Microsoft from offering “safe” access to both themselves and third parties.

Also, let’s not forget why these restrictions are applied in the first place - they kick in when the corp grows to become a gatekeeper, integrating multiple product categories and the expense of users and 3rd party vendors.

Re:Microsoft Blames European Commission for Major Worldwide ... by a2tech on Monday July 22, 2024 @03:43PM (#41038964)
Correct. The issue was defender getting kernel access and nothing else getting that level of integration. Microsoft could have dropped defender to the same level as competing products, or dropped the product entirely. They chose to allow third parties access to kernel access instead.
Re:Microsoft Blames European Commission for Major Worldwide ... by Rinzler89 on Monday July 22, 2024 @03:40PM (#41038924)
>Nothing is stopping Microsoft from offering “safe” access to both themselves and third parties.

They are offering "safe" access, it's called userspace.

Re:Microsoft Blames European Commission for Major Worldwide ... by freeopinion on Monday July 22, 2024 @04:18PM (#41039352)
To be clear, they have to offer third parties the same access they enjoy themselves. If they provide a spell-checker that requires kernel implementation, they have to give all competing spell-checkers the same access.

Obviously, it seems ludicrous to implement spell-checking in the kernel. Imagine if MS imposed the discipline upon themselves to provide enough API that their own security products didn't reach for the kernel crutch.

Linux is different because it is open source. If a vendor wants to reach into the kernel, it's completely possible. If they want to provide patches to the kernel that allow their or any other product to do what it needs outside the kernel, they can. But even if the kernel provided all the necessary APIs, vendors could ignore those and insist on being inside the kernel. It is up to the user to use wisdom about what they install. And there is no unfair advantage to the OS vendor competing with third-party apps.

It is silly to blame regulators instead of the app vendor in this case. I'm not sure why MS feels the need to deflect blame. I know that some are eager to point the finger at MS, but MS shouldn't be so defensive. It makes it look like they think there is some merit to those arguments that has to be deflected.

Re:Microsoft Blames European Commission for Major Worldwide ... by legitster on Monday July 22, 2024 @04:30PM (#41039483)
> I'm not sure why MS feels the need to deflect blame.

Everyone is editorializing. Microsoft never actually blamed the EU. They just were explaining why their kernel was open to third parties in the first place.

Re:Microsoft Blames European Commission for Major Worldwide ... by Rinzler89 on Monday July 22, 2024 @04:37PM (#41039542)
Their kernel was open to SW devs since the very beginning, it's one of the reason that helped Windows grew in popularity especially as a video game platform. Early 3d games needed direct kernel access to extract maximum performance from the HW, but then MS built Direct3D as a wrapper for that direct HW access so games couldn't crash your whole system.
Re:Microsoft Blames European Commission for Major Worldwide ... by MobiusHorizons on Monday July 22, 2024 @04:05PM (#41039207)
You can’t write programs like CrowdStrike falcon in user space on windows, because windows doesn’t offer the right kind of APIs and hooks from userspace to provide that kind of protection. On Mac OS CrowdStrike falcon runs in userspace already, and on Linux, the kernel interface is provided by eBPF, which acts as a sandbox, preventing certain classes of crash. So it really is true that Microsoft does not provide safe access like other operating systems do.
Re:Microsoft Blames European Commission for Major Worldwide ... by Rinzler89 on Monday July 22, 2024 @04:10PM (#41039263)
Does the MacOS Falcon app running in userspace have the exact same monitoring capability like the Windows variant running in kernel space?
Re:Microsoft Blames European Commission for Major Worldwide ... by rawicki on Monday July 22, 2024 @04:21PM (#41039390)
Nothing stops them from writing a minimal kernelspace driver that sends events to the userspace part and evaluates rules there.
Re:Microsoft Blames European Commission for Major Worldwide ... by isodev on Monday July 22, 2024 @04:04PM (#41039190)
Then the blame can safely go to the vendor who opted not to take advantage.

If anything, the Crowdstrike incident highlights the lack of diversity in the OS/security space.

Everyone using the same stack makes everyone vulnerable to the same bugs.