News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple’s Ping to End With a Thud in Next Release of iTunes by 51Cards on Tuesday June 12, 2012 @09:28PM (#4103859)
"At this point, years into the social networking phenomenon, why not leave the social stuff to the social people who are good at it?"

While I acknowledge that Ping was a huge failure the above statement strikes me as odd. If that's so obvious then...

Why not leave Maps to people who are good at it? Why not leave voice recognition to people who are good at it? Why not leave... etc. Apple hasn't been shy about diving into competitor's markets... which I don't always agree with fully. But on the flip side, you don't know if you don't try I guess.

Re:Apple’s Ping to End With a Thud in Next Release of iTunes by chj on Tuesday June 12, 2012 @09:41PM (#4103902)
That explains why iOS is not a good platform. The owner of this platform loses his focus (building a good platform, giving developers more power), instead it starts to duplicate developers' effort in the name of user experience. Surely they have a chance of doing it better, but it is just because they can use their private APIs.
Re:Apple’s Ping to End With a Thud in Next Release of iTunes by ryannielsen on Tuesday June 12, 2012 @11:32PM (#4104192)
Are you very familiar with iOS development? I ask because those people I know who are were very happy with the improvements and APIs added in past iOS releases and seem to be delighted with what's being released with iOS 6.

Perhaps you've found yourself hampered by the lack of certain APIs that Apple has yet to add or yet to promote from SPI. I know some devs in that boat. But I don't think you can accuse Apple of having lost focus on the iOS platform, or that they aren't feverishly working to give devs more power.

Re:Apple’s Ping to End With a Thud in Next Release of iTunes by chj on Wednesday June 13, 2012 @01:54AM (#4104513)
A very important missing feature is external keyboard event support. I don't want to go too far into the details, just let me tell you this: ESC, Function Keys,CTRL, ALT are all dead.

I submitted a feature request among other developers like the month iPad came out. So far, no any sign of adding it. Yet we continue to see Apple adding this message that reminder.

Re:Apple’s Ping to End With a Thud in Next Release of iTunes by nl on Wednesday June 13, 2012 @02:03AM (#4104539)
I'm probably not the worlds biggest Apple fan, but:

A very important missing feature is external keyboard event support

Umm.. no it isn't. It's pretty clear iOS is designed for devices without a physical keyboard, and if that is important to you then you will always be working on something Apple doesn't think is important. Their priority there is quite clear and I don't think it is reasonable to blame them for that.

(Written by someone who likes a physical keyboard and is very happy with my Asus Transformer)

Re:Apple’s Ping to End With a Thud in Next Release of iTunes by chj on Wednesday June 13, 2012 @02:24AM (#4104593)
Even if it is not universally important, it is very good for projects like:

http://www.pcworld.com/article/229284/the_250_case_that_turn...

As a platform provider, why bother work on an app that thousands of developers can do better, and not work on a missing feature that can enable further innovation? We are not talking about a Siri level of feature, we are talking of a trivial platform feature that basically a decent engineer in Apple should be able to do it in a week, testing included.

Re:Apple’s Ping to End With a Thud in Next Release of iTunes by nl on Wednesday June 13, 2012 @03:03AM (#4104672)
As a platform provider, why bother work on an app that thousands of developers can do better, and not work on a missing feature that can enable further innovation?

I'm not sure if you want to hear the answer to that or not.

It's economics & platform strategy. Ping was created to attempt to increase the stickiness of the iTunes platform, to appease the record labels (who wanted an alternative to MySpace) and to bring Apple closer to Facebook. All of those things were major strategic goals for Apple at the time.

Making the iPad something more like a laptop when the MacBook Air already exists? The only way your "bug" will get traction within Apple is if someone decides that is a goal of the iOS platform. That might happen, but pulling an Apple engineer for a whole week off other projects to work on it seems unlikely to happen without fairly major executive sponsorship.

Re:Apple’s Ping to End With a Thud in Next Release of iTunes by chj on Wednesday June 13, 2012 @06:21AM (#4105187)
There are tons of cases where iPad could be better off with a keyboard, especially for productivity apps. Come on, android has full keyboard support from day one.
Re:Apple’s Ping to End With a Thud in Next Release of iTunes by untog on Wednesday June 13, 2012 @10:49AM (#4106206)
And what percentage of users actually use the full keyboard support? I mean, with Android tablets we're asking "what is a low percent of a tiny number of people", but still. Being able to use an external keyboard with your phone/tablet is a very, very niche activity.
Re:Apple’s Ping to End With a Thud in Next Release of iTunes by 51Cards on Wednesday June 13, 2012 @12:41PM (#4106882)
Tons... look at the ASUS Transformer and Slider. Devices like that can't exist in iOS properly.
Re:Apple’s Ping to End With a Thud in Next Release of iTunes by nl on Wednesday June 13, 2012 @11:16PM (#4109606)
You don't need to convince me (like I said, I have a Asus Transformer).

I'm merely pointing out that it isn't likely to be a priority for Apple.

Re:Apple’s Ping to End With a Thud in Next Release of iTunes by georgespencer on Wednesday June 13, 2012 @05:11AM (#4104992)
> That explains why iOS is not a good platform.

I don't know anyone–not Android developers, not iOS developers, not Apple engineers, not Google engineers-who thinks that iOS is not a good platform.

Re:Apple’s Ping to End With a Thud in Next Release of iTunes by dwc on Tuesday June 12, 2012 @10:09PM (#4103980)
Just translate that from corp speak into normal human language: "At this point, years into the social phenomenon, I can't imagine what the heck we were even trying to accomplish with this."
Re:Apple’s Ping to End With a Thud in Next Release of iTunes by smackfu on Wednesday June 13, 2012 @09:36AM (#4105798)
We'll see whether Apple Maps is actually better than Google Maps. I have doubts, Apple has always been a bit lackluster in online services. Even Siri is rather unreliable.
Re:Apple’s Ping to End With a Thud in Next Release of iTunes by taligent on Tuesday June 12, 2012 @10:42PM (#4104061)
Why not leave Maps ? Because Google wasn't going to provide the APIs necessary to implement turn by turn navigation.

Why not leave Voice Recognition ? They do. Apple didn't implement their own custom voice recognition software.

Re:Apple’s Ping to End With a Thud in Next Release of iTunes by meepmorp on Wednesday June 13, 2012 @07:47AM (#4105361)
> Apple didn't implement their own custom voice recognition software.

And Google didn't implement their own custom mobile OS. You don't have to build your own to move into a product space - it counts if you do so via purchase.

Re:Apple’s Ping to End With a Thud in Next Release of iTunes by fpgeek on Wednesday June 13, 2012 @06:29AM (#4105206)
Why not leave ebooks? I can't see anything Apple has gained that makes up for all of the problems that move has created.