News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[dead]
Re:Microsoft says 8.5M Windows devices were affected by Crow... by trothamel on Saturday July 20, 2024 @07:02PM (#41020833)
No.

Software freedom 0 is that you should be free to run the program as you wish, for any purpose.

If that means loading your system up with third-party crapware, that's on you, not them. That doesn't mean Microsoft shouldn't work on making it easy to recover a system, if they can, but preventing you from running software would make the cure worse that the disease.

Re:Microsoft says 8.5M Windows devices were affected by Crow... by oddb0d on Saturday July 20, 2024 @07:10PM (#41020890)
You're quoting Software freedom 0 when referring to Microsoft? Wow, that's bold!
Re:Microsoft says 8.5M Windows devices were affected by Crow... by 4rt on Saturday July 20, 2024 @07:16PM (#41020939)
Bold would be accusing them of not allowing you to install shit quality kernel drivers in ring0, and then accusing them of negligence when you hose your machine by doing it.
Re:Microsoft says 8.5M Windows devices were affected by Crow... by asveikau on Saturday July 20, 2024 @07:04PM (#41020847)
If you install some pointless garbage as root on a free OS, it can make your system unbootable. I don't think an OS vendor has any blame here.

The mistake here is people think they need third party security solutions that are actually worse than nothing.

Re:Microsoft says 8.5M Windows devices were affected by Crow... by numpad0 on Saturday July 20, 2024 @07:21PM (#41020975)
I think it's actually one of MS moats that you can do this on Windows.

This had been much harder on macOS, and practically impossible on iOS; considering that few business take those OS seriously, it's most likely a requirement than a flaw.

Re:Microsoft says 8.5M Windows devices were affected by Crow... by teeray on Saturday July 20, 2024 @07:15PM (#41020926)
if you burn out the engine of your car with third-party tuning chips, would auto manufacturers cover that under warrantee?
Re:Microsoft says 8.5M Windows devices were affected by Crow... by mschuster91 on Saturday July 20, 2024 @07:26PM (#41021014)
To keep up your analogy, it can be said that Microsoft delivers a 2024 sports car with a 1980s naturally-aspirated diesel engine.

If Microsoft had done their job instead of inventing new UI frameworks basically for each recent Windows release, there would be no need for an antivirus engine at all.

Re:Microsoft says 8.5M Windows devices were affected by Crow... by HPsquared on Saturday July 20, 2024 @07:34PM (#41021066)
Is there really a need for antivirus software anyway? What does it actually prevent?
Re:Microsoft says 8.5M Windows devices were affected by Crow... by LadyCailin on Saturday July 20, 2024 @07:00PM (#41020812)
Absolutely not. If they did, we would immediately have a walled garden. We’re moving too far in that direction already, we don’t need to give Microsoft an excuse to jump there immediately. If you install stupid shit on your computer, that’s on you, not Windows, not MacOS, not Linux.
Re:Microsoft says 8.5M Windows devices were affected by Crow... by belter on Saturday July 20, 2024 @07:05PM (#41020868)
Should MS hold liability for selling a system who needs additional 3rd party components to be considered secure?
Re:Microsoft says 8.5M Windows devices were affected by Crow... by iowemoretohim on Saturday July 20, 2024 @07:42PM (#41021138)
Crowdstrike is also used on Linux and MacOS devices. So by your definition, does that means they aren't considered secure either?

Crowdstrike is certainly not required for a device to be considered secure, it is a tool that uses AI and ML to detect and prevent malware, 0-day exploits and other cyber threats in real-time across endpoints.

Re:Microsoft says 8.5M Windows devices were affected by Crow... by belter on Saturday July 20, 2024 @08:00PM (#41021260)
> uses AI and ML

No it does not. Such thing does not exist.

Most antivirus programs rely primarily on signature-based detection and heuristic analysis rather than advanced machine learning algorithms. While some modern antivirus solutions incorporate basic machine learning for anomaly detection, they do not typically employ the sophisticated, self-learning AI systems that are characteristic of true artificial intelligence applications. And I do understand Crowdstrike is more than just an antivirus.

Please don't repeat CNBC Stock market pumping memes. No they are not an "AI Stock"

Re:Microsoft says 8.5M Windows devices were affected by Crow... by hipadev23 on Saturday July 20, 2024 @07:10PM (#41020891)
Crowdstrike doesn’t make anything secure. It’s the same smoke and mirrors bullshit they were selling in the early 00’s via Norton or McAfee. It slows down machines in the best case and periodically renders them inoperable.
Re:Microsoft says 8.5M Windows devices were affected by Crow... by gruez on Saturday July 20, 2024 @07:23PM (#41020982)
>Crowdstrike doesn’t make anything secure.

It's not security pixie dust, and might introduce more security vulnerabilities itself, but it's probably pretty good at preventing Alice from accounting from running a random macro-enabled excel file with a malicious payload.