If a person sold a house bought pre-bubble during the bubble, the wealth was very muched possessed. If a person invested money in real estate during the bubble, they very much lost wealth. Likewise, if their 401k took a hit when the stock market dove, or they cashed out their retirement savings when they lost their job, the wealth lost wasn't on paper, but very much real.
Yes, some people's gains and losses were on paper, but for others, the losses were jobs, homes, and savings.
The bubble said everyones houses were worth 20 gazillion dollars. One person is persuaded to sell thier house for 10 million dollars, another borrows 10 m to buy it.
The seller is very happy, The borrower is obligied to repay and the bank borrowed 8 m in someone elses cash and invented theremaining 2.
Is there an economist who could tell me what that 2 m that gets created by bank lending actually does to inflation ?
Where do you get this concept of the bank inventing 2 million? Shirly that's just wrong.
the figures I quoted are just examples, but money creation trhu bank lending is real, and I just wonder if derivatives / banking crisis is enabling less or more of it outside the traditional measures.
It was a thought without much supportive thinking
But debt is an asset to everyone but the debtor.
You can technically bid a stock to trillions in dollar worth (say Cisco goes to $25 trillion during the dotcom bubble), but you'll never be able to actually realize even a fraction of that value. And if you can't mathematically ever realize that value through a sale, then it is not actual.
This is one thing that definitely rings true to me. I grew up in a wealthy community that abutted many, many poorer ones. I would often ride my bike through all of these places, especially the most impoverished ones and lament to myself "So this is the richest country in the world?"
Later, after I graduated college and started looking for places to live it was amazing to me how much wealth was caught up in places I don't think I'd ever want to live. Nearly identical tract housing for 10s of miles in all directions. Nothing walkable at all, even sidewalks were just an afterthought. "So, is this is what wealth looks like?" I thought to myself. Obviously it wasn't wealth. That money never existed, but the debt people signed contracts for is real.
My dad always refused. He ran a medium sized manufacturing business (about 100 employees) and is certainly in the top 5%, but not the 1% of people in the country in terms of income.
His rational at the time for not buying the house was very simple: "There aren't that many people in this country that can afford a house this expensive. It just doesn't add up to me. I know that most people don't make what I make, and if it's a struggle for me to do it rationally, something is wrong here".
They didn't buy the house, but we all thought he was being too pride bound at the time.
Now they're looking at what used to be 1.5 million dollar places that are going for $550-$600k. Meanwhile our house in New Jersey dropped in price roughly $100k because the bubble economics didn't take hold here as much.
The bubble was absolutely crazy. At the end of the day there were a lot of people buying houses that they could only afford assuming the value of the house increased signifcantly before they sold them. Essentially they could only pay the carrying costs - and that was before the jobs market tanked.
The problem with complex macroeconomics and popular politics summarized in one phrase.
So no, unelected elites aren't going to save us either.
As soon as the idea of some sort of federal level reform got going the House Of Morgan and friends seized control and the Fed became a tool of the major banks, which were already working fine, to increase their profits and control. Almost from the start it was the case the Federal Reserve Bank of New York really ran the system, which was entirely not the original idea. The idea of the Fed originated from a temporary problem unique to a particular period of American history, but was immediately usurped by clever power and money hungry people.
Its a very very real question, though the consensus that democracy is the best thing we've got has been building for centuries.
"Elites" have pushed most idiotic economic and foreign policy initiatives against the popular will. Americans have generally had to be tricked by lies and expensive PR campaigns into supporting wars, for example. Their initial judgments were sound.
Though you may be interested in reading the essay, "The Problem of Scarcity".
My parents neighborhood is now about 20% uninhabited, because of bank foreclosures. My parents are $70k+ in the hole on their house, purchased during the peak of the boom, and it would never cross their minds to default on a debt. $70k is a pretty devastating economic hit to a middle class couple, now living on savings and Social Security.
It's easy for folks not impacted by the economic meltdown (like those of us in the tech industry) to make light of the very real pain a lot of lower income and middle class home owners are going through right now. But, the reality is that people are being screwed left and right by the very banks that caused the crisis.
http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2010-10-08/man-who-had-no-mort...
http://www.tampabay.com/news/business/realestate/bank-of-ame...
http://articles.sun-sentinel.com/2010-09-23/business/fl-wron...
http://online.wsj.com/article/SB1000142405297020379190457660...
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/02/16/illegal-foreclosure...
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2010/12/08/foreclosure-mistake...
http://abcnews.go.com/WN/robo-signers-blamed-foreclosure-mis...
http://seattletimes.nwsource.com/html/realestate/2015541624_...
This isn't isolated, it is a systemic problem in the banking industry right now, created by reckless (and illegal) business practices on the part of the major banks and mortgage companies.
Losing bubble wealth is bad enough (the psychological impact alone), losing it when you've stacked debt against it is a very real problem. The fake wealth was used to create very real debt. Suddenly you've got 1/3 of all home owners under water on their mortgages.