What I'd like to see is a 100% exemption from inheritance taxes for productive land and property (family owned businesses, business assets, office space for family or individually owned business and land contained thereon, farmland, etc), and a tax on income derived from renting out land and housing (this is designed to make it harder to make money from buying up housing to rent, and thus tilting the balance towards home ownership rather than renting). It would also help tilt the balance from corporate ownership to individual ownership of productive assets.
Good point, didn't think of that.
That's the problem with many policies and tax schemes. Their goal is not to make us better off but to manipulate or enforce someone's vision of fairness, often just thinly disguised envy.
Which in turn leads to all kinds of exceptions for politicians' pet projects, tax breaks for selected industries and just plain corruption.
Also, inflation is a wealth tax only on those whose wealth is in dollars.
I think it's almost certain that the effect of trying to impose a 100% inheritance tax would be that the rich-and-dishonest would find ways to get around most of it, and the poor-and-honest would get screwed even worse than they already do.
On the other hand, someone inheriting $10b can do more than just live a life of leisure: that kind of multi-generational concentration of wealth significantly changes societies, producing quasi-aristocratic families that have oversized influence, and really damaging any sort of pretense to an egalitarian society with a level playing field (something Thomas Jefferson, for example, was very worried about).
So imo inheritance taxes should be mostly aimed at very large fortunes and trusts, stuff in the $100m+ range, not $5m inheritances. Other benefits are that a large exemption would avoid causing problems for inheritance of family businesses, and greatly reduce the number of people affected (which in turn should reduce administrative expenses).
Beyond the issue of privileging corporations, a 100% inheritance tax leads to a bunch of strange behavior (with trusts, etc.), and doesn't handle well the possibility of people living a very, very long time.
By taxing wealth at 2% yearly, in combination with inflation, irresponsible/prodigal children will soon be out of money if they don't create value with their assets.
Furthermore, by using inflation as the "wealth tax", people are motivated to put their money into assets that match inflation (e.g. real estate) without necessarily making productive use of those assets.
Inheritance tax should be 100%. Why should a person be rich just because their parents were rich? What about the people without rich parents?
How about:
The only taxes are:
1) VAT X%
2) 100% inheritance tax.
3) No capital or dividend tax.
4) A "basic salary" of a fixed X dollars to every individual.
5) Inflation of 1-3% a year via increase in monetary supply. (This is the wealth tax).
1. X depends on how much energy consumed for product/service; this is the carbon tax.
2. If you don't want to give all your money to the government when you die - just donate it to a charity not related to any of your relatives. Your children will not be left with nothing. See 4.
3. Encourages people to work and save for passive income for a better than minimum living conditions, as there will not always be jobs available.
4. The salary should be the bare minimum to live on. This takes care of social welfare. It'll be needed as technology increases and unskilled people have no ability to find jobs.