Don't see how Apple makes more money is a good thing - it means millions of their clients have less money left.
I don't think $200 is justified nor do I want to defend Apple... but where do you get 8GB with 100 GB/s bandwidth for $10?
Regardless, I'd want Apple to have two additional LPDDR5 slots. The system could swap there or have a tiered memory.
And again as a reminder, we agree that Apple's RAM pricing is ridiculous.
I showed that a company can buy those chips, put them on boards, package them, ship them in tiny quantities, market them, and support them for a total cost of $20.
How much do you think those things cost? They all need to be subtracted from the $20, and also Apple can probably get a better wholesale deal than the brand I was looking at.
I'm not saying $10 is definitely right, but I think it's a pretty good guess.
So there's something they're doing pretty differently.
That said 8->16 GB should be more like $50, not $200.
They do use LPDDR5, which was harder for me to find a price on, but so do lots of other laptops, and I don't know if it's more or less expensive than DDR5.
With DDR5 I'd say more like 2.4x. And it should be made clear that that's mostly by virtue of fitting the equivalent of four memory channels on the Pro models. The non-Pro models don't see a very big boost.
In that context, CAMM stays exciting, because if you design a CPU to support two LPCAMM2 modules you can get 200+GB/s on upgradable memory. Though in a laptop form factor it would be hard to double that again to compete with a Max chip.
"According to Intel, this move will make the RAM use up to 40 percent less power."
On top of the performance gains integrated RAM uses less power.
On top of these two things, Intel has better margins if they sell the RAM.
And while it's not as fast as GPU memory, you can easily have more memory for AI in an unified memory model (64gb e.g.) - or rumored 128gb for Strix Halo.
See how Mx is faster, uses less power, is better for AI, and Apple makes more money?